何其生戴吟 : 模拟国际商事仲裁比赛与学生法律技能的提升 Vis Vis Vis 2 Willem C. Vis Willem C. Vis Vis

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "何其生戴吟 : 模拟国际商事仲裁比赛与学生法律技能的提升 Vis Vis Vis 2 Willem C. Vis Willem C. Vis Vis"

诚麴
5 years ago
Views:

1 河南财经政法大学学报 2014 年第 1 期 ( 总第 141 期 ) 1 何其生戴 2 吟在众多的国际法律竞赛中,Williem C. Vis 模拟国际商事仲裁辩论赛是规模最大的国际法赛事, 它也是一项以教学为实质以竞赛为包装的法学教育活动它能够提升参赛学生的庭辩技巧外语水平和团体合作能力学生能够在文书写作中提高分析问题和解决问题的能力通过对国际商事仲裁庭的模拟训练, 学生能够将国际法尤其是国际贸易法国际商事仲裁法国际惯例外国的案例法以及中国的法律和案例结合运用该项赛事有利于深化中国学生运用英语研究国际性法律问题的意识, 培养具有理论素养和实践能力的国际法律人才 Vis 辩论赛 ; 国际商事仲裁 ; 法律职业技能 ; 庭辩技巧 D A Willem C. Vis Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot Vis Vis Vis Vis United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods CISG 1 CISG Vis CISG *

2 何其生戴吟 : 模拟国际商事仲裁比赛与学生法律技能的提升 Vis Vis Vis 2 Willem C. Vis Willem C. Vis Vis

3 河南财经政法大学学报 2014 年第 1 期 Vis Westlaw Lexis Heonline Kluwer Nigel Blackaby et al Redfern and Hunter on International Arbitration 5 th ed. Oxford University Press Gary Born International Commercial Arbitration 3 rd ed. Kluwer Law International Gary Born International Arbitration Cases and Materials Wolters Kluwer Julian D. M. Lew et al Comparative International Commercial Arbitration Kluwer Law International Klaus Peter Berger Private Dispute Resolution in International Business Negotiation Mediation Arbitration Vol. II Kluwer Law International John O. Honnold Uniform Law for International Sales Under the 1980 United Nations Convention 3 rd ed. Kluwer Law International Peter Schlechtriem Commentary on the UN Convention on the International Sale of Goods 2 nd ed. Oxford University Press Michael Bridge The International Sale of Goods Law and Practice 2 nd ed. Oxford University Press Ingeborg Schwenzer Commentary on the UN Convention on the International Sale of Goods 3 rd ed. Oxford University Press James Fawcett at el Cheshire North & Private International Law 14 th ed. Oxford University Press Lawrence Collins et al Dicey Morris and Collins on The Conflict of Laws 14 th ed. Sweet & Maxwell Richard C. Wydick Plain English for Lawyers 5th ed Lief Carter Reason in Law 8 th ed Linda H. Edwards Legal Writing and Analysis 2 nd ed. Wolters Kluwer Charles R. Calleros Legal Method and Writing 2 nd ed Little Brown and Company

4 何其生戴吟 : 模拟国际商事仲裁比赛与学生法律技能的提升 Vis Vis MacCrate Vis ( 一 ) 庭辩技巧与沟通能力 Vis 5 1. Vis 155

5 河南财经政法大学学报 2014 年第 1 期 Vis Vis Vis 7 3. Vis Vis 1 Vis 79 CISG CISG CISG 4. CISG Vis See Black s Law Dictionary 60 8 th ed 2004 Merriam Webster s Collegiate Dictionary th ed 1993.

6 何其生戴吟 : 模拟国际商事仲裁比赛与学生法律技能的提升 - 5. Vis 1 2 ( 二 ) 理解国际贸易法与仲裁 1. CISG 2. 3 Vis Vis Vis Vis Vis 1 See The 2007 Philip C. Jessup International Law Moot Court Competition Official Rules 2007 hereafter Jessup Rules Rule 2. 2 http / /www. ilsa. org /jessup /jessup07 /rules. htm visited on May Vis Vis Rules See Blase F. A Brief SWOT - Analysis of the Willem C. Vis Moot 5 The Vindobona Journal of International Commercial Law and Arbitration Dickerson D. In the Moot Court 29 Stetson L. Rev Vis See Kenety W. H. Observations on Teaching Appellate Advocacy 45 J. Legal Educ

7 河南财经政法大学学报 2014 年第 1 期 1 Vis Vis 2 3 ( 一 ) 一对一辅导围绕比赛来设立课程 Vis Vis Vis Vis Vis 7 1 See Vis Rules See Vis Rules See Vis Rules % 28% 18% Toronto College Law Center Jack M. Grave Stetson University College of Law Tampa Law Center Stephanie A. Vaughan Eric E. Bergsten % 2006 See Jack M. Graves & Stephanie A. Vaughan The Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot Making the most of an extraordinary Education Opportunity 10 2 The Vindobona Journal of International Commercial Law and Arbitration E. g. Research & Writing Trial Advocacy Interviewing Counseling & Negotiation Advocacy /Practice

8 何其生戴吟 : 模拟国际商事仲裁比赛与学生法律技能的提升 /3 2 1 /4 3 4 Vis CISG 5 Vis ( 二 ) 鼓励热身赛在热身赛中学习庭辩技巧 % 78% 41% 74% 17% 89% 13 Vis ( 三 ) 教学性与竞争性相结合在竞争中学习 Vis Vis 6 7 Vis % 72% % 56% % 44% % 67% See Scherk v Alberto-Culver Co. 417 US See Vis Rules See Waincymer J. International and Comparative Legal Education Through the Willem C. Vis Moot Program A Personal Reflection 2 5 The Vindobona Journal of International Commercial Law and Arbitration

9 河南财经政法大学学报 2014 年第 1 期 Vis Vis Vis [1] 何其生, 范晓亮. 法学教育视野下的 Willem C. Vis 模拟国际商事仲裁辩论赛 [J]. 时代法学,2012, ( 4) : 113. [2]See Boyle R. & Dunn R.,Teaching Law Students Through Individual Learning Styles,62 Alb. L. Rev. 213 ( 1998). [3]See MacCrate Report: An Educational Continuum Report of the Task Force on Law Schools and the Profession: Narrowing the Gap,1992 ABA. SEC. LEAP,available at http: / / www. abanet. org / legaled / publication / onlinepubs / maccrate. html,visited on September 15,2013. [4]See Waincymer,J.,International and Comparative Legal Education Through the Willem C. Vis Moot Program: A Personal Reflection,2( 5) The Vindobona Journal of International Commercial Law and Arbitration 251( 2001). [5]See Rule of the Thirteenth Annual Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot Rules ( 2006),available at http: / / www. cisg. law. pace. edu / cisg / moot / rules13. pdf. Hereinafter Vis Rules. [6]See Waincymer,J.,International and Comparative Legal Education Through the Willem C. Vis Moot Program: A Personal Reflection,2( 5) The Vindobona Journal of International Commercial Law and Arbitration 251( 2001). [7]See the Thirteenth Annual Willem C. Vis International Arbitration Moot ,available at http: / / www. cisg. law. pace. edu / cisg / moot / awards13. html,visited on May 13,2013. [8]See Cooper B. D.,The Integration of Theory,Doctrine,and Practice in Legal Education,51 J. Ass N. Legal Writing Directors 58-60( 2002). [9]See Smith M. R.,Alternative Substantive Approaches to Advanced Legal Writing Courses,54 J. Legal Educ. 119,120( 2004). [10]See Stipanowich,T. J.,Contract and Conflict Management,3 Wis. L. Rev. 831( 2001). [11]See Greenberg,S. N.,Appellate Advocacy Competitions: Let s Loosen Some Restrictions on Faculty As- 160

10 何其生戴吟 : 模拟国际商事仲裁比赛与学生法律技能的提升 sistance,49 J. Legal. Educ. 545,546( 1999). [12]See Jessup Rules,Rule [13]Greenberg,S. N.,Appellate Advocacy Competitions: Let s Loosen Some Restrictions on Faculty Assistance,49 J. Legal. Educ. 545,546( 1999). [14]See Jack M. Graves & Stephanie A. Vaughan,The Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot: Making the most of an extraordinary Education Opportunity,10( 2) The Vindobona Journal of International Commercial Law and Arbitration 173( 2006). International Commercial Arbitration Moot and Improvement in Students Legal Skills He Qisheng 1 Dai Yin 1 1. Law School Wuhan University Wuhan Hubei Shanghai Representative Office of Keller and Heckman LLP Shanghai Abstract Among numerous international legal competitions Williem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot is the largest international event. The moot is also a legal teaching program that combines teaching and competition. Through the moot students can improve their advocacy English and team work and they can enhance their abilities to analyze and resolve issues. Through the moot training students can learn more knowledge of international law especially international trade law international commercial arbitration international practices foreign case laws Chinese laws and cases. The moot will be useful for students to increase the consciousness that uses English to conduct legal research in China. The program is helpful to educate international legal talents who possess theoretical attainment and highly practical ability. Key words Vis Moot international commercial arbitration legal skills advocacy 161

法律教育及培训常设委员会周年报告 2013

法律教育及培训常设委员会周年报告 2013 法律教育及培训常设委员会二零一三年周年报告二零一三年一月一日至二零一三年十二月三十一日目录周年报告 1 附件 1 : 法律执业者条例第 74A 条 5 附件 2 : 法律教育及培训常设委员会成员 8 附件 3 : 香港城市大学法学士课程报