: 2016 6 CJS 36 : : : DOI:10.15992/j.cnki.31-1123/c.2016.06.004 Unfinished Natural Sociability : Human Nature and NormativityoftheModernSociety LI Meng Abstract:NaturalSocietyintendstoinvestigatethedoctrineofhumannatureand normativityarticulatedbythomashobbesandothermembersofthe modern naturallawschoolconcerningtheconstitutionofmodernmoralworld.thestate ofnaturenaturalrightsornaturallawandsocialcontractarethreedecisive momentsof modern moralorder.thetheory ofnaturalstateadvanced by HobbesandGrotiussynthesizedtheapparentoppositeself-loveandsociability andthusprovidedastartingpointformodern moralphilosophy.thestateof natureasmoralspaceshouldnotbeunderstoodanormativeorderwiththe * : (Author:LIMeng Department ofphilosophy PekingUniversity ; InstituteofForeignPhilosophy PekingUniversity ) E-mail: limengemail@126.com 78
: naturalorobjective measurebeyondsubjectivenaturalrights.inthe modern worldnormativityis madesimultaneously withthesocialcontract which constitutestheleviathan. Keywords:naturalsociability HobbesHuman Naturethestateof Nature normativity : ( ) : 17 (2016) ; : ( 2015: 3 ); 79
2016 6 ( 2015: 6-7 ); 18 (2016:39-40) : 2015 6 (2015) (2016) 18 (2016) 80
: (Gemeinschaft) (Geselschaft) 17 1 1. ( 2002:703-704) 81
2016 6 ( 2012) (2016) : (2016) ( :1168a29ff) ( 82
: 1988: 2 Riesmanetal.2001:ch. 6-8) ; ( 2015: 19 ) (2007) (2016) ( 2010:3-5) (2016) 83
2016 6 ( ) ( ) (2016) (2016) ( 2015: 5 ) 84
: ( ) (Hobbes1966vol.I: vi.2; 2015: 8 177 ) (2016:61) : ; ; (Hobbes2012:v.3) (arightreasonconstitutedbynature) 85
2016 6 2 (rightly ) 13 (nothingcanbeunjust) (Hobbes2012:xi.13) ( Wilkür) ( 2015:139-140) ( 2015: 6 ) : (2016) 2. ( Hobbes1994:xix.8) (Hobbes1983) : (rectaerationisdictamenestlexnaturae.i.15 pasiminch.i- I esp.seei.1) : (I.25) : ( ) (I.1) (comp.hobbes2012:xv. 34cf.vi.23; 2015:293 1) (2016) 86
: (2016) (Straus1971:183-184193) : (duty ) (theindividualregardlesofhisqualities) (Straus1971:183-185n.193) 87
2016 6 (2016) ( ) (maker sknowledge) ( ) ( ) 3 3. (Straus1971) : ( 2001) ( 2001:532-33) : ( 2001:166) 88
: 4 5 ( ) : (notonly byrightbutalso by necesityofnature) ; 4. (Hobbes1983) (a necesitate) (iusnaturale ) (cumiure...tum necesario...) (I.3:iure...necesitatenaturae; I.18necesitatenaturali; I.9iure...necesitatenaturali) (I.4) (AdLectores) (VI.4IX.3) : (Hobbes1983:XVI.27 cf.ix.3) (rectaratio) (iusteetiure) ( ) (mensuraiuris.i.710) (2016) 5. :Hobbes1994:ix.14x.3 (comp.vi.1) (xiv.612cf.xx.14) (xi.3) (xvi. 16) ( xix.2 xiv.13) ( ) 89
2016 6 (Hobbes2012:xv.17;Hobbes1983:I.9;Hobbes1994:xvi.8) 6 : (Hobbes2012:xi.14xxv.2) ( 2015: 18 ) (Hobbes2012:xiv.3-4xvi.2) (Hobbes2012:xvi.9-11) 6. : (naturaenonmodolegesedetiamnecesitate) (xxi.4) ( 2015: 6 ) 90
: (Hobbes 2012:xv.38-41xxvi.8) 7 : ( ) (Hobbes2012:xvi.2comp.v.3. ) (lawfuly licitum) ; (Hobbes 2012:xxvi.21) ( ) (Hobbes1991:xi.4) (Hobbes2012:xi.13) (Hobbes2012:xxx.14) ( j ustitiaeorigoprima) ( ) (Hobbes 7. (thescienceofnaturaljustice) (Hobbes2012: xxxi.41xxvi.14;hobbes1966:vol.vi.p.471) (Hobbes2012:xxx.30) : ( 2015:316-319) 91
2016 6 1983:AdLectores) (2016) ( 2015: 20 ) 92
: 8 (2016:73) (2016:128) ( ) 8. (2016:71-73) laydown : (simplyrenouncing ) ; (transferring ) ( ) (notcontractbutgiftfreegift) ( 2015:391) 28 give giveaway concesionorgift ( ): ( giveaway ) (concesionorgift) 93
2016 6 : 17 ; (fiat) (artificial person) (Hobbes 1991:xv.4) : (Hobbes2012:xx.4-8 comp.xvi.2xi.11; 2015: 7 ) ( ) ( 2015:112-114) ( 94
: 1988: 2 1 17 ) ( 2015: 22 8 ) : Home-madehome-made Butaren tweal (References).2016. : [ J ]. (6):55-77..2016. ( ). (2016 6 )..2016. [ J ]. (3):117-125..2016. [ J ]. (3):126-133..2015. [ J ]. (12):112-121..2010. : [ J ]. (5):1-30..2012. : [ J ]. (10):87-106. 95
2016 6.2015. : [M]...2002. [M].. :..2007. [M].. :..2001. : [M].. :..1988. [M].. :..2016. : [ J ]. (6):32-54..2016. [ J ]. (6):1-31. HobbesThomas.1966.TheEnglish Worksof Thomas Hobbesof Malmesbury ( 1839) editedby Wiliam Molesworth.Aalen:ScientiaVerlag. HobbesThomas.1983.De Cive:TheLatin Versioneditedby Howard Warrender. Oxford:ClarendonPres. HobbesThomas.1991. Manand Citizenedited by Bernard Gert.Indianapolisand Cambridge:HacketPublishingCompany. HobbesThomas.1994.ElementsofLaw NaturalandPoliticeditedbyJ.Gaskin.Oxford: OxfordUniversityPres. HobbesThomas.2012.Leviathaneditedby Noel Malcolm.Oxford:ClarendonPres ( Curley :editedbyedwincurley.hacketpublishing Company 1994). RiesmannDavidNathanGlazerandReuelDenney.2001.TheLonely Crowd:A Studyof thechanging American Character.New Heaven:YaleUniversityPres. StrausLeo.1971.NaturalRightand History.Chicago:UniversityofChicagoPres. : 96