Chinese Journal of Health Policy June 2014 Vol. 7 No. 6 基于英国 德国 新加坡和美国的分析 1 2* 3 4 2 2 1. 442008 2. 430030 3. 430072 4. 430014 摘要 在界定医疗机构分工协作内涵基础上, 本文描述了英国 德国 新加坡和美国四个国家开展医疗机 构分工协作的现状, 认为其有利条件包括合格的全科医生 严格的卫生资源配置 有效的社区首诊和双向转诊制 度分析医疗联合体 管理型保健以及全科医生签约政策调整对分工协作的影响, 总结出国外开展医疗机构分工 协作的经验和启示 : 门诊与住院服务是否需要分离, 基层医疗机构的私有化模式, 护理 康复类机构与医疗机构的 分工协作, 医院集团化与分工协作的关系, 以及分工协作并不能解决医疗服务提供体系的所有问题 关键词 医疗机构 ; 分工协作 ; 分级诊疗 中图分类号 : R197 文献标识码 : A doi: 10. 3969 /j. issn. 1674-2982. 2014. 06. 003 International experience on the division and cooperation among medical institutions and its implications for China An analysis of the UK Germany Singapore and the US YU Hong-xing 1 2 FENG You-mei 3 FU Min 4 LIU Zhi-yong 2 YAO Lan 2 1. Affiliated Dongfeng Hospital Hubei University of Medicine Hubei Shiyan 442008 China 2. School of Medicine and Health Management Tongji Medical College of Huazhong University of Science and Technology Hubei Wuhan 430030 China 3. Wuhan University Hubei Wuhan 430072 China 4. Health and Family Planning Commission of Wuhan Municipality Hubei Wuhan 430014 China Abstract Through defining the connotation of division and cooperation among medical institutions this paper introduces the current status for division and cooperation among medical institutions of Britain Germany Singapore and USA. The advantages include excellent general practices optimal health resource allocation effective first treatment in community health facilities and effective two-way referral. We analyzed the influence of some new policies on the division and cooperation among medical institutions such as medical association managed care and the General Practices' service contract. This provided a lot of experience and revelations including the dynamics to promote the division and cooperation the separation of outpatient services and inpatient services privatization of primary medical institutions division and cooperation between medical institutions and nursing rehabilitation institutions distinguishing the division and cooperation from hospitals alliance and division and cooperation among medical institutions can not resolve the all issues in the medical care supply system. Key words Medical institutions Division and cooperation Bottom-up cascading healthcare practice 10 * 20110112110025 1974 E-mail yuhongx@ 163. com E-mail lanyao@ vip. 163. com
2014 6 7 6 2009 11 8 10 9 2013 2. 2 1 1971 10 2-3 4 5 11 6 12 2. 3 1 13 NHS 14 2 400 18 7 National University Hospital National Heart Centre Singapore Singapore National Eye Centre KK Women's and Children's Hospital 2 2. 1 2009 11
Chinese Journal of Health Policy June 2014 Vol. 7 No. 6 60% 70% 15 90% 17 22 16 4% MRI 30% 17 3 2. 4 3. 1 1991 18 NHS NHS Smith 13 5 19 NHS 20 NHS 1999 The National Healthcare Group 9 NHG Singapore Health Services SHS 15 1980 400 90% 23 21 12
3. 2 2014 6 7 6 NHS PCTs PCTs 1991 GP fund holder 29 1998 57% 24 25 3. 3 Managed care 26 1999 27 Primary Care Groups PCGs 24 2002 Primary Care Trusts Health Maintenance Oraganization HMO PCTs 31 1 3 ~ 5 15 PCTs NHS 2013 3 Integrated Delivery Clinical System IDS Commissioning Groups CCGs Local area teams LATs 28 NHS 211 CCGs 66 500 ~ 870 000 250 29 NHS England 4 CCGs CCGs 4. 1 30 CCGs PCTs 13
Chinese Journal of Health Policy June 2014 Vol. 7 No. 6 4. 5 4. 2 32-33 35% 34 35-36 1. D. 2011. 2. J. 2012 12 67-70. 3. J. 1996 2 7-10. 4. J. 2010 10 22-23. 4. 3 5. J. 2011 31 11 NHS 17-19. 6 Kodner D Spreeuwenberg C. Integrated care meaning logic applications and implications a discussion paper J. International Journal of Integrated Care 2002 2 3 1-6. 7. J. 2008 29 8 65-67. 8. J. 2000 20 2 59-60. 4. 4 9. J. 2013 16 10 3519-3521. 14
2014 6 7 6 10 R. 26. J. J. 2007 10 74-75. J. 2009 9 22-25. 12. J. 2001 11 10-12. J. 2002 16 1 44-46. 14. J. 29 Walshe K. Reinventing clinical commissioning groups J. 1997 13 1 60-63. 15. M. 2013. 16. M.. 2008. 17 E P. 31. M.. M. 2010. 2006. 18. J.. 2011 6 21-26. J. 2002 5 3 209-210. 19 Department of Health. Building on the best choice responsiveness and equity in the NHS R. London Department of Health 2003. 20. 34 Schoen C Osborn R Squires D et al. New 2011 Survey of J. 2007 24 4 151-155. 21. J. that care is often poorly coordinated J. Health Affairs 2005 21 3 213-215. 22. 35 Amelung V Hildebrandt H Wolf S. Integrated care in M.. Germany-a stony but necessary road J. International 2011. 23. J. 36 Braun B Marstedt G Sievers C. About the importance of 2003 1 70-72. interfaces and transitions in the German Health System J. 24 Kay A. The abolition of the GP fundholding scheme a lesson in evidence-based policy making J. British Journal of General Practice 2002 52 475 141-144. 25. J. 2014-04-06 1996 13 4 187-189. 2005 25 4 62-64. 11. 27 Mannion R. General practitioner commissioning in the English national health service Continuity Change and future challenges J. International Journal of Health Services 2008 38 4 717-730. 28 The NHS in England EB /OL. 2013-01-28 2014-03- 13. 31. http / /www. nhs. uk /NHSEngland /thenhs /about /Pages / nhsstructure. aspx BMJ 2013 347 1-2. 30 Clinical Commissioning Groups CCG and how they Perform EB /OL. 2013-10-06 2014-03-31. http / / www. nhs. uk /NHSEngland /thenhs /about /Pages /ccg-outcomes. aspx 32. 33 Hansch H Fleck E. New possibilities for communication between hospital cardiologists and general practitioners J. Disease Management and Health Outcomes 2006 14 19-22. patients with complex care needs in eleven countries finds 2011 30 12 2347-448. Journal of Integrated Care 2012 12 1-5. Ein Newsletterder Bertelsmann Stiftung und der BARMER GEK 2011 3 1-11. 2014-04-24 15