5 : 99, [ 1 ],,,,,,, :,,, ; ; ;,,,,,, :, Max W eber,,w eber, ;,,,,,,,,,, ;, ;,,,,,,,,,, : (1) ; (2) ; (3) ; (4) ; (5), [ 2 ] ( P131),,,,,,, [ 3 ],,, (

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "5 : 99, [ 1 ],,,,,,, :,,, ; ; ;,,,,,, :, Max W eber,,w eber, ;,,,,,,,,,, ;, ;,,,,,,,,,, : (1) ; (2) ; (3) ; (4) ; (5), [ 2 ] ( P131),,,,,,, [ 3 ],,, ("

跪槽最庞
5 years ago
Views:

24 5 2006 9 ( ) Tribune o f Po litica l Scie nce a nd Law (Jo u rna l o f C h ina U n ive rsity o f Po litica l Sc ie nce a nd Law ) Vol. 24, No.

1 ( ) Tribune o f Po litica l Scie nce a nd Law (Jo u rna l o f C h ina U n ive rsity o f Po litica l Sc ie nce a nd Law ) Vol. 24, No. 5 Sep (, ) :,,,,,,,,, ;, : ; ; : DF08 : A : (2006) ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ( ),,,,,, : : (1955 ),,,, 3,,,,

2 5 : 99, [ 1 ],,,,,,, :,,, ; ; ;,,,,,, :, Max W eber,,w eber, ;,,,,,,,,,, ;, ;,,,,,,,,,, : (1) ; (2) ; (3) ; (4) ; (5), [ 2 ] ( P131),,,,,,, [ 3 ],,, (R. Schm idt),,,,,

3 100 ( ) 2006,,,,,, ( ), ( ),,, ( ),,,,, :,,,,,,, ( ),,,,, ;,,,,,,, ( ),,, ( ),,,,,,, 19,,,,,, [ 4 ],,,,,,,,,, 19,, M. W eber, Economy and Society: An Outline Interp retive Sociology, transl. by E. Fischoff et al., Berkeley: University of California Press, 1978, pp ;,, : ( ), ( Imperative),,,, ;,, [ ] :,, 2003, 30 ;

4 5 : 101,, ;,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ( Sharia law),,, ;,, ( ),,,,, ( ), 17 18, ( ) ( ), ( ), ( ), [ 5 ] ( P189-91),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, [ 4 ] ( P ),, ; :,?,!?! [ ] :, 3,, 1991, 36

5 102 ( ) 2006,,,,,,,,,,,, [ 6 ] ( P ),,,,,,, [ 6 ] ( P ), :?,,,, :,,,, [ 2 ] ( P ),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :,,,, :! : :, : : : :, :, :, : :, : : : :! : : [ ] :, 2,, 1990,

6 5 : 103,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ;,,,,,,,,,, (, ),,,,,,,,,,, ;,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

7 104 ( ) 2006,,,,,,,, ;,,, ;,, ;,,,,,,,,, ;,,,,,,,, [ 7 ] :,,,,,, :, ;,,,,,,,,,,??,, ( ) ( ),,,,,,,, [ 8 ],,,,, 1966,,, ;,,,,,,,,,,,

8 5 : 105,,,, ( ),,,, /,,,,,,, [ 9 ],,,,,,,,,?,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ;, ;, ;,,,, ;,,, ;,,??,,,,,,,, : ; ;,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ;,,

9 106 ( ) 2006,,,,,,,, :?,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ( ),, ( ),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ;,,, ;,,,,,

10 5 : 107,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ( ),,,, ( ),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :,,,,,,, :,,?, ;,,,,?,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ( ),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

11 108 ( ) 2006 ;,,, ;,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,?,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ;, ;,,,,,,,,, :,,,,, :,, : :,? : :, : :, :,!,,,,,,

12 5 : 109 :,,,,,, : [ 1 ] 1 [A ] 1, 1 ( 7 8 ) [ C ]1 :, [ 2 ] [ ] 1 [M ]1, 1 :, [ 3 ] M. W eber1economy and Society: An Outline Interp re2 tive Sociology[M ] 1transl. by E. Fischoff et al. 1Berke2 ley: University of California Press, [ 4 ] 1 : ( ) [M ]1 :, [ 5 ] Joseph Schacht1An Introduction to Islam ic Law [M ] 1 Oxford University Press, [ 6 ] [ ] 1 ( 2 ) [M ] 1,, 1 :, [ 7 ] [M ]1 [ 8 ] [ ] 1 [M ]1,, 1 :, [ 9 ] [ ] 1 [M ] 1, 1 :, There s Nothing to Say vs. There s Something to Say On Traditional Justice and Jurisprudence in China by ZHANGWeiren GAO Hong - jun ( Tsinghua University, B eijing ) Abstract: Some believe that Chinese traditional justice is Khadi justice. Prof. ZhangW eiren from Tai2 wan, holds that the p roposition of Khadi justice raised byw ebber has no basis, and the Chinese traditional justice does not fall into the category of Khadi justice. According to the w riter of this thesis, the p roposition of Khadi justice is correct and Chinese traditional justice basically belongs to the Khadi justice. How to comment on the Chinese traditional judicial system and concep ts involves both the issues concerning the law s in ancient and modern China and other countries and the fundamental direction of contemporary Chinese rule of law. The contemporary Chinese rule of law should be divided into three dim ensions: peop le s livelihood, de2 mocracy, and popular sentiments, which respectively correspond to the econom ic system, political field and Chinese culture. The first two are m ainly about the issue of ancient time and that of modern time, and the main task is to build the modern system. W hile the third is about the issue concerning China and western countries, mainly restoring the Chinese tradition culture. Nowadays the m arketing econom y, democratic gov2 ernment, and Chinese tradition and culture are in p rogress and w ill be necessary to the modernization of the le2 gality of China and the modernization of China. Key W ords: Conflict; Justice; Modernization of Legality ( )

5 : 67 ( ),,,,, : (1),,,,,,,, ( ),, ( : ) [ 1 ],, (2),,,, ;,,, [ 2 ] ( P1 2),,, (3),, [ 1 ] ( P1 1),,, [ 3 ] ( P1364),,,,, [ 4 ] ( P1135),,,,,,, [ 5 ]

5 : 67 ( ),,,,, : (1),,,,,,,, ( ),, ( : ) [ 1 ],, (2),,,, ;,,, [ 2 ] ( P1 2),,, (3),, [ 1 ] ( P1 1),,, [ 3 ] ( P1364),,,,, [ 4 ] ( P1135),,,,,,, [ 5 ] 24 5 2006 9 Tribune o f Po litica l Scie nce a nd Law (Jo u rna l o f C h ina U n ive rsity o f Po litica l Sc ie nce a nd Law ) Vol. 24, No. 5 Sep. 2006 (, 310028) :,,,,, : ; ; ; ; ; : ; ; ; : DF5 : A