i
1 1 3..13....23..24.....33......42..51..51..52.. 60..69 ii
.. 69..80..91..97..97..98..99....101.... 110.. 110.. 112.. 114.. 115..118.. 131.136 iii
..17..18..19 59..61..62..64..66..75..86 95..96 i
..21..59..61..64..65..65..67..67..67..68
1 1989 Nathan1987:277-299 198971-116 1998 35-6869-100 Hagen Koo 2 1 Samuel P.Huntington 1996 2 1997 502 1
3 199850-7 200088-118 Huntington 4 3 1998 35-6 4 1994103 2
1994102-7 3
5 S.M. Lipset, Political Man( London, Heinemann.1960),p31. 6 4 1995 149 7 1988 151 4
8 Terry Lynn Karl, Dilemmas of Democratizaton in Latin America. Comparatie Politics 23(October), p6-7. 9 1992 26 5
10 6 155 11 Barrington Moore, Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy: Lord and Peasant in the Making of the Modern World(Boton: Beacan Press.1966),p418. 12 6
13 342 1989 12 13-5 14 1989 17 15 31-61 7
8
9
16 Andrew Heywood 1998 112 17 199768-9 Joseph A. Schumpeter1946:266 Robert Dahl1971:8-10 polyarchy Samuel P.Huntington 19965-7 18 Larry Diamond, Juan J. Linz, S.M. Lipset, eds. Democracy in Deeloping Countries (Boulder, Co.:Lynne Rienner Publishers,1988),xi. 19 16 350-2 10
20 50 1993 12 51 21 1997 140 22 45 1991 6 399 23 Werner J. Seerin and James W. Tankard. Jr 1992 11
12
1999113-115 24 24 2000.1257-103 13
14
25 II 26 25 Romon H. Myers 1998 10 199-200 26 II 2002 89-2414-H-110-009 15
16
17
18
1949-70 1972-86 6 7 1 2 7 9 1991113 19
200093 20
21 27 28 1976-1986 1993 29 27 1997 345 28 1997 337
1950 12 7 1952 6 1954 1 13 22
2000136 23
quasi-leninist party 1996218 24
1994 101 1950.12.07 1 2 1 1952.06 2 25
3 4 195810-11 5 1994179 3 1954.01.13 4 5 26
199875 6 7 8 197913 9 6 1241 1972 23 7 2200 1990 4 10 8 9 7 27
1994180-1 10 11 12 10 2000138 11 1986 3 30 ( 1993 ) 153 12 28
13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 13 ( 1993 ) 153 14 ( 1995 ) 223-4 15 16 17 14 225 18 1990 227-8 19 20 110 1986 10 25 13-5 29
21 1993174-5 Stephen Solarz 22 ( 1995531) 21 1986 11 1 ( 1993 ) 175 22 16 30
1995214 1995 293 23 24 23 24 1998 113 31
1995295-6 229 230 32
1997169-171 1994188 33
25 1954 6 1957 6 1969103 1969101 564 25 34
26 1997 133 134 27 28 19666 29 26 16 27 28 29 35
19666 19666-7 199793 30 198790 30 36
122 31 1997171 32 33 34 31 32 Claude Ceoffroy 1997 170 33 1987 123127 34 128 37
35 36 37 38 35 136 36 192 37 156 38 1971 http://serice.pct.org.tw/announce2.nsf/5fc5efa0ab4c92974825673900089b4e/f724aa30430c333048 2567390017d150?OpenDocument 38
39 1988201 119-20 1988213 40 39 33 163 40 1987 222 39
1990 14 41 1987282-3 41 1987 7 23 40
42 43 44 1994169-72 1990206-10 42 40 286 43 44 19987174-5 41
45 1995 302-3 45 1990 4 5 1990 4 5 42
1995209 46 47 48 46 122 1986 6 2 4 47 5 48 1987 225 43
1995216-7 1998159 44
1998194 49 50 51 49 1990 7 3 50 1990 7 3 51 1990 7 3 45
199857-8 46
1987253-4 DC 19987294 47
1987264-5 19879 48
1987265-6 97 52 53 52 53 1987 267-86 49
50
1987119 51
1 112 1 9 11 1959 2 52
53
. 2 2 54
. 1987 128136 55
.. 56
. 57
58
........... 59
... 60
. 1970.2.24. (1973.2.23). 1976.2.27. 1981.2.24. 1984.2.24. 1987.2.24. 1990.2.01....... 16 6 1988 10-5 1990 02 04 4 61
72.73 80.39 80.77 81.44 84.69 79.00 72.31 1987 165-166 191 62
63
19541969 19701972 19731975 19761980 19811983 19841986 19871989 19901991 64
65
19541969 19701972 19731975 19761980 19811983 19841986 19871989 19901991 66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
( ) 1952.02.16 209 1954.07.10 334 1958.02.08 521 1958.09.20 553 1959.03.07 577 1959.08.15 600 1959.08.22 601 1961.12.29 776 1966.04.23 949 1966.05.07 951 1966.08.27 967 1068.09.28 1076 1969.01.11 1091 1969.09.27 1128 1971.11.27 1241 1971.12.04 1242 75
1971.12.25 1245 1972.01.15 1248 1972.04.15 1261 1972.05.06 1264 1972.05.30 1265 1975.06.14 1426 1976.01.10 1456 1978.01.07 1560 1979.02.24 1619 1979.04.14 1626 1979.04.28 1628 1979.06.16 1635 1980.01.05 1664 ( ) 1980.01.12 1665 1980.07.05 1690 76
1981.05.02 1733 1983.03.19 1831 1986.01.25 1980 1986.02.01 1981 1986.03.08 1986 1987.03.07 2038 1987.03.28 2041 1987.05.23 2049 1987.11.21 2075 1993.2.1 1987.12.05 2077 1988.01.23 2084 1988.02.06 2086 1988.02.13 2087 ( ) 1988.02.27 2089 316 218 77
1988.03.26 2093 80.4 98 49.6 1988.03.26 2093 1988.04.16 2096 1988.05.21 2101 1988.07.09 2108 1988.11.12 2126 1989.01.07 2134 1989.04.01 2146 1989.06.17 2157 1989.11.04 2177 1989.11.25 2180 1989.12.01 2183 1990.02.24 2193 1990.03.03 2194 1990.04.14 2200 1990.04.14 2200 78
1990.04.21 2201 1990.05.05 2203 1990.05.12 2204 1990.05.12 2204 1990.07.21 2214 1990.08.04 2216 1990.08.18 2218 1990.11.24 2232 1991.12.31 1991.02.09 2243 1969 1991.03.02 2246 1991 1991.04.06 2251 1991.11.02 2281 1991 9992 168 2290 1951 5 5 1992 1 4 79
199790-92 80
198790-92 106 81
325-6 327 absentee oting sample 82
84 1960 17 1971.01~1972.12 83
197165 84
197116 19718-10 197283 197116197293-95 85
197115197294 197283 197214 197291 1 ( ) 46 1971.10 2/3 46 1971.10 1 86
46 1971.10 46 1971.10 46 1971.10 47 1971.11 48 1971.12 49 1972.01 49 1972.01 49 1972.01 50 1972.02 50 1972.02 50 1972.02 50 1972.02 50 1972.02 54 1972.06 87
56 1972.08 57 1972.09 Legitimacy Legitimacy 88
2 2 3 1979 http://news.yam.com/forum/formosa/formosa-3/ 89
3 1985375 1987105 3 90
1985375 91
92
93
94
95
96
1 1987 272 97
2 98
99
1991113 108 19942-3 100
1984 1981 : 1987 1991 1997 Daid Potter, Daid Goldbalt, Margaret Kiloh, Paul Lewis, 2000 1991 : : 241-264 1997 1997 1993 1976-1986 1993 1995 101
1989 1990 1987 2000 1998Andrew Heywood 1991 : : 105-128 1990 1994 1998 35-6769-100153-200 1985 1995 1991 : : 11-31 1984 1989 102
103 1995 1969 1988 1990 131-135216-220 Claude Ceoffroy 1997 1992 1994 1970 1973 1997 1997 1-46 1996 275-291 1996Samuel P.Huntington 1977 : 1987 1997 501-532 1976
1990-1 1945-1965 1993 1966-1978 1996 1979-1988 1991 : : 81-101 Werner J. Seerin and James W. Tankard. Jr 1992 Romon H. Myers 1998 1989 2 1 71-116 1990 Social Protests and Political Democratization 1 271-303 1992 23 4 72-81 1991 45 385-426 1988 2 1 145-161 2000 57-103 1995 4 135-183 104
1998 1-21 1998 206 50-76 2000 4 3-55 2000 14 13-5 1999 7 113-127 1989 342 13-5 1988 16 6 3-21 1995 26 4 132-46 1997 54 189-209 1993 50 47-78 1992 1997 85-97 1999 7 9-11 1995 4 2 201-212 105
1994 7 12 25-60 1993 Elite Politics in the Process of Taiwan Regime Change(1984-1987) 2 93-130 1996 27 201-34 1995 20 177-234 1998 1990 5 1 84-96 1991 1996 143 6-7 1996 138 2-3 1990 : 127-145 1997 36 8 67-80 2001 1 3 112-7 1997 106
1987 2038 5-10 1957 17 11 323-327 1959 9 11 2-3 1972 49 80-90 1979 3 http://news.yam.com/forum/formosa/formosa-3/ 1958 553 9-12 1990 2201 12-15 1966 951 9-10 1971 48 65 1971 4 11 7-10 1972 49 91-92 1960 22 3 84 1971 46 13-16 1972 49 93-8 1979 1628 13-15 1972 1241 22-24 1960 10 5 17 1979 3 107
http://news.yam.com/forum/formosa/formosa-3/ 1972 50 14-15 1971 http://serice.pct.org.tw/announce2.nsf/5fc5efa0ab4c92974825673900089b4e /f724aa30430c3330482567390017d150?opendocument 1950 12 7 1952 6 1954 1 13 1954 1986 1971 1987 1991 1990 02 04 4 1989 8 16 8 18 168 2290 1951 5 5 1992 1 4 2002 II 89-2414-H-110-009 1994 84-2412-H-004-005 Cheng, Tun-jen and Haggard, Stepan. 1992 Regime Transformation in Taiwan: Theoretical and a Comparatie Perspecties. In Tun-jen Cheng and Stepan Haggard eds., Political Change in Taiwan. Boulder: Lynne Rienner. Cheng, Tun-jen,1989, Democratizing the Quasi-Leninist Regime in Taiwan. World 108
Politics,ol.61, no.4(july):471-499. Chou, Yang-sun and Andrew J. Nathan 1987 Democratizing Transition in Taiwan. Asia Surey,ol.27, no.3,(march):277-299. Dahl, Robert A. Polyarchy: Participation and Opppsition,. New Haen: Yale Uniersity Press,1971) Diamond, LarryLinz, Juan J.Lipset, S.M.eds. 1988, Democracy in Deeloping Countries.Boulder, Co.:Lynne Rienner Publishers, xi. Gold, Thomas B. 1986, State and Society in the Taiwan Miracle. Armonk, N.Y. : M.E. Sharpe. Hsiao, Hsin-Huang,1989 Emerging Social! Moements the Rise of a Demanding Ciil Society in Taiwan. paper presented at conference on Democratization in the R.O.C., Institute of International relation. Lipset, S.M.1960, Political Man.London, Heinemann. Moore Barrington,1966Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy: Lord and Peasant in the Making of the Modern World.Boton: Beacan Press. Schumpeter, Joseph A. 1946, Capitalism,Socialism and Democracy. New York:Harper. Terry Lynn Karl, Dilemmas of Democratizaton in Latin America. Comparatie Politics,ol 23(October), p6-7. 109
110
111
112
113
1954.01.13 114
115
116
117
( ) 31 211 118
119 1954 1951 ( ) (
) 230( 75) 98 (27-18- 53- ) 330 ( ) ( ) ( ) 70% 25% ( )( 120
) 78 81 50 (1951-1954) 121
1951-1954 122 1948
123 52 (
( ) 124
1947 1969 176 125
126
35 34 80% 127
261 26 1990 32 3 3 128
129
2002 II 89-2414-H-110-009 130
1950 1229 1951 0522 5 7 1952 0501 1953 0411 1954 0121 0130 31 1956 0223 1957 1201 absentee oting 1959 0114 0612 50% 1960 0301 1962 0619 1964 0305.. 1966 0317 0319 0406 0523 1969 0327 1220 15 131
11 8 3 1971 0430 28 0428 0611 0506 4 28 0617 1025 763517 0617 1026 0817 1207 1216 1025 22 23 1226 336 1972 0110 0317 0629 58 0727 1106 10 1223 53 51 1975 1220 37 1977 0916 1978 1205 1215 1979.1.1 1216 1220 1979 0118 1229 132
0611 0624 1209 1210 1211 12 10. 1211 1212 12.9 1213 1213 14 1216 10228 1220 1980 0122 0313 0123 30 0422 0125 0228 02 0418 8 0506 0601 0611 1008 1206 69 68% 133
70 57 13 76 63 12 1 1982 0525 0928 1983 0407 0416 0909 100 0918 1983 1023 10 1204 62 9 1984 0902 1985 0301 03 1986 0409 0510 7 0824 0928 7 1206 1987 02 0623 0224 0227 0329 0706 0807 0902 0908 134
0909 1011 11/22 1225 1988 0203 1117 1989 0126 0129 1203 130 1990 0402 0403 26 31 28 6 0418 0621 135
70 136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
1987 165-6191 145