HOUSE [18] [19] ; WEBER [8] HOUSE [1] [20] [9] CEO 1CEO [10] 1.1 ;2 [11] [21] [12] [22] [13] [14] [12] SHAMIR [6] 1 ;2 [15] [2

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "HOUSE [18] [19] ; WEBER [8] HOUSE [1] [20] [9] CEO 1CEO [10] 1.1 ;2 [11] [21] [12] [22] [13] [14] [12] SHAMIR [6] 1 ;2 [15] [2"

伸风孙
5 years ago
Views:

1 ChineseJournalofManagement Vol.12No.2 Feb.2015 DOI /j.issn x ( ) ; ; ; ; ; C93 A X(2015) TheRelationshipbetweenCharismaticLeadershipandPerformanceA Meta-Analysis HU Haijun WENG Qingxiong CAO Weilin (UniversityofScienceandTechnologyofChinaHefeiChina) AbstractCharismaticleadershipwasarguedinlotsofresearchhoweverweneverclearlyknow whetheritisbeneficialtoperformance.using Meta-analysisweconductedaqualitativereviewonthe literaturesoftherelationshipbetweencharismaticleadershipandperformanceinindividualgroup andorganizationlevel.a12933sampleincludedin53valuablepaperswasselectedthroughliterature searchtheanalysisonwhichshowedthatcharismaticleadershipispositivelyrelatedtoeachlevelof performance;therelationship betweencharismaticleadershipand organization performanceisthe highestfolowedbygroupperformanceandindividualperformance;themeasurementofcharismatic leadershipandregionalculturemoderatedstherelationshipbetweencharismaticleadershipandindivid- ualperformance.thedirectionoffurtherstudyingcharismaticleadershipwasdiscussedaswel. Keywordsleadership;performance;levelsofanalysis;meta-analysis;moderatedefect [56] [1] 30 [2] [7] [3] [4] ( ); ( ); ( ); 223 转载

2 HOUSE [18] [19] ; WEBER [8] HOUSE [1] [20] [9] CEO 1CEO [10] 1.1 ;2 [11] [21] [12] [22] [13] [14] [12] SHAMIR [6] 1 ;2 [15] [23] 53 [16] 2 ( CEO) [24] 1.2 [17] [25] 224

3 ) ( ) [26] [27] 6 ( ) 2 ; EBSCO ElsevierScienceDirect Emer ald Springer SAGE Wiley ; CNKI CSSCI [10] (multifactorleadership questionnairemlq) C-K 1 [5] WALD- ;2 MAN [4] ; T F ;4 ;5 7 ; ( ) ; ; [28] [29] 1 LOWE [30] ( 225

4 MLQ ( ) ( ) 2.3 [31] Com- prehensivemeta Analysis ROTHSTEIN [32] 5K+10(K ) (K = 28); 1~ (K = 11); ( ) 1~ (K =14) Fisher sz Fisher sz Q ;I-squared ;Tau-squared Q (p<0.001) ;I-squared % % ; Tau-squared 0.006

5 0.6% 1 1 ;2 [33] 1 (Q ) Tau-squared Q df(q) p I-squared Tau-squared SE Tau < < < < < (p <0.001) (N =10316) ( 2) 2 1~ (p < 0.001) 11 (N = 848) 0.271(p < 0.001) 14 (N =1769) 2 95% N Z p < < <0.001 (r = ( 3) 0.232p <0.001 ) 3 (r=0.178p <0.001); MLQ 16 (N = 5835) 12 (N = 4481); MLQ (r= 0.229p <0.001) 22 (N =7960) (r=0.140p <0.001) 6 (N =2356); (N =8620) 3 5 (N =1696) 95% Q df p N Z p < < <0.001 MLQ < < < <

6 [3536] 3 MLQ MLQ [2021] [37] MLQ WALDMAN [21] 3 ( ) ; ENSARI [34] ( ) ; 2 ( ) 1 228

7 2 Charismaand OrganizationalChangeA Multilevel MLQ Study of Perceived Charisma Commitment to Changeand Team Performance [J]. Leadership Quarterly201324(2)378~389 [3]SHAMIRBHOWELL J M. Organizational and ContextualInfluencesonthe Emergenceand Efec- tivenessof Charismatic Leadership[J].Leadership Quarterly199910(2)257~283 [4]WALDMAN D ARAMIREZG GHOUSERJet 3 al.doesleadership Mater CEO LeadershipAtrib- utesandprofitability UnderConditionsofPerceived EnvironmentalUncertainty[J].AcademyofManage- mentjournal200144(1)134~143 [5]CONGERJAKANUNGO R N.CharismaticLead- 4 ershipinorganizations[m].new YorkSage1998 [6]SHAMIRBHOUSE R JARTHUR M B.The MotivationalEfects of Charismatic LeadershipA Self-ConceptBasedTheory[J].OrganizationScience 19934(4)577~594 ; [7]BERGMANN D.DevelopingCharisma with Caution [C]//CANDANLL D. Leadership Lessons from WestPoint.ChichesterJohn Wileyand Sons Ltd ~252 [8]WEBER M.TheTheoryofSocialandEconomicOr- ganization[m].new YorkOxfordUniversityPress 5 [9]FANELLIAMISANGYIV FTOSIH L.InCha- 1 risma WeTrustTheEfectsofCEO CharismaticVi- sionson Securities Analysts[J].Organization Sci- ence200920(6)1011~1033 [10]AVOLIOBJBASS B M.MultifactorLeadership ;2 Questionnaire(MLQ)[M].Palo AltoMind Gar- den2004 ( ) [11]HOUSERJSPANGLER W DWOYCKEJ.Per- sonalityandcharismaintheuspresidencya Psy- chologicaltheoryofleaderefectiveness[j].ad- ;3 ( ministrativesciencequarterly ~396 ) [12]JACOBSEN CHOUSE RJ.DynamicsofCharis- matic Leadership A Process TheorySimulation ;4 53 ModelandTests[J].LeadershipQuarterly (1)75~112 [13]. [J] (8)68~69 [14]EREZAMISANGYIV FJOHNSON DEetal. StirringtheHeartsofFolowersCharismaticLead- [1]HOUSERJ.A1976 TheoryofCharismaticLeader- ship Efectiveness [M ]//HUNT JLARSON L. LeadershipTheCutingEdge.CarbondaleSouthern IlinoisUniversityPress1977 [2]NOHECMICHAELIS B MENGES JIetal ershipasthetransferalofafect[j].journalofap- pliedpsychology200893(3)602~616 [15]HOWELLJMSHAMIRB.TheRoleofFolowers inthe Charismatic Leadership ProcessRelation- shipsandtheirconsequences[j].academyofman- agementreview200530(1)96~

8 [16]MOSSS ARITOSSA D A.TheImpactofgoal Orientationonthe Associationbetween Leadership style and Folower Performance Creativity and WorkAtitudes[J].Leadership20073(4)433~ 456 [17]LIM BC PLOYHART R E. Transformational LeadershipRelationstotheFive-FactorModeland Team Performancein Typicaland Maximum Con- texts[j].journalof Applied Psychology (4)610 [18]HOUSERJADITYA R N.TheSocialScientific StudyofLeadershipQuo Vadis [J].Journalof Management199723(3)409~473 [19]KARK RSHAMIRBCHEN G.TheTwoFaces oftransformationalleadershipempowermentand Dependency[J].Journalof Applied Psychology (2)246 agement199723(3)213~237 [20]CANNELLA A A MONROE M J. Contrasting PerspectivesonStrategicLeadersTowarda more realisticviewoftop Managers[J].JournalofMan- [21]WALDMAN D A YAMMARINO F J. CEO CharismaticLeadershipLevels-of-Managementand Levels-of-AnalysisEfects[J].AcademyofManage- mentreview199924(2)266~285 [22]LIAO HCHUANG A.TransformingServiceEm- inglong-termservicerelationships[j].journalof AppliedPsychology200792(4)1006~1019 [23]. [35]. Meta [J]. 2012(8)10~14 LA S Aetal.CulturalInfluenceson Leadership andorganizationsprojectglobe[j].advancesin GlobalLeadership19991(2)171~233 mentreview199823(2)285~304 [26]HOFSTEDE GHOFSTEDE GJMINKOV M. Culturesand OrganizationsSoftwareofthe Mind [M].LondonMcGraw-Hil1991 [27]EARLEY PC.SocialLoafingandColectivismA Comparisonofthe UnitedStatesandthePeople s terly198934(4)565~581 nalof Economic Behavior & Organization (4)423~446 ployeesandclimatea MultilevelMultisourceEx- aminationoftransformationalleadershipinbuild- [24]HOUSERJHANGESPJRUIZ-QUINTANIL- [25]CHEN CCCHEN XPMEINDLJR.How Can Cooperation Be Fostered The CulturalEfectsof Individualism-Colectivism[J].AcademyofManage- RepublicofChina[J].AdministrativeScienceQuar- [28]LEETE L.WageEquityandEmployee Motivation innonprofitandfor-profitorganizations[j].jour- [29]BOERNERS.ArtisticQualityinanOperaCompa- nytowardthedevelopmentofaconcept[j].non- profit Managementand Leadership200414(4) 425~436 [30]LOWE K BKROECK K GSIVASUBRAMANI- AM N.EfectivenessCorrelatesofTransformational andtransactionalleadershipa Meta-AnalyticRe- viewofthemlq Literature[J].LeadershipQuarter- ly19967(3)385~425 [31]PASCOEE ASMART RICHMAN L.Perceived DiscriminationandHealthA Meta-AnalyticReview [J].PsychologicalBuletin (4)531~ 554 [32]ROTHSTEIN H RSUTTON AJBORENSTEIN M.PublicationBiasin Meta-AnalysisPrevention AssessmentandAdjustments[M].ChichesterJohn WileyandSonsLtd2006 ysis[m].thousandoakssage2001 [33]LIPSEY M WWILSON DB.PracticalMeta-Anal- [34]ENSARINMURPHYSECross-CulturalVaria- tionsin Leadership Perceptionsand Atributionof CharismatotheLeader[J].OrganizationalBehavior andhumandecisionprocesses200392()52~ 66 [J] (8)1118~1125 [36]. [J] (11)1704~1709 [37]. [J]. 2008(1)67~71 ( ) (1981~) ( ) q.weng@uq. edu.au 230

CULTURAL SENSITIVITY

CULTURAL SENSITIVITY 第四课文化敏感度介绍每个国家都有自己的文化我们通常会把每个民族当作一种文化, 却忘记每个民族里也存在着多种文化词典对文化是这样定义的 : 一些特定的人或人群的文化, 和习惯另一种定义是 : 客观地了解文化差异性和相似