The China Sustainable Energy Program 2011 11 18 The Energy Foundation San Francisco Office: 301 Battery Street San Francisco, CA 94111, U.S.A. Tel: (415) 561-6700 Fax: (415) 561-6709 Email: china@ef.org Web: www.efchina.org : 19 2403 100004 Beijing Office: CITIC Building, Room 2403, No. 19, Jianguomenwai Dajie Beijing 100004, P.R. China Tel: (86-10) 8526-2422 Fax: (86-10) 6525-3764 Email: china@ef.org Web: www.efchina.org
... 1... 2... 3 2011... A... B... C... D... E
... F... G... H
2011 11 18 S. 9: 00am S. 9:15am 9:35am 9:55am 10:15am 10:30am 10:50am 11:45am 12:00am Eric HEITZ, S.
Eric HEITZ, 1:30pm 1:50pm 2:10pm 2:25pm 2:40pm 3:20pm Joseph SCANGA, Eric HEITZ, 3:30 pm S. 3:45 pm 2011 4:00 pm 2012 5:00 pm S. 5:15 pm
2011 11 18 ( ) 1
(Susan F. TIERNEY) (Colburn WILBUR) (Peter BRADFORD) (Thomas JOHANSSON) 599, 200050 (William REILLY) 2
3
4
5
6
7
.Mark LEVINE (Michael WALSH) (Joseph SCANGA) () ARUP China Khee Poh LAM Michael WANG Hongjun ZHANG (Anji CLUBB) 8
9 (Eric HEITZ) (Jean KU) Diego MONTERO
10
1988 1998 2003 3 IAC 1
8 9 1987 1992 1999 1978 1981 1985 1991 1991 2001 2001 2007 2007 4 2006 12 2007 12 2008 3 2
,,, 1986 1999 10 1991 1992 1980 1983 1996 1991 2001 1977 1991 1995 2001 1959 1988 1998 Peter A. BRADFORD 3
Thomas JOHANSSON 1994 UNDP 2000 Vattenfall 2000 K William K. REILLY 1989 1993 1992 1993 1994 TPG Capital, LP ConocoPhilps Ionics F Susan F. TIERNEY 1984 1988 S Colburn S. WILBUR 1976 1999 Sierra club 1999 Sierra 4
2011 11 1 NMM TOD 1. 2. 3. 4. TDM 1 2. 1
3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 2 1. 2. 3. 4. 1. 2. 3. 4. 2
3 1. 2. 3. 4. 1 2. 3. 3
1 NMM TOD 1. 2. 6 1
3. BRT BRT 1. 2007 6 75.3, 30% 10 3% 10% 14.3 15% 2. EMME OD 287 2 2011 1 3 2
1000 25%-33% 5% 17% 100 CO2 4.72 3. 2010 6 2011 2012 6 2 3 6 3
2 2011 2 259 90.2% 2011 4
2004 1 2 3 4 5
3 50 100 200 9 22 2011 11 143 6
1. NMM TOD 2010 12 01 300,000 2011 05 01 120,000 2011 05 01 100,000 2011 06 01 300,000 2011 07 01 75,000 2011 07 01 125,000 1
2. 2011 06 01 500,000 2011 06 01 200,000 2011 06 01 100,000 2011 08 01 100,000 2011 09 01 450,000 3. (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) 2010 09 01 240,000 2
(Portland State University) 2010 09 01 150,000 (Univerisity of California, Davis) 2011 04 01 150,000 / 2011 04 01 90,000 2011 04 01 300,000 (University of California, Berkeley) 2011 04 01 150,000 2011 09 01 250,000 3
2011 11 1 1 2. 3. 1 2 3 4 5 1
2 1 2 1 2 3 4. 3 1 3-4 1 2 2
3. 3
1 2011 8 2012 1 1 1
21 5 7 2010 10 2011 21 2
2 2010 65% 65% 8 65% 3
2005 2012 30 150 2011 2012 2012 2008 65%2011 2012 2010-2020 4
2012 2010 2011 2011 3 2011 5
2012 2007 1 (2) (3) (4) 2012 2008 (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) 62009 2010 2011 2009 6
20 2011 7
1. 2010 12 1 150,000 2011 7 1 200,000 2011 7 1 230,000 2011 7 1 70,000 2011 7 1 95,000 2011 8 1 80,000 2. 2011 2 1 80,000 2011 3 1 30,000 2011 3 1 100,000 1
2011 3 1 100,000 2011 5 1 50,000 2011 7 1 150,000 (Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory) 2011 7 1 200,000 2011 8 1 120,000 2011 8 1 150,000 1 2 34 2011 8 1 200,000 2011 10 1 100,000 2
2011 11 1 150,000 2011 11 1 100,000 2011 11 1 150,000 3. -Carnegie Mellon University 2009 10 1 90,000 2010 7 1 150,000 2011 6 1 150,000 2011 11 1 100,000 2010 12 1 150,000 2011 1 1 100,000 3
2011 2 1 128,000 2011 2 1 80,000 2011 4 1 80,000 2011 5 1 100,000 2011 8 1 130,000 2011 8 1 30,000 2011 8 1 30,000 4
2011 11 1 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. 3. 4. 1
2 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 2
3 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 3
1. 2011 1 (2) 3 4 5 6 7. 1. 27 27 5 3 2011 100 1
2. 2009 GBT23331-20092010 2011 6 ISO50001. 2011 2010 2
2. 1. 1.56 2. 2011 5, 3
. 2006 4
3.. 1. 2010 1 UAIEE 16 40 2011 14 13 (1) 2 3 5
4 5 67 8) 2. 2011 9 11 1 2 3 4 5 6
1. 2011 2 1 180,000 2011 3 1 160,000 2011 6 1 100,000 Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory) 2011 4 1 345,000 2011 5 1 100,000 2011 5 1 50,000 2011 5 1 150,000 2011 5 1 50,000 1
2011 6 1 200,000 2011 8 1 200,000 2011 6 1 100,000 2011 8 1 100,000 2. 2011 1 1 150,000 2011 5 1 200,000 2011 5 1 120,000 2008-2010 2011 2011 6 1 120,000 2
2011 6 1 80,000 2011 6 1 130,000 2011 7 1 100,000 2011 7 1 120,000 2011 10 1 150,000 3. 2011 2 1 100,000 2011 4 1 120,000 2011 4 1 120,000 2011 4 1 9 100,000 3
2011 5 1 150,000 2011 7 1 350,000 2011 7 1 150,000 2011 8 1 150,000 2011 8 1 120,000 2011 9 1 200,000 2011 10 1 186,000 2011 11 1 180,000 4
2011 11 1 150,000 5
2011 11 1 1 2 3 4 5 6. 12020 10% 2 3 1
4 5 2
1 2009 2010 2010 2011 1
2010 2020 2030 2011 2050 2050 2011 10 2
2020 15% 2010 2011 2011 100 1000 2009-2010 3
2015 2020 1 1.5 1000 5000 2010 4
2011 2012 2010 12 5
4 UWIG 2010 2010 4000 2010 2030 10% 10% 6
2010 6 2010 2011 2009 2010 2010 2020 3000 1000 100 2007 2010 8 2015 2020 7
2015 2020 5179 1.19 2015 2020 2010 GHG 2011 8
2010 800 50 6% 2015 1000 2020 5000 2015 300 2020 2500 2011 8 1 2010 2011 8 12 2015 1 / 2020 0.8 / 2015 0.8 / 2020 0.6 / 2030 0.6 / 2015 9
2020 2010 10
1 2010 6 1 180,000 2010 11 1 100,000 2010 11 1 120,000 2010 11 1 100,000 2011 5 1 120,000 2011 6 1 150,000 2011 9 1 40,000 2050 2010 1 1 80,000 1
2010 5 1 120,000 2010 6 1 120,000 2010 8 1 80,000 2010 6 1 60,000 2010 6 1 120,000 2011 10 1 300,000 2010 6 1 120,000 2011 6 1 180,000 2010 8 1 90,000 2010 8 1 80,000 2
2010 8 1 80,000 2010 10 1 200,000 2010 8 1 200,000 2011 7 1 200,000 2010 8 1 120,000 2010 8 1 90,000 2010 10 1 150,000 2010 10 1 120,000 2010 12 1 300,000 2011 8 1 100,000 3
2011 1 1 60,000 2011 1 1 180,000 2011 5 1 100,000 2011 6 1 150,000 (Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory) 2011 8 1 180,000 2011 9 1 60,000 4
2010 11 1 130,000 2010 11 1 150,000 2010 11 1 200,735 2010 11 1 110,000 2011 3 1 150,000 2011 4 1 120,000 2011 5 1 150,000 2011 6 1 100,000 2011 6 1 150,000 3
Natural Resources Defense Council) 2011 8 1 80,000 2011 8 1 130,000 2011 10 1 139,000 2011 10 1 130,000 2011 10 1 400,000 3. 2010 11 1 21 210,000 2011 10 1 160,000 4
2011 11 1 1 2 3 1. 2 3 / 1
2...... 3 /, 3 1IGCC 2. IGCC 3 4 IGCC(CCS) 5 IGCC/ CCS 2
1 IGCC 2 IGCC CCS 3 IGCC CCS 4 IGCC CCS 3
1 2002 2010 11 2011 1 1 2011 2011 5 (Natural Resources Defense Council) (The Regulatory Assistance Project) (Natural Resources Defense Council) 2011 7 100 2000 4000 1
2011 7 6 60 100 1200 2009 2009-2013 150 100 2011 2010-2015 2
2010, 2010 2011 2011 2. 3
2010 5, 2011. 2009, 2011 1. 4
2011 5 2010 2010 2030 2011 2009 2011. 2009 2010 4 2010 8 2010 9 2011 5 5
2011 7, 2011 3 4% 8% 2015 2600 2010 2011 1% 6
2006 2008 2009 2009 11 2010 6 6 1 2010 10 10 () 2011 7
3 2010 9.62 7.07 75% 2050 50% 80% IGCC CCS IGCC IGCC 863 IGCC 2008 2010 IGCC 2011 2008 2009 CCS 2010 2011 8
IGCC/ IGCC IGCC/ 9
1. 2010 10 1 200,000 2011 8 1 140,000 () 2010 10 1 100,000 2010 10 1 150,000 2010 11 1 80,000 2010 11 1 80,000 Natural Resources Defense Council) 2010 11 1 450,000 2011 5 1 120,000 1
2011 5 1 120,000 2011 6 1 150,000 2011 6 1 200,000 2011 6 1 120,000 2011 8 1 180,000 2011 8 1 140,000 2011 8 1 140,000 2011 10 1 140,000 2. 2010 10 1 125,000 2
2010 11 1 130,000 2010 11 1 150,000 2010 11 1 200,735 2010 11 1 110,000 2011 3 1 150,000 2011 4 1 120,000 2011 5 1 150,000 2011 6 1 100,000 2011 6 1 150,000 3
Natural Resources Defense Council) 2011 8 1 80,000 2011 8 1 130,000 2011 10 1 139,000 2011 10 1 130,000 2011 10 1 400,000 3. 2010 11 1 21 210,000 2011 10 1 160,000 4
2011 11 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. 3. 1
4. 5. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 2
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 3
2010 6 1
PM2.5 2010 PM2.5 PM2.5 2
PM2.5 PM2.5 1,259 GDP 3.41% GPS GPS 9 3
2011 11 VOCs 2010 6 4
2011 8 5
PM2.5 2011 11 2012 6
1. 2010 5 1 100,000 2010 9 1 100,000 2010 9 1 100,000 2010 9 1 130,000 (Natural Resources Defense Council) 2011 1 1 120,000 2011 8 1 150,000 2011 9 1 100,000 1
2011 11 1 80,000 2. 2010 5 1 200,000 2011 10 1 101,700 2010 6 1 90,000 2010 11 1 80,000-2010 11 1 100,000 GAINS 2010 8 1 135,000 2010 9 1 100,000 2010 10 1 100,000 2010 11 1 80,000 2
2010 11 1 80,000 2010 11 1 80,000 2010 10 1 80,000 2011 10 1 125,000 2010 11 1 150,000 (International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis) 2010 11 1 49,908 GAINS 2010 11 1 80,000 (International Sustainable System Research Center) 2011 1 1 69,640 2011 3 1 60,000 The Regulatory Assistance Project 2011 3 1 105,000 3
2011 11 1 91,090 NOx,VOCs, (Clean Air Initiative - Asia) 2011 5 1 100,000 2011 8 1 115,000 VOCs 2011 9 1 100,000 2011 9 1 120,000 2011 9 1 100,000 2011 10 1 110,000 (chinadialogue) 2011 10 1 35,070 4
2011 11 1 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1
2 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 3 1 2 3. 2
1 2 3. 4 1 2 3 4 5 TOP100 100 6 7 8 1 2 3 TOP 100 4 3
5 4
1 1. CAFC 18.6% 2015 7L/100km 167g/km WTO 2. 1. 2010 5 1.6 3000 1
1.6 10 1 8% 427 90% 1. 2010 2011 4 2010 5 2006-2010 3.1% 2002-2006 11% 2
2. 2001 2009 12 7 1 5 12 2014 1 1. 2011 5 1 1. NO X 2010 3
. / NO X NO X 60%. 2007 2010 2011 V 4
3 5-10 2009 4 2010 7 2011 5 CSS 90 5
6
1. 2010 7 1 70,000 2010 11 1 150,000 2011 9 1 55,000 2010 12 1 68,000 2011 1 1 200,000 2010 2011 1 1 100,000 2011 4 1 35,000 2011 5 1 120,000 1
2011 10 1 120,000 2. 2010 6 1 120,000 2010 7 1 70,000 2010 9 1 150,000 2010 7 1 80,000 2010 12 1 360,000 2011 9 1 120,000 / 2011 9 1 80,000 2011 9 1 80,000 2
2010 11 1 200,000 (The International Council on Clean Transportation) 2010 12 1 65,000 2011 1 1 100,000 2011 1 1 80,000 IV V 3. 2010 11 1 250,000 2010 12 1 120,000 University of California, Davis 2010 12 1 50,000 2011 4 1 50,000 3
2011 4 1 120,000 2011 5 1 140,000 4. 2010 12 1 120,000 2011 1 1 150,000 2011 8 1 80,000 2011 10 1 200,000 4
2011 11 1 1 GDP 2 3. 1 2 3. 1
2 1. 2 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 2
4. 4 1. 2 3 1 2 3 3
1 1
ICET 2: 7 2
3 20% CDM 2011 5 3
4 3 9 4
GDP CCS 5
6
1 2010 11 1 100,000 2011 11 1 40,000 2011 11 1 90,000 2011 12 1 160,000 Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory 2011 2 1 295,000 2011 4 1 100,000 1
2011 4 1 160,000 2011 4 1 90,000 2011 4 1 23,000 (Innovation Center for Energy and Transportation) 2011 5 1 120,000 2011 5 1 120,000 2011 5 1 120,000 2011 7 1 120,000 2
2011 7 1 200,000 2. 2011 4 1 120,000 3. 2011 7 1 150,000 4. Center for Climate Strategies 2011 4 1 175,000 2011 8 1 130,000 2011 9 1 130,000 2011 9 1 158,800 3
2011 9 1 150,000 2011 9 1 100,000 2011 9 1 120,000 4