2012 11 11 170 JOURNAL OF RAILWAY ENGINEERING SOCIETY Nov 2012 NO. 11 Ser. 170 1006-2106 2012 11-0078 - 04 ( 中 信 建 筑 设 计 研 究 总 院 有 限 公 司, 武 汉 430014) 1 2 U24 A Comparison between Railway Codes and Building Codes in Design of Support Rail Structure QIU Jian YE Zhi - xiong WEN Si - qing XIE Xian - yi Citic General Institute of Architectural Design and Research Co. Ltd Wuhan Hubei 430014 China Abstract Research purposes Taking the support rail layer of the Guiyang North Railway Station as an illustration this paper comparatively analyzes the calculation result with the railway code and the calculaltion result with building code by the probabilistic limit states method and the permissible stresses method from the areas of the comparison of the calculation results with the typical software the control of the prestress degree of the prestressed beam and the control of the crack of the prestressed beam and discusses the design method for the structure of the support rail layer of the bridge combined with station building. Research conclusions 1 There is no essential conflict between the railway codes and building codes and the reasonable design of the framed support rail structure can be realized by appropriate control of the prestressing degree of the prestressed support rail beam according the railway codes and the building codes. 2 The calculation should be made according to the bridge codes for control of the crack of the framed support rail beam. Key words bridge combined with building support rail beam probabilistic limit states method permissible stress method prestressing degree 1-4 2012-07 - 12 1971
79 PKPM2010 /SATWE Midas Civil 7. 80 2 3 K 5-7 2 mm 1 15 32 12 m 2 1 2 3 135 kn / m 24. 3 kn /m 2 ZK 4 1 200 kn /1. 6 m 200 /1. 6 /5. 55 = 22. 52 kn /m 2 5. 55 6. 4 m 2 ± 0. 00 m - 2. 60 m 64 kn /m 64 /5. 55 = 11. 5 kn /m 2 18 m + 24 m + 18 m 5. 0 kn /m 2 21 m 12 m ± 25 SATWE + 7. 5-7. 5 TB 10002. 1 2005
80 2012 11 4 ZK 4. 4. 4 4. 4. 5 1 5 7 24 10 ~ 20 + 15-15 1 1 MPa 2 1 1 24 m 8 605 14 521 1 500 2 000 24 m 14 502 21 706 24 m 10 738 16 702 M 1 000 3 200 24 m 11 562 14 367 24 m 17 364 25 021 3 000 2 500 24 m 37 810 48 476 1 500 2 000 90 60 184 1 31 1 000 3 200 30 9 /cm 2 84 116 3 000 2 500 135 86 253 232 1 500 2 000 24 m 8. 8 12. 5 1 000 3 200 24 m 8. 3 13. 3 /mm 3 000 2 500 21 m 6. 2 10. 9 3 TB 10002. 3 2005 6. 1. 3 0. 7 λ = σ c /σσ σ c JGJ 140 2004 4. 2. 3 λ 0. 60 λ 0. 75 1 HRB400
81 2. 5% 0. 75 K f σ σ c + γf ct PKPM SATWE σ ct 0. 7f ct σ ct f ct C40 f ct = 2. 70 MPa SATWE 1 500 2 000 0. 7f ct = 0. 7 2. 70 = 1. 89 MPa < 2. 39 MPa 2 2 M M 10768-6210 - 10843 3757-2591 - 3750 M 14525-8801 - 14593 11509-7824 - 11833 3564-2323 - 3601 21706-14521 - 22134 - - - - - - 4 σ ck - σ pc f tk C40 f tk = 2. 39 MPa 5 1 / 64 s 15. 24 64 s 15. 24 /cm 2 131-79 - 131 131-79 - 131 0. 63 0. 70 / 90 s 15. 24 90 s 15. 24 /cm 2 131 131 0. 75 0. 76 / 90 s 15. 24 90 s 15. 24 2 /cm 2 184 184 0. 75 0. 65 3 1 MPa 100% ( 下 转 第 93 页 )
93 Technology 2009 11 1025-1028. 5. J. Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering 2007 2 2009 1 970-975. 195-197. Zhao Xiangping. Risk Control on the Slurry Shield Initiation of Shi ziyang Tunnel J. Railway Construction Technology 2009 11 137-140. 6. 250 m Accident Induced by Urban Underground Project J. 2009 11 137-140. Construction and Its Control Measures J. Journal of Liu Bingke Shi Meng. State Control Technique of Architecture and Civil Engineering 2008 2 1-3. Shield 250 m Radius Curve Lauching Segment Pipe J. Architecture Technology 2009 11 970-975. 7. D. Zhang Dingli Safety Risk Control Technology of Urban 2007 1-5. Underground Engineering Construction J. Science Cheng Zhou. Study on the Design and Application for Paper Online 2009 7 485-487. Safety Control System in Metro Construction Project D. Wuhan Huazhong University of Science & Technology 2007 1-5. China s Underground Engineering J. Chinese 9. J. 2008 2 1-3. Wang Mengshu Zhang Chengping. Analysis of 10. J. 2009 7 485-487. 11. J. 2010 11 68-73. Zhou Ying Ding Lieyun Zhou Cheng etc. Analysis of 8. Adaptability of Slurry Shield for Construction of River - J. 2008 4 650. crossing Tunnel J. Journal of Railway Engineering Qian Qihu Rong Xiaoli. State Issues and Relevant Society 2010 11 68-73. Recommendations for Security Risk Management of 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 檨 ( 上 接 第 81 页 ) 1. Society 2010 8 73-78. J. 2009 12 43-45. Sheng Ping Wang Yi Zhang Nan etc. Study of 5. J. 2010 2 32-36. Vibration Comfort of a Bridge - Station Combined Zhou Mu. The Design and Construction of a Frame Railway Station J. Building Structure 2009 12 43 - Structure of High Railway Station with Double 45. Prestressed J. Special Structure 2010 2 32-36. 2. J. 6. J. 2003 10 62-65. 2007 5 93-95. Sun Junling. Several Problems on the Structural Design Wang Fengyuan. The Application of Prestressed of Station - bridge Structure of Elevated Train Station Project J. Building Structure 2003 10 62-65. Technology in the Design of Elevated Station Structure J. Railway Standard Design 2007 5 93-95. 3. 7. J. 2009 1 31-33. Zhou Yongli Yang Jing. Analysis of Effects Caused by J. 2010 13 88-92. Shrinkage Creep and Temperature on Overhead Chu Songtao Cao Shaowei Gao Xiliang. The Station Designed by the Method of Combination of Comprehensive Technology in Designing and Bridge and Building J. Railway Standard Design 2009 10 62-65. Construction of the Support Layer of Combination of Bridge and Building of Chengdu East Railway Station 4. J. Science & Technology Information 2010 13 J. 2010 8 73-78. 88-92. Sun Junling. Study on Application of Frame Structure System in the Main - line Bridge in ShangHai Hongqiao Railway Station J. Journal of Railway Engineering