1. 2. 3. 2010 4. * Lawrence J. Lau 2000 7 29 3
Comparative Studies 1 ( ) 2 3 1. 60 55 200 / 200 2000 4
200 200 200 2. 8 8 16 12 3. 4. 5. 16% 25 28 Pay As You Go 1. 5
Comparative Studies 2000 4 26 28 10 12.4 72600 2015 2026 2039 3.4 1 One Family, One Child 1999 6 2 11 6 2 6
1980 13 1 2000 6 1 2010 4 1 2020 2.7 1 2030 2 1 2017 2029 2040 28 36 1 1.7 20 80 25 28 20 1999 1000 1998 56 7 2000 4 11
Comparative Studies 2. 1 2 3 4 5 1. 2400 2000 200,, 8
20 2. 200 200 means test 3. 4. 20 90 0.4 9
Comparative Studies 5. public good progressive 1. 10
2. 8 8 20000 8 8 12 20000 3. 2000 65 79.2 81.8 2045 65 84.8 87.4 8 +8 2000 20 250 / 64 789 65 574 73 200 774 98 1 65 90 65 60 4. 8 20000 5. 1995 65 2000 2000 65 2045 ln =a+bln +c ln 2 a=5.52 b = 0.5 c=-0.05 55 11
Comparative Studies 1 * 20 20 20 20 2000 2000 2000 2000 / 250 250 250 250 60 55 65 65 2040 2035 2045 2045 ( / ) 789 786 789 789 ( / ) 423 262 574 513 200 200 200 200 ( / ) 0 0 0 0 623 462 774 713 ( / ) 423 262 574 513 ( ) 79 59 98 90 54 33 73 65 * 55 8%+8%, 3% 1.5% 6. 7. 8. 12
70 55 2010 2010 60 10 20 1. 2. 3. 4. 13
8 12 8 ) 1 2 3 risk pooling) 4 5 GNP 3 7 11 8 16 14 Comparative Studies
0.25 15
Comparative Studies 2 2.5 16
1 200 annuity 2000 200 60 41000 55 53000 3 2 1999-2.5 20 8 +8 20 2000 17 2000
Comparative Studies 3 3 2 2000 23 10 18
3 6 3 1 2 2001 141.2 78.3 2002 138.9 79.3 2003 136.5 80.3 2004 146.2 81.1 2005 150.4 82.0 2006 195.1 82.8 2007 266.3 83.5 2008 332.8 86.2 2009 432.2 87.2 2010 550.6 88.5 2011 510.0 82.8 2012 597.7 85.1 2013 686.7 87.4 2014 776.4 89.5 2015 867.2 91.6 2016 983.0 95.3 2017 1100.0 98.8 2018 1218.4 102.3 2019 1337.9 105.6 2020 1459.2 108.9 2021 1558.9 110.7 2022 1658.4 112.5 2023 1757.5 114.1 2024 1855.9 115.7 2025 1952.7 117.2 2026 2090.0 120.8 2027 2228.0 124.3 2028 2365.8 127.7 2029 2502.9 130.9 2030 2638.7 134.0 2031 2762.6 139.7 2032 2890.3 145.6 2033 3022.2 151.8 2034 3158.9 158.4 19
Comparative Studies 1 2 2035 3301.1 165.3 2036 3449.7 172.7 2037 3605.3 180.4 2038 3768.9 188.5 2039 3941.2 197.1 2040 4122.8 206.2 1 200 / 2000 20 90 0.4%) 1997 0.1, 2001 2010 60 55 2011 65 2 200 / ( 1999 761 1998 387.1 1 4 5 2010 200 / 5 4 5 1 2 3 4 2001 2338 1300 561 155 716 491 2002 2525 1600 606 163 769 544 2003 2713 1900 651 171 822 597 2004 2901 2200 696 180 876 651 2005 2803 673 673 448 2006 2693 646 646 421 2007 2589 621 621 396 2008 2483 596 596 371 2009 2375 570 570 345 2010 2267 544 544 319 2011 2157 518 518 293 2012 2046 491 491 266 2013 1938 465 465 240 2014 1856 445 445 220 2015 1768 424 424 199 2016 1601 384 384 159 2017 1455 349 349 124 2018 1300 312 312 87 2019 1169 281 281 56 20
5 1 2 3 4 2020 1044 250 250 25 2021 949 228 228 3 2022 862 207 207-18 2023 776 186 186-39 2024 684 164 164-61 2025 598 143 143-82 2026 520 125 125-100 2027 437 105 105-120 2028 353 85 85-140 2029 260 62 62-163 2030 178 43 43-182 2031 94 22 22-203 1 2000 2150 1700 2001 2004 200 / 2005 600 1987 1987 20 2032 65 2031 2 2000 1200 3900 2001 2004 300 / 2005 2700 3 2400 / 2000 4 5 2000 225 5 2 1 3 2001 2098.2 287.7 163.1 196.4 2745.4 287.7 2457.7 2002 2034.7 279.5 158.4 222.2 2694.8 279.5 2415.3 2003 1969.4 273.4 154.9 247.9 2645.6 273.4 2372.3 2004 1901.6 267.2 151.4 267.3 2587.5 267.2 2320.3 2005 1831.9 263.1 149.1 289.8 2533.8 263.1 2270.8 2006 1759.8 260.1 147.4 317.2 2484.4 260.1 2224.4 2007 1686.2 291.2 165.0 353.2 2495.7 291.2 2204.4 2008 1610.1 276.6 156.7 333.6 2377.1 276.6 2100.5 2009 1532.7 285.7 161.9 342.6 2322.9 285.7 2037.2 2010 1454.6 291.3 165.1 347.4 2258.4 291.3 1967.1 21
Comparative Studies 2 1 3 2011 1374.5 293.1 166.1 347.7 2181.4 293.1 1888.3 2012 1294.4 299.6 169.8 353.5 2117.3 299.6 1817.6 2013 1213.0 306.1 173.4 359.0 2051.6 306.1 1745.5 2014 1132.6 297.0 168.3 346.4 1944.3 297.0 1647.3 2015 1051.2 228.7 129.6 265.3 1674.8 228.7 1446.1 2016 970.1 244.2 138.4 281.7 1634.3 244.2 1390.1 2017 890.5 468.0 265.2 536.9 2160.6 468.0 1692.6 2018 811.6 412.0 233.5 470.0 1927.1 412.0 1515.1 2019 734.4 440.8 249.8 500.1 1925.1 440.8 1484.3 2020 657.8 374.2 212.1 422.2 1666.3 374.2 1292.1 2021 584.2 360.3 204.2 404.2 1552.9 360.3 1192.6 2022 513.5 272.8 154.6 304.3 1245.2 272.8 972.4 2023 446.9 252.1 142.8 279.7 1121.5 252.1 869.5 2024 384.3 251.6 142.6 277.6 1056.1 251.6 804.5 2025 327.1 269.7 152.8 295.9 1045.6 269.7 775.9 2026 273.7 254.8 144.4 278.0 950.9 254.8 696.1 2027 222.8 229.3 130.0 248.9 831.0 229.3 601.6 2028 177.0 248.2 140.7 267.8 833.7 248.2 585.5 2029 137.4 252.1 142.8 270.5 802.8 252.1 550.7 2030 104.6 281.5 159.5 300.4 846.1 281.5 564.5 2031 76.3 249.3 141.3 264.6 731.4 249.3 482.1 2032 53.4 285.3 161.7 301.1 801.5 285.3 516.2 2033 35.8 207.8 243.6 207.8 35.8 2034 23.0 174.7 197.8 174.7 23.0 2035 14.2 147.7 161.9 147.7 14.2 2036 8.4 125.2 133.6 125.2 8.4 2037 4.8 108.8 113.6 108.8 4.8 2038 2.6 95.4 98.0 95.4 2.6 2039 1.4 83.5 84.9 83.5 1.4 2040 0.7 73.1 73.8 73.1 0.7 4 23597.4 6309.4 3374.6 6505.1 39786.4 1 1999 500 / 1999 3730 2000 2 4 3000 1987 2032 3 4 3 2000 22
6-a 1 GDP 2 GDP( ) 2001 141 2745 716 3603 1443 97263 1.48 2002 139 2695 769 3603 1443 104072 1.39 2003 136 2646 822 3604 1444 111357 1.30 2004 146 2587 876 3610 1450 119152 1.22 2005 150 2534 673 3357 1197 127492 0.94 2006 195 2484 646 3326 1166 136417 0.85 2007 266 2496 621 3383 1223 145966 0.84 2008 333 2377 596 3306 1146 156183 0.73 2009 432 2323 570 3325 1165 167116 0.70 2010 551 2258 544 3353 1193 178814 0.67 2011 510 2181 518 3209 1049 189543 0.55 2012 598 2117 491 3206 1046 200916 0.52 2013 687 2052 465 3203 1043 212971 0.49 2014 776 1944 445 3166 1006 225749 0.45 2015 867 1675 424 2966 806 239294 0.34 2016 983 1634 384 3002 842 253652 0.33 2017 1100 2161 349 3610 1450 268871 0.54 2018 1218 1927 312 3458 1298 285003 0.46 2019 1338 1925 281 3544 1384 302103 0.46 2020 1459 1666 250 3376 1216 320229 0.38 2021 1559 1553 228 3340 1180 336241 0.35 2022 1658 1245 207 3110 950 353053 0.27 2023 1757 1122 186 3065 905 370705 0.24 2024 1856 1056 164 3076 916 389241 0.24 2025 1953 1046 143 3142 982 408703 0.24 2026 2090 951 125 3166 1006 429138 0.23 2027 2228 831 105 3164 1004 450595 0.22 2028 2366 834 85 3284 1124 473124 0.24 2029 2503 803 62 3368 1208 496781 0.24 2030 2639 846 43 3527 1367 521620 0.26 2031 2763 731 22 3516 1356 547701 0.25 2032 2890 801 3692 1532 575086 0.27 2033 3022 244 3266 1106 603840 0.18 2034 3159 198 3357 1197 634032 0.19 2035 3301 162 3463 1303 665734 0.20 2036 3450 134 3583 1423 699020 0.20 23
Comparative Studies 1 GDP 2 GDP( ) 2037 3605 114 3719 1559 733971 0.21 2038 3769 98 3867 1707 770670 0.22 2039 3941 85 4026 1866 809203 0.23 2040 4123 74 4197 2037 849663 0.24 1 2000 2160 2 2000 2000 2010 7% 2010 2020 6% 2020 2040 5% 6-b 1 GDP 2 GDP(%) 2001 78 2745 716 3540 1380 97263 1.42 2002 79 2695 769 3543 1383 104072 1.33 2003 80 2646 822 3548 1388 111357 1.25 2004 81 2587 876 3545 1385 119152 1.16 2005 82 2534 673 3288 1128 127492 0.89 2006 83 2484 646 3214 1054 136417 0.77 2007 84 2496 621 3201 1041 145966 0.71 2008 86 2377 596 3059 899 156183 0.58 2009 87 2323 570 2980 820 167116 0.49 2010 88 2258 544 2891 731 178814 0.41 2011 83 2181 518 2782 622 189543 0.33 2012 85 2117 491 2693 533 200916 0.27 2013 87 2052 465 2604 444 212971 0.21 2014 90 1944 445 2479 319 225749 0.14 2015 92 1675 424 2191 31 239294 0.01 2016 95 1634 384 2114-46 253652-0.02 2017 99 2161 349 2609 449 268871 0.17 2018 102 1927 312 2341 181 285003 0.06 2019 106 1925 281 2311 151 302103 0.05 2020 109 1666 250 2026-134 320229-0.04 2021 111 1553 228 1891-269 336241-0.08 2022 112 1245 207 1565-595 353053-0.17 2023 114 1122 186 1422-738 370705-0.20 2024 116 1056 164 1336-824 389241-0.21 2025 117 1046 143 1306-854 408703-0.21 24
1 GDP 2 GDP(%) 2026 121 951 125 1197-963 429138-0.22 2027 124 831 105 1060-1100 450595-0.24 2028 128 834 85 1046-1114 473124-0.24 2029 131 803 62 996-1164 496781-0.23 2030 134 846 43 1023-1137 521620-0.22 2031 140 731 22 894-1266 547701-0.23 2032 146 801 947-1213 575086-0.21 2033 152 244 395-1765 603840-0.29 2034 158 198 356-1804 634032-0.28 2035 165 162 327-1833 665734-0.28 2036 173 134 306-1854 699020-0.27 2037 180 114 294-1866 733971-0.25 2038 188 98 287-1873 770670-0.24 2039 197 85 282-1878 809203-0.23 2040 206 74 280-1880 849663-0.22 1 2000 2160 2 2000 2000 2010 7% 2010 2020 6% 2020 2040 5 2000 2001 2100 / 2010 1500 / 2001 2010 60 55 2011 65 1 200 2001 140 2010 550 / 2 40000 1999 136 137 1997 2518 1998 4760 25
2001 2010 2500 2000 2160 340 / 3 2000 3150 2001 2004 800 1200 2004 2400 2001 2010 680 2000 225 455 2011 2020 25 4 2000 8 200 1 200 2001 80 2010 90 2 2000 8 2001 2010 1275 1075 200 2040 4000 5-a 5-b 16 8 +8 25 28 26 Comparative Studies 2000 3000 8000 8 3000 8000 8 192
1 2 70 51 perpetual bond 27
Comparative Studies 1. 2. 3. 2010 4. 28