: ,551, 760 ; :,25 % 5 7,: :, , ,,,,,,,, :,,,, 10 :, 11 Rodell 1936,,Rodell 5 :,,,,,

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download ": ,551, 760 ; :,25 % 5 7,: :, , ,,,,,,,, :,,,, 10 :, 11 Rodell 1936,,Rodell 5 :,,,,,"

握范
7 years ago
Views:

1 : Ξ 1887,J1Mc Kelvey 3 ( : ) :,, 110, : ,800,5000 ; (AAL S) 153,, 9 2,,: ( The Journal of Legal Studies) ( The Journal of Legal Education),187,,,1991, 20, 3,,,,2 3,,, : :, ;,,,,, : 4,,,,, 5 Ξ, 1996,, William Alford 95 J1D1 Ben libermen ;1997 3,,, 1,,1,35, (1 Harv1 L1 Rev. 35), Leo P1 Martinez, ( Babies, Bathwater, and Law Reviews),,47,1145 (47 Stan1 L1Rev11145), , :,1991 Institute for Scientific Information,Social Sciences Citation In2 dex :Journal Citation Reports, Erwin N1Griswold, ( The Harvard Law Review - Glimpses of Its History as Seen by an Aflcionado),,100,15,56 (100 Harvard Law Review15,note 56), ,,,, :,: Richard A1Posner,,, ( Goodbye to the Bluebook),,53,1343 (53 U1Chi1L1Rev11350),

2 : ,551, 760 ; :,25 % 5 7,: :, , ,,,,,,,, :,,,, 10 :, 11 Rodell 1936,,Rodell 5 :,,,,, , 4 :, :, ( ),,,,, 6 Sirico & Marguilies,( The Citing of Law Reviews by the Supreme Court :An Empirical Study),,34,144 (34 UCLA L1REV1144), ,5 : 8 [ 6 ], Louis J1 Sirico,( The Citing of Law Reviews By The United States Courts of Appeals : An Empirical Analysis),,45,1051 (45 U1MIAMI L1REV11051),1991, :, ;,,,,,;, 10Fred Rodell, Goodbye to Law Reviews (, ),,23,38 (23 Va1 L1Rev138),1936,, ;James Lindgren, An Author s Manifesto (),,61,527, (61 U1Chi1L1Rev1527,537-38),1994 :,,,,, ;Janes Lindgren,Fear of Writing( ),78 Cal L1Rev11677 (1990), ;Richard A1Posner,,, ( Goodbye to the Bluebook),,53,1343 (53 U1Chi1L1Rev11343), 1986,, ;Richard A1Posner, ( The Future of the Stu2 dent - Edited Law Review),,47,1131 (47 Stan1L1Rev11131),1995 : 11John T1 Noonan,J r1, (Law Reviews),,47,1117 (47 Stan1 L1Rev11117),1995 ; Erwin N1 Griswold,[ 4 ] 12Richard A1Posner, ( The Future of the Student Edited Law Review),,47, ( 47 Stan1 L1Rev ),

3 13, 100,GRISWOLD :,,,,,,? 14,,,???? 1996,,40,, (),, 1902, ( : ),,,,,, 2,, 200,,, 15 (), , ,,, 1969,: 70 %,30 %, 84,,,42 ( J. D. ) 5 6 8, , 212 ( ),42 13Max Stier, Kelly M1 Klaus, Dan L1 Bagatell,Jeffrey J1Rachlinski, : (LAW REVIEW USAGE AND SU GGESTIONS FOR IMPROVEMEN T : A SURVEY OF ATTORNEYS, PROFESSORS, AND J UDGES),,44,1467 (44 STAN1L1REV11467),1992, 1162, 380, 3217 %,,: 3217 %,,, : [ 12 ],Richard A1Posner,113, 5 14Erwin N1Griswold,[ 4 ],20 15:Constitution and By - Laws of the Harvard Law Review Association () 16, 200,3 60, 6 171

4 :, ,,500,,,,,,, 70 %, 30 %,,,,:,,,;,,, ;,,,,,,,,,,,, , WASP(), 3 ;1955, 18 60,:,,,,,, (affirmative action),1982 : 3 8, 3 19 :, 20 :,3,, 21,, , 15 14, 1650 J. D. () (orgnization) 17: ,,1914 Adolf Augustus Berle,,,, ;,1954, Lubell 5,, 16 8,Lubell 1978,91 Lubell, : Erwin N1Griswold, [ 4 ], ,,,, 20Richard A1Posner, [ 12 ],1132, 4 21Michelle A1Jones, (Law Review Gender Task Force Stalled),( Harvard Law Record), Oct. 11,1996,pp11,3. 172

5 : :, DAV ID PAN TON :,, :6,, (primary editor) :5,, :6,,,, :7,(note) (article), : ,,,5 : (108) (109) (105) (106) (SU PREUM COURT OFFICE) :6, 11,25, 3,3, ;3 18 (NO TE), 3, 18,,:,,,,GANN ET, 19, 22 11, 7, 1000, 8 11, 22 : (1) ; (2) The Greenbook :Manual of Operation and Procedure (: ) 173

6 : () ,,, 1 5,,,2 (preemption check), 1, 1,,,, (office read),,,,,,, (), (cite check),2,, ( P - READ), ; 2 : (: ),,,,, :, :,,, 23 (),,,,,,,,,, 23,,61 174

7 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :,,,,,,,,,, :,, 24 ()? :,,,:,?, 25,,: (1), ; (2),, ; (3),, :,,, ;,, 26, : ;,, 24, :,, 1 AMES,,, GRISWOLD ([ 4 ]) 50, :25,27, 19, 12, 51, 34, 25Jordan H1Leibman & James P1White, ( How the Student Edited Law Journals Make Their Publication Decisions),,39,420 (39J1Legal Educ1420), Richard A1Posner,[ 12 ],

8 ,;,, : 27,,, 28,,,, 1991,, : % 8912 % 8510 % 6317 % 8715 % 7515 % :,, ;,;, 30 ()?,, ;,,,,, ;, 31, :,,,;,,, 32,,,,,,,,, 33 () David Wilkins , :,10 27 [ 25 ],418 28Elyce H1Zenoff,,,I Have Seen the Enemy and They Are Us,,36,23 (36 J1Legal Educ123), [ 13 ], Kenneth Lasson,:,Scholarship Amok : Excesses in the Pursuit of Truth and Tenure,,103,927 (103 Harv1L1Rev1927), Harry T. Edwards,, The Growing Disjunction Between Legal Education and the Legal Profes2 sion,,91,34 (91 Mich1L1Rev134), Leo P1Martinez,[ 2 ],

9 ,,, ,2 20,3 15, DAN ISE DOSSEN,?:, 35,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 36,,,,,, 30,,5-6,,,100 ;,,,,,,,,, : :,,,,,,, 22, :,,,,, ;,, David Wilkins David Wilkins 93, Danies Dossen Danies Dossen 36Alfred F1Conard,(A LOVABL E LAW REVIEW), 44,4 (44 J 1L EGAL, EDUC 4),

10 ,;,,,,,, 37,: (, ), ;, ; 38 :,,,,,, 39,, 40,,Noonan :,,, 41,,,,,, 42 () , 1925,,, , 16,Rodell, :,,,,, 43,, :,,,, , BEN L IBERMAN 38[ 13 ], Scott M 1Martin,:( The Law Review Citadel : Rodell Revisited),,71, 1103 (71 IOWA L1REV11103), Joel Seligman,: ( The High Citadel : The Influence of Harvard Law School),176-85, John T1Noonan, J r.,[ 11 ], Tom Wolfe, The Right Stuff (1979),:Leo P1Martinez,,Babies,Bathwater,and Law Reviews,,47,1142 (47 Stan1L1Rev1 1142), Fred Rodell,, ( Goodbye to Law reviews),,23,38,41 (23 VA1L1REV138,41),

11 44,, 1986 ( The University of Chicago Manual of Legal Citation),,,, 45, :, ;, ;,,,,;,, 46 Goldberg :, 47 Conard : Anglo - American,,,, 48,Austin,,,,,, 49 11,, ;,,, 50, :, 51,,,,,,,,, 44, , , Arthur J1Goldberg, ( The Rise and Fall ( We Hope) of Footnotes),, 69, 255 ( 69 A1B1A1J1255), [ 35 ] 49Arthur D1 Austin,( Footnotes as Product Differentiation),, 40, 1153 ( 40 VAND1L1REV11153), Robert Weisberg,(Some Ways to Think about Law Reviews),,47,1149 (47 Stan1L1Rev11149), (Richard Reeves), (American Journy),, (1992),

12 ,, (),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, Martinez,Rodell (30, [ 43 ]), 52 () :,,,, :, :, ( ), ;, (,,),,,,,,,,,,,:,,:, Leo P. Martinez,,Babies,Bathwater,and Law Reviews,,47 (47Stan. L. Rev. ),1995

13 ,,,, ;,,,,,,,, ()? :,,:, :,1 (,, 5 ) ;, 2 (,, 5 ),, ( : ),,,, ;,,,,, Q,,,,,,,,,,,:,,,,,,,,,?,, 181

2

2 3 314 1 2 1 437-466 2 94 4 J 1 JFK Holiday Inn RDU 5 Duke Chapel 1925 73 1,470 Perkins library Emerson Niou 6 chronicle uncle B uncle B uncle B uncle B Brevard Brown 7 uncle B uncle B uncle B uncle B