71 ( ),,, :,, ;,,,,, :, ;,,,,, :,,,, ;,,,,,,, :, 2002, 250, [ ], ( ), 2005, 486 [ ], ( ), 2005, 487 See A lbert Van den Berg, the New York Convention

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "71 ( ),,, :,, ;,,,,, :, ;,,,,, :,,,, ;,,,,,,, :, 2002, 250, [ ], ( ), 2005, 486 [ ], ( ), 2005, 487 See A lbert Van den Berg, the New York Convention"

倪芳郁
5 years ago
Views:

1 70 ( 63 ) 3,,,,,,,,, ; ; ; 3,

2 71 ( ),,, :,, ;,,,,, :, ;,,,,, :,,,, ;,,,,,,, :, 2002, 250, [ ], ( ), 2005, 486 [ ], ( ), 2005, 487 See A lbert Van den Berg, the New York Convention of 1958, Kluwer Law International Publishers, 1981, p1311

3 72 ( 63 ),,,,,,,, :,,,,,,, :,,,,,,,,,,,, :, ; :,, ; :,, :, , 374 :, , 374 :, 2002, 248

4 73 : 5 1,,, may (may), ( shall),,, may, shall,, may,, 5 1,,, ( ) A rticle V 11Recognition and enforcement of the award may be refused at the request of the party against whom it is invoked, only if that party furnished to the competent authority where the recognition and enforcement is sought, proof that ( a) ( e) The award has been set aside or suspended by a competent authority of the country in which, or under the law of which, that award was made1,,, : ( 5) [ ], ( ), 2005, 487 :, , 362 See Georgios Petrochios, Procedure Law in International A rbitration, Oxford University Press, 2003, p13011 :, 2002, 239 Georgios Petrochios, Procedure Law in International A rbitration, Oxford University Press, 2003, pp

5 74 ( 63 ) 31,,, 5 1 : : Recognition and enforcement of the award may be refused only, may,,, may, only,,, may,, only,,, 5,, 5,, may only, :,,,,,,,,,,, may, 7 1, 5 See Georgios Petrochios, Procedure Law in International A rbitration, Oxford University Press, 2003, p13011 [ ], ( ), 2005, 487

6 75,, 7 1 5,?, : 5 1, 7 1,,,,,,,, 31,,,,,,,, ( ),, 32, 31,,, 939 F1Supp1907 (DDC 1996) 1 [ ], ( ), 2005, 470 :, 2000, 255

7 76 ( 63 ), 5, ( ICC) ( 4 ) shall,, 4 shall may, shall,, 5 may shall,,,, 1 may, shall,,, ( seront refus es),,, may shall, 1959,,,,,,,, See ICC, Enforcement of International A rbitral Awards ( Publication NO 174, 1953) : Prelim inary D raft Convention, A rticle IV1 See D raft Convention, UN Doc E /2704 ( 1955), A rticle IV1 See UN Doc E /CONF126 /L134 ( 28 May 1958) 1 See UN Doc E /CONF126 /L140 (2 June 1958) 1 :, 2002, 244 Quote from van den Berg, International A rbitration in 21 st Century, Netherland International Law Review Vol1133, 1992, p11611

8 77 ( ) La reconnaissance et l ex cutio1 1 1ne seront refus es1 1 1que si ,, seront refus es,,, can be may be,,,, 33 :,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :, 2002, 255

9 78 ( 63 ) :,,,, ( ), 1502 : : ; ; ; ;, 5 1,,,,, Polish Ocean L ine, Unichp sv 1v 1 Gesnouin, H ilmarton, (H ilmarton) (H ilmarton L td1 v1o1t1v1) v1 O1T1V1,,,,,,, O1T1V1 : Cass Civ lre, 10 March 1993, ( 1993) 120 JD I 3601 Paris, 12 February 1993, [ 1993 ] Rev A rb 2551 H ilmarton L td1 v1o1t1v1, 1997, Fouchard, Rev A rb, pp

10 79 ;, ;,,,,,,,,,,,, (Van den Berg) :,,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,, :, 2002, 217 Quote from Christopher R1 D rahozal, Enforcing Vacated International A rbitration Awards: An Econom ic Approach, American Review of International A rbitration, Vol134, 2000, p14621 See Georgios Petrochios, Procedure Law in International A rbitration, Oxford University Press, 2003, p See, eg, Besson&Pittet, Bull ASA ( 1998) 16, p15101

11 80 ( 63 ), ( ) 1998,, ( Chromalloy Aeroservices v1 Egyp t),,,, ;,, 5, may, may,,,,,, :,,, : ( p ick and choose policy),, (Baker Marine (N ig1) L td1 v1 Chevron (N ig1) L td),, 939 F1Supp1907 (DDC 1996) 1 :, 2002, F1 3d 194 (2d cir1 1999) 1

12 81, may,, :, ( Sp ier v1 Calzaturificio Tecnica),,,,,,,, ( ) :,,,,, :,,, ;,,, 71 F1 supp1 2d 279 ( S1 D1 N1 Y1 1999).

13 82 ( 63 ) 5 1,,,,, 2003 ( ), 36 :,, :,,,, 31,,,,,,,,,, ( ),,, :, 2002, 110

14 83, :,,,,,,,, ( ), : 11,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :,, , 107 See J1 Paulson, A rbitration Unbound: Award Detached from the Law of its Country of O rigin, International and Comparative Law Quarterly, Vol130, 1981, p3651

15 84 ( 63 ),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ;,,,,, 21 :,, :,, , 108 :, See Georgios Petrochios, Procedure Law in International A rbitration, Oxford University Press, 2003, pp

16 85,,,,,, ;,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :,,,,? ( ),, :,,,, :, , 372

17 86 ( 63 ),,,,,,,,,,,, ;,,,,,,,,,,,, ;,,,,,,,, S1E1E1E1v1 Yugoslavia, 1956, 1986,,, :,, , 108 :, 1999, 248

18 87,,,, :,, W TO : ( ) 1993, ( ) , ( ) ( ),, ( ),, :, :,,, ;,,,, ,,,,,,,, ;,, :, , 69-71

19 88 ( 63 ),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ( ),,,,,,, 5 (1),,, :, , 76

20 89,,,,,,,, :,, ( curial law),,,,,, ;,,,, ( ),,,, :, 1025:,,,,

21 90 ( 63 ),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ( ),, : 11,,,, : ; ;, :, 2002, 96 :, , 362,,,,,,,

22 91,,,,, 21,, 1494 : ;, 5 1 5,,,,,,,,, 31,,, 182 :,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

23 92 ( 63 ),, :,,,,,,, 1 2 :,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :, , 362,,,

24 93,,, D iagnosia Inc1v1Gradipore,,,,,,,,,,,, ( ),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :,,, :,, Quote from R ichard Garnett, International arbitration but Subject to National Law: the Rejection of Delocalization in Australia, Australia Business Review, Vol1 281, 2000, No15, pp ,

25 94 ( 63 ),,,,, ( ),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 1965 ( ),,,, :,, , 73-74, :, 2000, 25 :, 2000, 25

26 95 ( ),,,,,, :,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ( ),,, 14 1 :,,,,, :, 1998,

27 96 ( 63 ),,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, Kajo v1 Radenska,, :, 1999, 246 See Andreas Reiner, Some Recent Austrian Court Decisions in the Field of A rbitration, Journal of International A rbitration, Vol117, 2000, p1851

28 97,,, ( ),,,,,,,, 1955, 30 ;,,,,,,,,, 5 1,,,,, 1956,, 1986,, ;,,, ;,, :,, , 105

29 98 ( 63 ),,,?, 5,, ;,,,,,,,,,,, :, 1999, 220

1927 double exequatur primary jurisdiction 1 secondary jurisdiction shall final 2 ICSID ICSID ICSID ICSID ad hoc tribunal ICSID Dallah

1927 double exequatur primary jurisdiction 1 secondary jurisdiction shall final 2 ICSID ICSID ICSID ICSID ad hoc tribunal ICSID Dallah 2017 1 39 1 Modern Law Science Jan. 2017 Vol. 39 No. 1 1001-2397 2017 01-0156 - 14 100720 Hilmarton Putrabali DF974 A DOI 10. 3969 /j. issn. 1001-2397. 2017. 01. 12 1 1 2015 90% 2015 International Arbitrition