2003 3 : : 87 89 ( ) 92112110 : ( ) : ( ) : : vsc - 1 ; 31
:?? (legitimacy)? (legality) (all or nothing) ( ) ( ) :? : : : 2 : ; : 1999 3 32
( ) : (Charisma) : 1993 51 : 1996 Max Weber Economy and Society : An Outline of Interpretive Sociology Vol :2 tran. by Parsons et al. eds. by Guenther Roth Claus Wittich Univ. of California Press 1978. : ( 3 ) 1997 1000 1002 33
:1992 10 29 ( ) 300 : ( 300 ) : 300 ( ) :? : (meaning)? (legitimacy)?? ( ) ( ) ( ) : (idea type/ idealtypus ) 34
( disenchantment/ entzubauer) ( (Charisma) ) : 11 Goldenweiser (involution) ( ) ( ) 5? ( 50 %)? / (social science involution) [ ] : 1999 : 1996 35
309 : 21 ( ) ( ) : 1996 52 ; : 1970 63 : 1999 277 12 : : 1996 267 : 1996 See introduction Michel Foucault The Foucault Reader ed. and with an introduction by Paul Rabinow Pantheon New York 1984. : 1996 119 36
( ) 31 (unintentional effect/ unanticipated consequences) ( ) ; Michahel Foucault Governmentality. in The Foucault Effect : Studies in Governmentality eds. by G. Burchell et al. The Univ. of Chicago Press 1991. See Fredric Pollock and Fredric Maitland The History of English Law 2nd vol :1 Cambridge Univ. Press 1968. Rita J. Simon The Jury (Lexington Books 1980). : : 1994 77 : 1993 53 : 1994 6 37
? ( ) : ( Hercules) : ( ) : ( ) 1995 319 : 1988 99 : 1996 300 301 :? 1 1 1998 38
( ) (craft) : : : 1994 80 : 2000 7 13 3 :? 1999 : 1999 5 ( ) : 1996 148 ; 8 1990 4 : 1998 8 : 1985 225 ( Edward Haller Carr) 39
(symbolic constructive) (incentive) (what happened) (what happens)? : 7 8 See Julis Cohen The Value of Value Symbols in Law in The Western Idea of Law J C Smith et al eds. Butterworth 1983 pp. 40
( ) a b a b a ( )? (validity claims) : (comprehensive claim) ; ; 41
(truth claim) ; (rightness claim) ; (truthfulness claim) :1 2 3 (inter - subjectivi2 ty) (rational consensus) (ideal speech situation) : :! 8 4 : : 300? :? : 72 125 73 : 1999 : 1980 120 (Habermas The Theory of Communication Vol :1 Boston : Beacon Press 1988. ) 42
( communicative ra2 tion) : 1806 1895 100 ( ) (visible) 43
; ( Gehlen) (deinsititutionalization) ( subjectivization) (project) ( ) : Wie es geschehen ist. ( ) ( : ) ( : ) 44