,,,,,,,,,,,, 1 2 3
4 5 6 7 1187 Glanvill 8 70 HenrydeBracton 13 9
12 13 1243-1254 Rechtsstaat[ ] rule by law 10 11 13 12 1215 1222 13 13 14
15 16 17 18 William Black stone 17 18 Duncan Kennedy 17 18 19 A.V.Dicey
19 20 21 JosephRaz 22 23 20 24
25 26 27 28
29 30 31 32 John Finnis 33 34 35
36 37 38 39 1. 21 21 40 41 42 2.
43 44 promulgation 45 3. 45 46 4. 47 48
5. A A 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 2 49 6. 50 7. 51
52 8. 53 54 55 56 57
58 9. 59 10. 60 61 62 70
63 65 66 67 Laurence H.Tribe 1989 68
69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77
78 79 80 81
82 83 84 rule book 85 -- 86 87 88
89 90 91 92 93 94
95 96 97 98
99 100 101 1979 102
1 HaroldBerman Harold J.Berman TowardanIntegrative Jurisprudence Politics Morality History 76 California Law Review 1989 pp.779 787 2 The Politics BookIII Ch 16. 3 1965 199 4 5 Friedrich A Hayek The Constitutionlf Liberty The Universityof Chicago Press 1978 p.167 6 TheKigestlfjustinian9 Theodor Mommsen & Paul Kruegereds. Alan Watsontrans. 1985. 7 BruceW.Frier Autonomy of Law and the Origins of the LegalProfession 8 Cardozo Law Review 1990 p.259 9 -- 1993 554 10 Henry De Bracton On the Law and Customs of England George E.Woodbineed. SamuelE.Thome Trans. 1968 p.20 11 259
12 12 13 1984 38 13 628 14 1996 1-8 17 1995 54 51 740 15 46 16 53-54 17 GuriAdemi Legal Intimations Michae loakeshott andthe Rule of Law Winscosin Law Review 1993 p.845. 18 1993 86-116 159-168 19 < > 1992 422-423 20 Albert.V.Decey Introduction to the Law of the Constitution 1885 1960 pp.202-203. 21 11
22 Guri Ademi Legal Intimations Michae loakeshott andthe Rule of Law Winscosin Law Review 1993 pp.844-845. 23 Joseph Raz The Authority of Law Essays on Law and Morality Clarend on Press 1979 p.218 footnote7. Albert.V.Decey 187 24 morality LonL.Fuller TheMoralityofLaw RevisedEdition.YaleUniversityPress 1969 25 LonL.Fuller TheMoralityOFLaw pp.46-94 26 27 Margaret Jane Radin Reconsidering The Rule of Law 69Boston University Law REVIEW 1989 p.786. 28 osephraz TheAuthorityofLaw pp.211-213. 29 JosephRaz TheAuthorityofLaw pp.214-218. 30 JosephRaz TheAuthorityofLaw pp.218-219. 31 JosephRaz TheAuthorityofLaw p.218 footnote7 32 JosephRaz TheAuthorityofLaw pp.222-223 33 JohnFinnis NaturalLawandNaturalRights ClarendonPress 1980 p.270
271 34 JohnFinnis NaturalLawandNaturalRights pp.270-271 35 JohnFinnis NaturalLawandNaturalRights p.270 36 126 6 pp.266-270 37 127 38 39 62-69 496-498 188-190 40 Margaret Jane Radin Reconsidering The Rule of Law 69Bost on University Law REVIEW 1989 pp.785-786 41 42 220 20.LonL.Fuller heauthorityoflaw p.51. 43 44. JohnFinnis naturallawandnaturalrights p.271
45 FreidrichA.VonHayek TheRoadtoSefdom 1944 p.54 46 Johnfinnis NaturalLawandNaturalRights p.271 47 48 49 60 50 LonL.Fuller The Morality of Law pp.70-79 51. John Rawls ATheory of Justice The Belknap Pressof Harvard University Press 1971 pp.236-237 52. 44 1980 230 53 Bryce 1997 9-13 54. 55 LonL.Fuller The Morality oflaw pp.209-210 56 oseph Raz The Authority of Law pp.215-216. 57 Richard A.Posner 1996 294
78 58 Richard A.Posner The Problems of Jurisprudence 1990 p.153 59 1799 Albert.V.Decey Introduction to the Study of the Lawof the Constitution p.188 Paul R.Verkuil Separationof Powers the Rule of Law and Idea of Independence 30Wm.&Mary Law Review.1987 121 60 1995 214 61 1983 193 62 -- 1988 5 63 John Rawls ATheory of Justice p.239. 64 Marc Galanter Why the Haves Come Out Ahead Speculationson the Limits of Legal Change 9 Law and Society Review 1974. 65 JosephRaz TheAuthorityofLaw p.211. 66. 281 66 67 Geoffreyde.Walker The Rule of Law Foundation of Constitutional Demacracy 1988 p.5 68 Laurence H.Tribe Revisiting the Rule of Law 64 New York University Law Review 1989 pp.728-730. 69.LonL.Fuller The Morality of Law p.162. Morality of Law p.40. 70 LonL.Fuller The
71 58 72 73 Richard A.Posner The Problems of Jurisprudence 1990 pp.358 154-155 74 195-196 75 JohnRaz TheAuthorityofLaw p.211. 76 77 78 JosephRaz TheAuthorityofLaw p.229. 219-229 79 LonL.Fuller TheMoralityofLaw p.157 80 Margaret Jane Radin Reconsidering The Ruleof Law 69Bost on University Law Review 1989 pp.783-791 1996 614-625 81. Joseph Raz The Authority of Law pp.221-222. 82. 1998 21-29 83. F.A.Hayek The Constitution of Liberty Chicago 1960 pp.153-154 1997 190-191 conception of freedomunder the law 84. G.C.Roche
148 85.Dowarkin AMatter of Principle Harvard University Press 1985.pp.11-12. 86.JohnRawls ATheoryofJustice p.235. 87.JohnRawls ATheoryofJustice p.235. 88.JohnRawls ATheoryofJustice p.26. 89.JohnRawls ATheoryofJustice p.240. modusviendi John Rawls The Idea of and overlapping Consensus 1987 7Oxford J.lEGALStudy pp.1 9-12. 90.JohnRawls ATheoryofJustice p.241. 91.JohnRawls ATheoryofJustice p.236. 92.JohnRawls ATheoryofJustice p.241. 93.JohnFinnis NaturalLawandNaturalRights p.274. pp.272-275 94. ALLanC.Hutchinson & Patrick Monahan Democracy andthe Rule of Law 1987 95 eoffreyde.walker The Rule of Law Foundation of Constitutional Kemacracy p.42. 96 25 97 LonL.Fuller TheMoralityofLaw pp.91-94 98 L.Wittgenstein Philosophical Investigations G.E.M.Anscombetrans.Rev.ed.1968. Margaret Jane Radin Recon sidering TheRule of Law 69Boston University Law Review 1989 pp.797-801
99 -- 1996 10 127-131 100 5 101 1998 3 4 1998 1997 1998 102 1979