紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 [ ] NGO

愛滋治理與在地行動 紅絲帶主流化 : 1 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 (UNAIDS) NGO NGO 1992 NGO 1 99 NSC 99-2410-H-008-050 "Mainstreaming the Red Ribbon: AIDS NGO Governance and the Deployment of Sexualities in Taiwan", 'Naming and Framing: The Making of Sexual (In) Equality' Conference, International Association for the Study of Sexuality, Culture and Society (IASSCS), Madrid, July 6-9, 2011. Kane Race 85

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 2 1997 2001 2 1992 [ ] 1994 1995 1996 1999 1999 1999 2003 1993 2005 2005 2006 1997 NGO 1998 2003 2008 86

愛滋治理與在地行動 Cindy Patton 1990 Patton 70 Patton 87

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 3 1990 Patton 2002 Kavita Misra 2006 NGO NGO NGO Misra NGO NGO NGO 4 3 Patton (1993) Watney (1989) 4 Ho (2008, 2010) 2005 2012 88

愛滋治理與在地行動 2005 5 2005 2004 6 2005 2004 5 1993 1997 62012 89

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 (neoliberal statist) (glocal) NGO 7 627 sexual healthism 8 AV AV 7 2008 8 2010 90

愛滋治理與在地行動 ABC Abstinence Be Faithful Condoms 9 10 MSM 2009 NGO 9 2009 2009 ABC 10 91

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 2011 9 AV Jump sexual governance ABC 11 ABC 12 11 Colvin(2010) Robins (2006) Thomas Cousins 12 NGO NGO 92

愛滋治理與在地行動 627 1990 Mark Finn Srikant Sarangi NGO Positive Speakers' Bureaus (PSBs) 93

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 Finn Sarangi Finn Sarangi Finn and Sarangi 2008 13 2007 NGO 14 2009 20 15 16 13 Finn and Sarangi (2008) 14 http://icarehiv.taiwanaids.org.tw/about/intro 15 http://icarehiv.taiwanaids.org.tw/about/showcase 16 http://icarehiv.taiwanaids.org.tw/about/intro 94

愛滋治理與在地行動 Jimmy 17 6 6 17 2000 95

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 18 19 Sara Ahmed 2010 (sociable happiness) 20 Jimmy 能夠 應當 2011c 18 http://icarehiv.taiwanaids.org.tw/node/135 19 20 Robert McRuer Crip Theory: Cultural Signs of Queerness and Disability 96

愛滋治理與在地行動 (Ahmed 2010: 581) 1980 21 2011d 2011d 21 2010 12 3 97

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 22 23 ABCDE 24 1986 22 http://icarehiv.taiwanaids.org.tw/ 23 24 1990 / 98

愛滋治理與在地行動 1990 1991 1991 25 1980 1984 1988 1989 1990 1991 1997 2000 2003 / / 2004 2005 2006 2009 26 25 2006 26 25 http://www.google.com/search?q=%e5%8f%b0%e7%81%a3%e6%84% 9B%E6%BB%8B%E7%97%85%E6%94%BF%E7%AD%96%E8%88%87%E6%B3 %95%E4%BB%A4%E5%8F%8A%E6%B5%81%E8%A1%8C%E7%97%85%E5%A D%B8%E4%BB%8B%E7%B4%B9&hl=zh-TW&client=firefox-a&hs=QAy&rls=org. mozilla:zh-tw:official&prmd=ivns&ei=hapxtspzlows8gohqmirda&start=0&sa= N&biw=1280&bih=610 2011 9 15 99

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 27 Cindy Patton Patton 1990: 103 1997 28 27 (Patton [1990]; Waldby [1996]) ELISA [ ] 28 21 2005 2006 2005 2004 2006 2004 HIV 2010 Li 2011 MSM (sexual tropics) 100

愛滋治理與在地行動 2000 HIV 29 2007 6 27 627 1994 National Testing Day 2 2009 627 take the test, take control Patton (2002) 2012 29 2009 3 20 12 2009 101

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 Living with HIV 30 (subjection) ABC ABC ABCDE D Detect, E Education ABCDE 100 31 30 HIV http://www.vir.us/tc/ watch_and_learn.html 2012 10 9 31 100 http://www.taiwanaids.org.tw/aidsfaq/% E9%82%A3%E4%BA%9B%E6%97%8F%E7%BE%A4%E5%8F%AF%E8%83%BD %E6%98%AF%E9%AB%98%E5%8D%B1%E9%9A%AA%E7%BE%A4 2011 9 15 102

愛滋治理與在地行動 32 33 ABCDE ABC 2010 34 35 DVD AIDS 32 33 http://www.taiwanaids.org.tw/node/80 342010 35 http://www.taiwanaids.org.tw/node/2502 2011 9 19 103

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 36 condom abstinence faithful ( 2009: 78) HIV HIV 37 36 37 2010 http://health99.doh.gov.tw/ educzone/edu_detail.aspx?catid=50478&type=004 2011 9 19 104

愛滋治理與在地行動 HIV safer sex 38 HIV Youtube Kuso 39 38 Scott (2003: 35-89) Patton 1996 39 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vernhtihafa 105

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 ABC HIV 40 ABCDE MSM 41 40 Worth, Patton, and Goldstein 2005: 11 41 106

愛滋治理與在地行動 42 NGO 2008 2011 43 2010 Gisneyland 2012 2012 Ginsneyland 44 45 2011 Huang (2012) 42 28 43 Song YY http://www. songyy.org.tw/ UniiGay http://www.uniigay.com/ 44 45 2010 2008 9 11 28 107

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 2009 46 2011 8 IC homo-normativity 47 2012 627 2008 46 http://praatw.org/right_2_cont. asp?id=103 2011 9 15 47 Duggan 2004 2012 neo-moralism 108

愛滋治理與在地行動 48 6 2012 49 50 51 48 / 49 Love 2007 50 2012 51 Enjoysex 2011 6 30 http://www. enjoysex.org.tw/static/upload/newsflash/epaper_03_2.html 2011 9 15 2011 109

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 2007 ( ) 52 2004 92 14 28 21 2004: 13 53 2007 52 http://www2.cdc.gov.tw/ public/data/812215101971.doc 2010 8 21 532004 3 2004 2004 2009 2012 Hung 2007 Chang (2010) 110

愛滋治理與在地行動 7 5 12 54 NGO 55 cultural imperative 56 627 take the test, take control 54 55 http://www.totrp.org.tw/index. php?mode=data_about 2010 8 21 56 Tim Dean (2009) We want to be healthy because we want to be normal Dean 2009: 63 Tomso (2009) HIV 111

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 並且勇於面對自己, 是多麼值得讓人稱許的事 2010a: 4 57 HIV 2009 MSM 2009 MSM MSM Mitigate Stigma Myself 57 2009: 2 112

愛滋治理與在地行動 Men Who Have Sex With Men MSM Mitigate Stigma Myself 2009 58 MSM D.I.Y 2009: 55 MSM 59 MSM 2011 Positive 60 58 Bevis Bevis 2009 59 Bevis 2009: 23 1980 Bevis 自保 自力救濟 Patton (1985) Crimp (2002) Kinsman (1996) 60 http://www.lourdes.org.tw/onepage.asp?menu1=7&menu2=117 2012 10 1 113

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 K 61 62 (sexual norm): "No condom, no sex" 2009 63 61http://www. peopo.org/quendigay/post/92567 2012 10 1 62 http://blog.yam.com/hugoman0104/category/215220 http://cms. mysss.org/ 63 MSM (194/334, 58.1%) MSM 2010b: 8 2008 2008 6 2008 2008 HIV 2005; 2006 MSM 114

愛滋治理與在地行動 5 2009 MSM 2007 http://picasaweb.google.com/1078659602240119 01477/071115?gsessionid=Gc24vdu3FuUEBMYCEYIZSA 2011 8 30 115

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 2008: 7, 15 64 HIV 13 此法徹底剝奪了感染者的醫療隱私 65 2007 66 64 65 2007 39 66 116

愛滋治理與在地行動 take the test and get controlled 67 HIV NGO 68 NGO 2011 patient compliance moral compliance 2009 2010 2006 Race 2009 67 http://www. taiwanaids.org.tw/node/2906 627 B HIV 20 14-32 68 Kinsman (1996) 117

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 ABC ABCDE NGO NGO Susan Kippax 118

愛滋治理與在地行動 negotiated safety sero sorting 69 (Kippax 2010) Kippax Kane Race sero- 69 sero-sorting 119

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 sorting Race 2003, 2008 70 Kippax 71 70 / Foucault (1992, 1988); Halperin (1995) 71 2009 120

愛滋治理與在地行動 72 Kippax Kane Race negotiated safety sero-sorting (accessible) (available to memory) 集體活動 (Kippax and Race, 2003: 7 ) neo-moralism NGO NGO 73 72 73 2010 Cindy Patton 121

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 Heather Love [ ] (psychic and corporeal reminder) (Love 2010) New MSM 2011 2011 11 80 (Huang 2011: 69-81) 74 2011 74 2009 122

愛滋治理與在地行動 2011 2012: 380 75 76 2011 6 Logo 9 2009 Huang (2011: 203-4) 75 2010 762011a 123

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 Logo 6 9 2011 MSM 2011, 2012 77 78 77 2012: 387 78 http://www2.cdc.gov.tw/ct.asp?xitem=35109&ctnode=26& mp=998 2012 10 13 124

愛滋治理與在地行動 125

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 79 80 81 24 82 83 79 2012 80 2008 1 http://www.cdc.gov.tw/ct.asp?xitem=11326&ctnode= 1829&mp=1 2010 8 21 81 2011b 82 2009: 40 83 (UNDP) Global Commission on HIV and the Law (2012); Barry et. al (2012). Worth, Patton, and Goldstein (2005) 126

愛滋治理與在地行動 84 Kippax Race 85 84 2007: 159-167 85 Patton (1996) 127

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 86 12 2004 HIV 87 86 87 2009, 2011b 128

愛滋治理與在地行動 88 NGO 因此, 酷兒的羞恥政治強烈反對 假 自主人權 真 強制篩檢的法律與政策, 也要求一個不以治療為名來剝奪感染者醫療隱私 不把感染者當嫌犯列管的醫療與社會環境 Ahmed, Sara (2010) "Killing Joy: Feminism and the History of Happiness," Signs 88 2009 627 2009 129

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 35.3: 571-594. Barry, Adam et. al (2012) "How Criminalisation is Affecting People Living with HIV in Ontario", http://www.ohtn.on.ca/documents/research/b-adam- OHTN-Criminalization-2012.pdf, accessed Oct 25, 2012. Chen, Kuan-Hsing (2010) Asia as Method: Towards Deimperialisation, Durham: Duke University Press. Chang, Jerry Yung-Ching ( ) (2010) "Affective Ruptures, Queer (Op) positionalities: Sex and Intimacy in Contemporary Taiwanese Literary Representations on Ecstasy", MA Thesis, Dept of English, National Central University. Colvin, Christopher J., Steven Robins, and Joan Leavens (2010) "Grounding Responsible Talk: Masculinities, Citizenship, and HIV in Cape Town, South Africa", Journal of Development Studies 46.7: 1179-1195. Crimp, Douglas (2002) Melancholia and Moralism: Essays on AIDS and Queer Politics, Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. Dean, Tim (2009) Unlimited Intimacy, Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Duggan, Lisa (2004) The Twilight of Equality? Neoliberalism, Cultural Politics and the Attack on Democracy, Boston: Beacon Press. Finn, Mark and Srikant Sarangi (2008) "Quality of Life as a Mode of Governance: NGO Talk of HIV 'Positive' Health in India", Social Science and Medicine 66: 1568-1578. Finn, Mark and Srikant Sarangi (2009) "Humanising HIV/AIDS and Its (Re) Stigmatising Effects: HIV Public 'Positive' Speaking in India, Health: An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of Health", Illness and Medicine 13.1: 47-65. Foucault, Michel (1992) The History of Sexuality, Volume II: The Use of Pleasure, London: Penguin. Foucault, Michel (1988) The History of Sexuality, Volume III: The Care of the Self, London: Penguin. Global Commission on HIV and the Law (2012) "Risk, Rights, and Health", http://www.hivlawcommission.org/resources/report/finalreport- Risks,Rights&Health-EN.pdf, accessed Oct 25, 2012. Halperin, David (1995) Saint=Foucault: Towards a Gay Hagiography, Cambridge: Oxford University Press. Ho, Josephine ( ) (2008) "Is Global Governance Bad for East Asian Queers?", GLQ 14.4: 457-479; Ho, Josephine ( )(2010) "Queer Existence under Global Governance: A Taiwan Exemplar", Positions: East Asia Culture Critiques 18.2: 537-554. 130

愛滋治理與在地行動 Huang, Hans Tao-Ming Huang ( ) 2011 Queer Politics and Sexual Modernity in Taiwan, Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press. Huang, Hans (2012) "HIV Testing, Neoliberal Governance and the New Moral Regime of Gay Health in Taiwan", Somatosphere, http:// somatosphere.net/2012/08/hiv-testing-neoliberal-governance-and-the-newmoral-regime-of-gay-health-in-taiwan.html, accessed October 10, 2012. Hung, Chiming Leonard ( ) (2007) "Gay Rave Culture and HIV Prevention: A Subcultural Intervention in Public Policy", MA Thesis, Dept of English, National Central University. Kinsman, Gary (1996) " 'Responsibility' as a Strategy of Governance: Regulating People Living with AIDS and Lesbian and Gay Men in Ontario", Economy and Society 25.3: 393-409. Kippax, Susan (2010) "Reasserting the Social in a Biomedical Epidemic: The Case of HIV Prevention", paper presented at "Reframing the Social Dimensions of HIV in a Biomedicalised Epidemic: The case of Treatment as Prevention" Conference, Oversees Development Institute, London, March 5. Kippax, Susuan and Kane Race (2003) "Sustaining Safe Practice: Twenty Years On", Social Science & Medicine 57: 1-12. Li, Chia-lin ( ) (2011) "The Uses of 'Men who have Sex with Men' in Taiwan's Official AIDS Discourse", MA Thesis, Dept of English, National Central University. Love, Heather (2007) "Compulsory happiness and queer existence", New Formations 63: 52 64. Love, Heather (2010) "On the Politics of Emotions: Feeling Backward, Feeling Bad", talk given at National Tsing Hua University, Taiwan, Dec 16, 2010. McRuer, Robert (2006) Crip Theory: Cultural Signs of Queerness and Disability, New York: New York University Press. Misra, Kavita (2006) "Politico-Moral Transactions in Indian AIDS Service: Confidentiality, Rights and New Modalities of Governance", Anthropological Quarterly 79.1: 33-74. Nguyen, V.K (2009) "Government-by-Exception: Enrolment and Experimentality in Mass HIV Treatment Programs in Africa", Social Theory and Health 7.3: 196-217. Patton, Cindy (1985) Sex and Germs: The Politics of AIDS, Boston: South End Press. Patton, Cindy (1990) Inventing AIDS, London: Routledge. Patton, Cindy (1993) "Containing African AIDS" in Henry Abelove et al. (eds.) The Lesbian and Gay Reader, New York: Routledge, 127-138 131

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 Patton, Cindy (1996) Fatal Advice: How Safe-Sex Education Went Wrong, Durham: Duke University Press. Patton, Cindy (2002) Globalising AIDS, Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press. Race, Kane (2003) "Revaluation of risk among gay men", AIDS Education and Prevention 15.4: 369-81; Race, Kane (2008) "The Use of Pleasure in Harm Reduction: Perspectives from the History of Sexuality", International Journal of Drug Policy 19: 417-423. Race, Kane (2009) Pleasure Consuming Medicine: The Queer Politics of Drugs, Durham: Duke University Press. Robins, Steven (2006) "From 'Rights' to 'Ritual': AIDS Activism in South Africa", American Anthropologist 108.2: 312-323. Scott, J Blake (2003) Risky Rhetoric: AIDS and the Cultural Practices of HIV Testing, Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press. Tomso, Gregory (2008) "Viral Sex and the Politics of Life", South Atlantic Quarterly 107.2: 265-285. Waldby, Catherine (1996) AIDS and the Body Politic: Biomedine and Sexual Difference, New York: Routledge. Watney, Simon (1989) "Missionary Positions: AIDS, 'Africa', and Race" in Practices of Freedoms: Selected Writings on HIV/AIDS, London: Rivers Oram Press, 109-127. Worth, Heather, Cindy Patton, and Diane Goldstein (2005) "Introduction to Special Issue: Reckless Vectors: The Infecting 'Other' in HIV/AIDS Law", Sexuality Research and Social Policy 2.2: 3-13. Bevis 2009 22-23 2009 20 14-32 NOW News (2011) 12 18 http://www.nownews.com/2011/12/18/11490-2767851.htm 2012 10 12 2009 MSM 2009 50-51 132

愛滋治理與在地行動 (2011) http://www.coolloud.org. tw/node/65494 2012 10 10 (2011) http://www.ccd.org.tw/upload/ news/345/2upfile.pdf 2012 10 10 (2009) 40-41 (2009) 12 3 22 http://www. lihpao.com/?action-viewnews-itemid-9169 2012 9 30 (2008) 2008 HIV http://www.coolloud.org.tw/node/30913 2012 10 10 http://www.cdc.gov.tw/sp.asp?xdurl=disease/disease_content. asp&id=2215&mp=1&ctnode=1498 2011 8 30 (2009) (2011) http:// www.cdc.gov.tw/info.aspx?treeid=45da8e73a81d495d&nowtreeid=1bd193e d6dabaee6&tid=0b4d71c8447b062f 2012 10 13 (2004) 3 24 (2005) NGO 59 1-42 (2009) 10 26 (2012) (2010) (2009) http://www.praatw.org/right_2_ cont.asp?id=94 2012 2 25 (2012) 6 9 http://www.healthnews.com.tw/readsupply.php?id=3977 2012 10 10 (2011) 9 6 http://udn.com/news/breakingnews/breakingnews9/6573649. shtml 2011 9 1 (2012) 7 22 133

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 http://mag.udn.com/mag/life/storypage.jsp?f_art_id=403431 2012 10 12 (2008) 2008 (2006) 2009 2009 54-55 (2009) 2009 53 http://gender.wrp.org.tw/uploads/%7b898deba8-3d1f- 4A76-8766-C544595402FB%7D_2009CSW.pdf 2011 9 15 (2008) http://www. taiwanngo.tw/proinfo_more.asp?id=6525&subjectid=3713 2011 9 15 (2008) HIV 63 34-40 (2010a) SQC 7 1-3 (2006) 95 (2005) 94 (2006) HIV 16 4 http://www.nics.org.tw/old_nics/magazine/16/04/16-4-4.htm 2012 10 10 (2010) (2010) 22 http://www2.cdc.gov.tw/aidstbenews/ aidstbenews22/hot022-06.html 2012 10 10 (2011a) http://icarehiv.taiwanaids.org.tw/about/ work, 2011 5 29 (2011b) http://icarehiv.taiwanaids.org.tw/about/ intro, 2011 5 29 134

愛滋治理與在地行動 (2011c) Mr. Jimmy http://icarehiv.taiwanaids. org.tw/node/33, 2011 5 29 (2011d) http://icarehiv.taiwanaids.org.tw/ node/34, 2011 5 29 (2009) 38-39 (2008) 6 1 27 http://www.libertytimes.com.tw/2008/new/jan/27/today-life2.htm 2011 8 15 (1997) 125-148 (2004) 16 10-13 (2009) 12 1 http://msmtaiwan. blogspot.com/2009_11_01_archive.html 2011 9 1 (2004) 46 2-3 (2004) 3 24 (2010) MSM 21 http://www.cdc.gov.tw/aidstbenews/aidstbenews21/hot021-04. html 2011 9 1 (2012) 8 21 http://news.chinatimes.com/focus/11050105/1120120821 00088.html 2012 10 10 (2009) 6 25 http://health.chinatimes.com/contents.aspx?cid=4,29&id=6726 2011 9 1 (2010) 45-60 (1991) 12 18 (2005) MSM HIV 94 (2010) 135

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 21 http://www2.cdc.gov.tw/ aidstbenews/aidstbenews21/hot021-02.html 2012 10 10 (2009) 181-196 (2009) http://gsrat.net/library/lib_post.php?pdata_id=224 2012 10 25 (2011a) http://www.coolloud. org.tw/node/65501 2012 10 10 (2011b) http://gsrat.net/ library/lib_post.php?pdata_id=289 2012 5 12 (2012) : 15 (2004) 7 20 (1995) (2000) (2008) 62 6-17 (2009) 27-32 (2008) HIV 15 http://www.cdc.gov.tw/aidstbenews/ aidstbenews15/international015-03.html 2011 8 15 (2009) (2007) (2012) 365-393 136

愛滋治理與在地行動 林純德 ( 主持人 ) KY 與會者 與會者 137

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 與會者 condom fingdom tandom 138

愛滋治理與在地行動 黃道明 139

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 萬延海 王蘋 140

愛滋治理與在地行動 141

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 nice 142

愛滋治理與在地行動 林純德 黃道明 HIV 143

紅絲帶主流化 : 台灣愛滋 NGO 防治文化與性治理 HIV NGO BB 林純德 144