2004 11 139 ~ 178 * 93.6.21 93.10.20 *
140 The Identity and Difference from the Comparison of Myth, Lao Tze and Chuang TzeToward To Modern New Taoism Lai, His-san * Abstract A comparison between myth, Lao Tze and Chuang Tze will achieve the following: first, to find the mythical origin for Taoism; second, to identify Taoism s critic inheritance of myth; and finally to develop a perfect paradigm of synthes for Taoism. This article argues that Chuang Tze s round teaching style will overcome the chaos-returning model of myth and Lao Tze. And by containing the dual possibilities of returning and opening, the round teaching can provide a philosophical model for what I call the Modern New Taoism. Keywords: MythTaoismChaosCreative mytheternal returnmodern New Taoism * Assistant professor, Department of Chinese & Literature, National Chung Cheng University.
141 * 1 Mircea Eliade archaic ontology * NSC-91-2411-H-260-007 1 20 1997 1-34
142 Joseph Campbell Bronislaw Malinowski Carl Jung Archetypes images of archetype collective unconciousness Levy Bruhl Ernst Cassirer C.G. Jung Erich Neumann (hierophany) Paul Ricoeur Thomas Khun paradigm 2 2 1991 165-190
143 3 4 N.J.Girardot 5 6 3 1997 101-149 7 1 223-251 4 34 2 2004 12 5 N.J.Girardot Myth and Meaning in Early Taism the theme of chaos(hun-tun) University of California Press1983 pp.88-90. 6 2000 87-145
144 R.E.Allison 7 8 7 R.E.AllisonChuang-Tzu For Spiritual TransformationUniversity of New York Press 1989pp.180 26-30 8 1999 363 ( 1988 ) 48 9 1994 107-159 1993 150-185 101-149
145 敍 10 11 12 13 14 10 109-110 11 (42 ) 1999 37 12 48 41 13 16 13 14
146 15 敍 16 15 1985 424 16 ( 1990 ) 11-15
147 mysticism primitive ritual repetition Analytcal Psychology 18 19 20 17 1998 18 19 1992 167-175 20
148 敍 敍 敍 131-132 21 ( ) 1995 39-40
149 22 敍 23 24 initiation 25 rites of passage 26 22 23 録 2003 1-39 24, 1996 79-90 25 1994 339-349 26 2002 176-185 66 2 1983 51-68
150 27 active imagination 28 29 30 敍 27 172 28 1999 495-502 29 2000 140-146 30 43-50
151 31 32 33 31 1997 32 1986 87-154 33 79
152 34 敍 34 1065-1099
153 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 35 309 36 246-247 37 79 38 424 39 741 40 390 41 733
154 ( ) 42 42 1993 143-152
155 43 44 45 46 47 48 (in itself) The Great Mother Erich Neumann 43 14 11 44 21 18 45 25 21 46 56 48 47 15 12 48 20 16
156 the uroboros 49 50 51 52 49 1998 3-62 50 2 1998 170-185 51 6 248-249 52 1982 55
157 嚣 53 54 55 53 1982 354 54 19 5 8 55 153-158
158 鳯 鳯 56 没 56 1999 45-47 1996
159 57 58 59 57 1997 127-150 58 87-97 1997 59 109-122
160 60 61 毁 62 毁 63 2000 3-68 60 1986 247 61 175-237 62 192 63 172-180
161 毁 64 64 24-37
162 65 犠 犠 犠 犠 65 22 20 27-28
163 66 67 66 28-30 67 38-39
164 剥 68 緑 69 68 1994 41-65 69 124-128
165 70 ( ) 71 (1) (2) (3) 70 252 71 : 1991 118-158 115-158
166 (4)
167 72 72 73 録
168 74 75 76 74 438 75 1098-1099 76 2-17
169 77 78 呑 闗 77 172-179 78 1990 46
170 79 80 81 79 272 80 606 81 172
171 82 83 82 17-20 83 69-71
172 84 85 86 Individuation 84 365 85 C. G. JungPsychology and Alchemy The Collected Works of C. G. JungVol.12 Princeton1983 p256p349p419p459470 86 193
173 87 87 Murray Stein 1999 223-254 186-277
174 (1) (2) (3) (4)
175 (5) 1 2 3 4 5 6 2 5 6 (6) 88 88 1999 37 136-143 2003 9
176 1993 1999 1991
177 1991 1994 1998 1986 1999 1997 2000 1994 1997 19 5 ( 1988 ) 1999 2003 1992 1982 1985 1996 37 2003 9 ( 1990 ) 1997 1994 1995 7 1
178 1996 2 1998 1997 1999 1986 2002 66 2 1983 1990 1999 1993 34 2 2004 12 1998 6 C. G. JungPsychology and Alchemy The Collected Works of C. G. JungVol.12Princeton1983 N. J. GirardotMyth and Meaning in Early Taismthe theme of chaos(hun-tun) University of California Press1983. R. E. AllisonChuang-Tzu For Spiritual TransformationUniversity of New York Press1989