学报 2017 年第 6 期 1 CDE () K L Z ] T MN CD K TMN 0 ZQ5K c MN = R "7 G MN 4 YQR Y Y YE 5J Y MN c * E MN MNMN R"7 G MN ] MN VWc!"#$# %&' % $ Q W D < D. >)

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "学报 2017 年第 6 期 1 CDE () K L Z ] T MN CD K TMN 0 ZQ5K c MN = R "7 G MN 4 YQR Y Y YE 5J Y MN c * E MN MNMN R"7 G MN ] MN VWc!"#$# %&' % $ Q W D < D. >)"

仑欻羊
4 years ago
Views:

$S KV V Q &U $D V %J=\ 4D`L \ W I*_7856* = * 8! D`L B I V W*_ U]0 <M c?$

1 学报 2017 年第 6 期 1 CDE () K L Z ]T MN CD K TMN0ZQ5K c MN = R "7 G MN4YQR YYYE 5J Y MN c * E MN MNMN R"7 G MN ] MN VWc!"#$#%&' % $ Q W D < D. >)NOIJ8 I - b W I *_D0! S KV V Q &U $D V %J=\ 4D`L \ W I*_7856* = * 8! D`L B I V W*_ U]0 <M c?! 3 D V W I :C 3*_78=_I K6 58 W I=V; " W 678=2 2] #5 W 5_Ia_ G# W W 6E : 2: ]IK,$78 ` L b W*_=B <K M] 1 W*_=,' %J 8 ' 0 4 W*_=\ S58 W*_=` I J <U W*_= <BV 4]1P+ %& c- W*_= Z 2 K W* _= $ 3 V;U < + 7, = CDO U V; - /, :NU 4 - :FU ' - /81 W K L b 2 <. K L 2 <D

2 bc H W*_= 4 W*_=.1ZbR c W*_= W*_=-0 Q W*_=<Zb W*_ =_` @W*_= a * 8 D 4D W 56Z W*_= D 3V c? 2!" cdb I W= D < ;c ; W*_= az # W* _= ; c_!" O V Z$ 1=D W*_=W*_= D 5D_ V W*_= -ab W 6 W $ W*_= 5]Z =D W*_=W*_?@ F " W*_=4 $P+! " L ZW W*_= 4 89K J= J! " <!" $ _4J 56 6 <@%ZaBS/- & Y $ 15 Z C@ _4= J = 56! " +CC W*_=< 4 W* _=# b 56! " < B # = 4=K c_ #4=V ;! " 89 K W [ c W W W [ < 6Tc< 6W! " D 1) S W BS W <? S! " V WZ!" ^5 4/ - W*_=56 c 6 / 6 NO 6 # 4 56!" - 4 SB=>I =D 134 W*_=2 K W*_=J W- W*_= NM W*_=-# = $_` 89 8 W*_= ZZF C C L 4 W1W W 6 /! 4 a0 CW*_= - 4 W*_= -56 # W*_= "7 %# W*_= # Q=D W*_= [H IJc]< D0 : W9#K W1W W 9#.; W*_= [ 4 W *_ E56 [\

3 学报 2017 年第 6 期 H [\] ZWD^! K D`L 8 `/ # C@ Z W IGHD C 4( C- W I $ :C NO Z IJA J_ D- W I 6 M S W I 6 I ;Q < ) < \ < W I 4 56[\ <D8 2 V W*_= - 0 < W I[\ a#5 W 6 [ c W 9# b W*_= W 9#8 W1W W 6 WW K W1W W 9#.; WWW*_C W9#K I 1V [\c0a < 8 WVV T 56Ga D`LD IJ 56 W.% c.%= K 456 a@ D`L56@ Wc] W _ Ia*_ I _I W 6 6 K 4 I W V; W 4 KI WP+- 9 a W*_7856S 4 I WP+ 56 R V W ][. WJ W 6 K W*_ 未来预测审计机关监督监督监督政策决策政策执行政策评价政策变迁反馈反馈! 审计准备阶段审计实施阶段审计报告阶段后续审计阶段 = c < W 3 KV;[ W 678c Q@<2Q V 政策落实跟踪审计评价 W*_=4 W*_3 65 _$7856 CQ[\ W*_= _I 56H L ZW J W*_=KW*_= W*_= a W*_=2 - W*_= cb 1 F0C < 0 [ <8 K K DQ K K 4S > F[0[I 6< > [ P+ W*_= T D N OE< D >_I >) * +G<DKb[\8 W*_=K

4 bc 0! Y V V =- #5 V V 556 U V V VP W*_= 3- - U =- #5 U W*_4 JS U ( ' W *_=- Q( ' W* ' ' W-#5 Y <;`/ # C@ Z$ W*_=- 1 #5 W*_ 5,' a]" W*_=2 - #5D W* W-- 58[\ W*_ %= W*_= -c] =DD0 W*_= KO DD"8 4 ` 78 [@ W *_= V <b0w*_= ` c] W*_= ; < =5 $ K W*_= 2 ^ <` - ( $A W*_= 2 ^ <2R R / c] [ - + E2 I P+ _ 78 0$78 < =5 ^ < W*_= c0( W*_ I -KW*_=2QT BCO [0F ]W* _ 0Z BC$78 W*_= 8 T O "] c _ T 1Wb / W*_= 5] W*_= W*_=<bW*_= E[0 c]w*_=@ [ a W*_= < 8SIJ- W*_= S *_ J- 34 _ IJI2Q YW*_= 7 S5K F_ #5 W I*_- \" B \" <% $9 \" C\" \"DV\" =_ \" - F K c<4 a ; a -a a a0 * DV =_ \"5]CQ 2Q Y %=J#5 IJ- W*_= 2 4 W 678 W_I 4 $P+56 ( W*_= *,]I W*_= * 0Ob *, ] W*_ = - 8 4= 56a #5 W*_= * 9 5 W*_= 6@A2@ Z Z4 $Z<2 W*_=J4 W*_= * CQ W*_= 8 W*_= H4 W*_= IJ '[b U W*_= V IJc ] Q W*_=

5 学报 2017 年第 6 期 3 : # "7 < %# W*_= H ZW S N_ ` # S W! 3UBS W <D c>c_ # 4S WS W S W S W@ 56[\7 $ Q + < $ ^ c_ 56 S W*_= _`K ] W*_=K _ 4_ # c]_ W*_=8-! " _# _#V 4 W*_= K c]%=w*_=8 - K78 [ < 8 '! # #V 4 W*_= K #5 W378 c]%=w*_=8 - W378 W*_= 2 8 I W*_ K P+a \# R = W 5]W 2 ^ < Q W*_I] >> 4-56 # #V 4 W*_= K #[0A NO 6 56 NO _ c]%=w*_=8 - W*_= NO 8 - "S $ 2 < 8 4NO! 4- &IJ - _ #W*_=0 4 W*_ $56 _ - M] Y 0$ "7 a4 56 => # /#%# W* _=c]58 QW*_= a%= 0 W*_= - L =ZWab c W*_= 6 -W*_= # K[W*_= > _ V W 6 W 6 _ V9 Y # "7 =`B `# K=`# B # _# # ( V 0N 6 NO 6 "7 K` #

6 bc # W*_= - W*_= a 0 8 K/ # # #V W*_= "7 W*_= _ % # J cj [ % #" 8 _# # # 2 34 W*_= 6 _# # "7 K=`# B # _# # T# W1W I P+< ] # [\ _# # # BF_ - 流程维度评价价值维度评价学习与成长维度评价政策落实跟踪审计评价框架形式维度评价! 3 事实维度评价 #8Q1 _# #)*U # _# W*_- "! # #W*_= - W*_= a 0 8V 4 "# 2 " W*_= K4 L # W*_=$J4 E #.1 IF_I W*_=T# [ "# 2 "W Y 0 _# # # #- Q1 ##_ W*_= - # T# < E U, 7P - I : SR@ $ "7 a 4=D W*_=56_ H ZWcK : SR : SR W*_= 2 : 2 ; - " 2: S <T!" SR $ 6[\> U " :S SR _ " c W*_ = I: 56 W*_78S ( W*_ K P+ W*_=K2 ] 56 = 8 : SR 2 W*_= W*_= L W*_= ZK C Z5

7 学报 2017 年第 6 期 6 _ # K # K < $ E 0 C W*_=\ 4 [)* ^ Z56 H* # :U 4 F )* ^ Z *56 [ >) W*_= 0 QZb W*_= Z W*_=-BV "ZE M] - W[& 89 Z "ECV;W*_= C _ W*_= Z_ ^ < Z[ ] [1 I W*_= Z [0 W*_= H 1 [1 S < [)* [ [ W*_= )*70 4E Z56H5]*U : L ZWcK # "7 J /04 W*_= Za <_Za-- "Z MSW *_= a-< E E *_V W I : C 3 *_= NOIJ K 7 8 P+34 c] W*_= Ba- < W*_= % # 56 4 Z56) * _# Z # Z # Z # Z # Z W*_= 3IV S $ 4Z56 <=D W*_= ^ _# Z I a- - " Z W*_= a- _# " # " # " # " # "! GHP ' I P+ Z P+ 4, $> 0 #5I, *+ U 6 / / < LW*_ S% E B-AS 8 P W Y W*_ I 4 _# Z@ -!" Y!" D = ND!" <!"

8 bc $ 1 Z Z F^ %Z! GHP 'I P+ZZ < Z W*_= L; IG]0c] I P+ $5] W*_=@- #5 P+ G B $,/ W*_= K / Z 0 W*_= G B L; P+ 4, $> 0" W*_= K P+[ W S KS S I P+ # P+ H*=P + P+ SIP+ 4, $> 0 S K)!" S K! \# 8\ P+4! " S K!!#5 D & a $6 $ &c c $ &;' $ # Z W*_= - 8 W*_= Q W*_ 58 #5W I- =>-!"!" $ 1, *+ < # Z! Y S 1 L - - =78 \# L - 56 *_ ZC ] 4 -K 1 NO - KZ K4, $> < ) < $P+a4E9 L E-*_7856H _ Y` Q W*_ # Z W- NO _ 0 %= W*_= - Q W*_= W- NO SSF #* # Z4 " 8 ' W*_= C*_ 8S _ = = WA 5 Y!" U 6 / / Z56 # ZK U < W*_=@ K@ B!" M W*_=@ S KZ :! C: _IU- K VU_C: *5 %= - /!" M W*_=@ S KZ U: Y 4 40& 4' K PH &G G -G![ / 8 B $ Z< Z [4P C@ < 58#5 D`L K " 78 P+#5 W*, "- KS 89: W I*_ W*_= KI 2Q6< 6<R ".=4NOR [b I W*_= & # ZK / Z I a

9 学报 2017 年第 6 期 078 # Z D LNO!" W*_= <D 8 L < >) [\ W 6 K L > S K W*_ a58 #5 L c]_ - M] W*_ =K 4 W -H! [0b 4 K bm ck 1 [\1c? < S =8P [ Z KB< < # Z 8 "7 W*_= -=>D L K S % # Z!" & LW*_ S% < L Z ( BC # Z!" &E B-AS Z W*_E B- 4LV _ # Z W*_= " > (-a0k 4 $( * -0 4I 0 W*_= 4V W 8 P+ 56 # \, W Y 0 "7 W*_= - D c / KZ&! " => 8 P W Y W* _ I<@% Z0 W 60 Y 0 [cl!jk)! 3J! 0 Z 8 _ 8 $( 8C![A8 #8 K D 6 L$- C " C 5 T 2 $ ^ Y -D0 V - W 9#4 W*_= 56a W*_= - # "7( _# # # # # $%# W*_= /0 a< W*_= [b W*_=58 % J K=> B4_Z %&!"D D 3*_WKD 34DV W <!," KD!" J] W= ;!9" 56"! " % &'. >2& 4? & & %&*+! " O W 678= O!,"! " V W I*_78 O!,"! " ZW W 6 _W!,"

10 bc! "KDJZ!,"!" - L JZ!,"!"J Z -J Z &!,"!" < J I5P+!,"!"= J 0_`!," 0= L!" Y 3J Z!," K 1! " + C# b W I*_78=!,"! "<# b 4=V;W!," F! " WU S W b!1" IKDIN! " Wb S W!9" 56"! " % >2& 4? & & %&*!" V S W =D W!," O NOU I!" ^5 [H IJ/ - W*_=WU:% <!," =O!"D = ND J!," O!"< S= J Z!," KD!"D.VNO!," T NOU I!" ( 6 _`K%J!," KD6 K! "D c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

:13: 年第 1 期!"#$%&' ]= F7 P 4, K, T T F W J NJ K Y2 CW C S = S U 7

:13: 年第 1 期!#$%&' ]= F7 P 4, K, T T F W J NJ K Y2 CW C S = S U 7 2017-12-21 16:13:44 http://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/32.1317.f.20171221.1609.020.html 2018 年第 1 期!"#$%&' ]= F7 P 4, K,T T F WJ NJ KY2 CW C S = S U 78 C K G C 78 WK Sb; \ 7*" ()*KK7878 F +,-./ 01 0/ *+./.QR