2001 7
Kirkpatrick Four Level Evaluation Model
68 41
Kirkpatrick Kirkpatrick Kirkpatrick Kirkpatric
Goldstein Parry
1
2
3
4
5
Training 6
Campbell DunnetteLawlerWeick Vocational Training 7
Evaluation evaluation is to determine the value or worth of something Fisher et al R. E. Stak Stufflebeam R. W. Tyle 8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17 Systems Model Goldstein Parry Goldstein Goldstei Goldstein
Goldstein pp Goldstein Training in Organizations: Needs Assessment, Development, and Evaluation, Pacific Grove, CA :Brooks-Cole Publishing Co. pp. Parry Parry Parry Parry 18
Parry Parry Evaluating the Impact of Training : A Collection of tools and Techniques, American Society for Training & Development, pp. AMA, American Management Association 19
20 pp. AMA, American Management Association
GlodsteinParry Kirkpatrick Four Level Evaluation Model)Hamblin Five-Level Model Brinkerhoff Six-Stage ModelBushnell IPO Evaluation Mode Stufflebeam CIPP Context-Input-Process-Product 21
Kirkpatrick Kirkpatrick1959a, 1959b, 1960a, 1960b Techniques for Evaluation Programs reaction learning behavior results Kirkpatrick Faerman Ban Dessler Reaction Learning Behavior Results Kirkpatrick Kirkpatrick 22
23
Kirkpatrick right climate Newstrom Kirkpatrick Fisher et al 24
ISO pp. Fisher et al Alexandria Personnel Administrator, The Society for Resource Management Kirkpatrick 25
26
Hamblin Hamblin reaction learning job behavior organization impact ultimatevalue variables Brinkerhoff Brinkerhoff Kirkpatrick Brinkerhoff 27
Brinkerhoff An Integrated Evaluation Model for HRD. Training & Development, volume numbe pp. 28
Bushnell Bushnell EE Input stage E Process stage E E E E Output stage E Outcomes E Bushnell 29
Bushnell Input, Process, Output: a Model for Evaluation Training, Training & Development, volume number pp. Stufflebeam CIPP Stufflebeam Stufflebeam Shinkfield CIPP CIPP context input process product CIPP CIPP 30
IPO IPO CIPP IPO 31
Holcomb Interview Questionnaire Survey Observation Documents Simulations Action Plans 32 Dr. Charles R. Hopkins
33
34 Hibert, Preskill Russ-Eft Kirkpatrick Kirkpatrick
Kirkpatrick Clement Noe Schmitt Dixon Faerman Ban Warr Bunce 35
Kirkpatrick Clement Noe Shmitt Baldwin Magjuka Loher Job Involvement Psychological Attachment 36
Kirkpatrick Warr Bunce Rouillier Goldstein Mclinden Davis Sheriff Russ-Dfe Kirshna- -murthi Ravishan--k ar 37
Kirkpatrick Bernthal Byham pp Hilbert, Preskill Russ-Eft, Evaluation Training, What Assessment, Development, and Measurement, ASTD One way Analysis of Variance 38
Kirkpatrick 39
Factor Analysis Persons Product-Moment Correlation Analysis 40
Kirkpatrick 41
Descriptive Statistics Inferential Statistics 42
1. 2. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 1. 43
Parry Competency 44
45
46
47
structured questionnaire closed questionnaire open-ended questionnaire A 48
Likert R. A. Likert Likert Liker Kirkpatrick Parry 49
50 Competency
1 Parry Parry 51
pretest Likert-Type 52
Open-ended questionnaire Closed-ended questionnaire 53
SPSS for Windows Microsoft Excel Frequency Distribution Rates Mean Standard Deviation 54
55
2 3 56
69 145 31 65 57
49 37 8 6 58
10 90 59
2.19 60
53 47 61
18 31 48 3 14 13 22 27 17 20 20 13 62
41 86 59 124 8 10 5 8 17 22 16 13 4 63
5 64
33 30 7 7 1 13 2 7 65
44 35 10 8 2 66
55 35 4.23 0.66 10 1 0 51 3.96 24 23 0.80 2 0 67
47 32 3.61 0.82 12 9 0 15 56 24 3.81 0.77 4 1 68
16 55 25 3.8 0.78 4 1 54 13 28 3.72 0.83 4 1 69
56 3.81 0.83 26 15 2 1 47 35 3.62 0.80 11 6 1 70
9 36 41 3.35 0.97 11 4 36 39 3.28 0.97 7 14 4 71
22 59 17 3.99 0.84 1 1 12 55 28 4 3.74 0.75 1 72
73
74
62 22 13 4.03 0.73 3 0 14 51 30 3.73 0.82 4 1 75
11 37 45 3.50 0.90 7 0 10 44 38 3.56 0.90 6 1 76
12 49 21 3.53 1.00 15 3 28 55 13 4.05 0.79 3 1 77
14 40 28 3.49 1.08 14 3 12 41 26 3.41 1.07 16 5 78
79
80
13 10 51 82 81
30 38 26 6 3.9 0.93 1 82
9 21 34 33 32 42 48 48 63 73 83
3 19 5 25 27 13 15 52 46 49 59 64 84
12 13 28 32 47 61 74 85
45 41 11 4.29 0.83 1 1 48 40 4.34 0.8 10 2 0 86
41 40 11 4.13 0.93 7 1 43 51 4.36 0.62 6 0 0 87
39 50 4.27 0.69 9 1 0 43 49 4.33 0.68 6 2 0 88
41 50 4.31 0.73 9 1 0 51 43 4.44 0.83 5 1 0 89
41 50 4.26 0.94 6 2 1 90
6 91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
2000 112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
8 122
Employment Promotion Act for the Aged 123
Disadvantaged Group 124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
07-8210172 611 07-8118630 1... 2... 3... 4... 5... 6...... 7... 8... 9... 10 11 12 137
13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 22 22 23 A B C D E F G H I J 24 23 ABC. 25 A B C D E F G H I J K L 138
26 25 ABC. 27 A B C D E F G 28 27 ABC. 29 37 38 29.... 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 1 2 3 139
140
-- 07-8210172 611 07-8118630 1... 2... 3... 4... 5... 6... 7... 8... 9... 10 11 12 141
13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 22 23 22 23 24 A B C D E F G H I J 25 24 ABC. 26 A B 142
C D E F G H I J K L 27 26 ABC. 28 A B C D E F G 29 28 ABC. 29 37 38 30.... 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 1 2 143
3 144