()
9397( )() 2822 CORPS22 CORPS 60% I
II
... 8... 10... 10... 10... 10... 12... 13... 14... 14... 17... 43... 46... 50... 55... 55... 59... 67... 80... 115... 164... 164... 166... 169... 173... 173 9397... 177 9397... 191 9397... 204... 209 1
...209...214...225...228...228...233...236...239...241...241...246...247...249 2
1...13 2...14 3...18 4()...21 5...22 6...22 7...23 8...24 9...25 10...26 11...27 12...29 13...31 14...33 15...34 162005...35 172005...39 18CORPS...43 19...47 209397...80 219397....82 229397()...83 239397()...84 249397...85 259397...86 269397...87 279397...88 289397...89 299397...90 309497...91 319397...92 329397...93 339397...94 349397...95 359397...96 369397...97 379397...99 389397...101 399397...102 3
409397... 103 419397... 105 429397... 107 439397... 109 449397... 110 459397...111 469397... 113 479397... 115 489397... 117 499397... 119 509397... 120 519397... 122 529397... 123 539397... 125 549397()... 127 559397()... 128 569397... 130 579497... 132 589397()... 134 599397()... 135 609397... 137 619397... 139 629397... 141 639397... 143 649397... 145 659397... 147 669397... 149 679397... 151 689397... 153 699397... 155 709397()... 157 719397()... 158 729397... 160 739397... 162 74... 175 7593... 177 7694... 179 7795... 181 7896... 183 7997... 185 4
809397...187 819397...188 829397...189 839397...189 8493...191 8594...193 8695...195 8796...197 8897...199 899397...201 909397...202 919397...202 929397...205 939397...207 94...242 5
1... 17 2... 19 3()... 20 4... 24 5... 25 6... 26 7... 27 8... 28 9... 29 10... 30 11... 31 12... 32 132005... 36 14... 37 152005... 39 16... 49 179394... 60 189497... 63 19CORPS... 66 2097... 68 219397... 71 229397... 73 239397... 74 249397... 76 259397... 78 26... 79 2793... 178 2894... 180 2995... 182 3096... 184 3197... 186 329397... 187 3393... 192 3494... 194 3595... 196 3696... 198 3797... 200 389397... 201 399397... 204 409397... 206 6
41...210 42...210 43...211 44...213 45...243 46...245 7
70 85 III 2001 97 1.3%4% 98 232,450,000 8
9
9397 10
9397 Secondary Data AnalysisFocus group Stewart2000 9397 (Focused Interview) moderator 1996223237 (insight)(exploratory)2005224 11
9397 9397 12
97 0 13
第二章 文獻探討 第一節 表演藝術產業價值鏈 圖 1 表演藝術產業價值鏈1 資料來源 文建會 2005 表演藝術產業生態系統初探 表演藝術團隊透過交換的行為 以價值活動組成 價值鏈 價值鏈中的交 1 因公部門主要扮演資金提供者 該研究未將 公部門 部分繪入價值鏈 14
2 2 2 15
16
(, 2007)9257 266 1 2007 17
1 3 2,2007 3 18
2 (%) 41 15.41 94 35.34 44 16.54 87 32.71 266 100.00 2007 23(, 2007)266 9435.34%87 32.71%4441 16.54%15.41% 19
(, 2007) 27261 114 3() 615 337 190 1,142 53.85% 29.51% 16.64% 100% 1,007 2,585 886 4,478 22.49% 57.73% 19.79% 100% 134 335 87 556 24.10% 60.25% 15.65% 100% 1,756 3,257 1,163 6,176 28.43% 52.74% 18.83% 100% 2007 20
3() 2007 4320056,176 1,75628.43%3,25752.74% 1,16318.83% 1,142615 53.85%337 29.51%19016.64% 4,4782,585 57.73%1,00722.49% 88616.64% 556335 60.25%134 28.43%8718.83% 21
4 2007 531,756 57%1,10735%615 8%134 5 2007 22
633,257 80%2,58510%337 10%335 6 2007 31,163 76%88616%8% 87 23
7 2007 4 (%) 191 72.08 74 27.92 265 100.00 2007 24
482005 72.08%19127.92% 74 8 2007 5 37 50 38 66 191 90.24% 53.19% 86.36% 76.74% 72.08% 4 44 6 20 74 9.76% 46.81% 13.64% 23.26% 27.92% 41 94 44 86 265 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 25
2007 59 6676.74%3886.36%50 53.19%3790.24% 2064441 9 2007 6 86 10.96% 149 18.98% 91 11.59% 459 58.47% 785 100.00% 2007 26
6102005785 45958.47%91 11.59%14918.98% 8610.96% 10 2007 7 (%) 261 98.12 5 1.88 266 100.00 2007 27
8 39 94 43 85 261 95.12% 100.00% 97.73% 97.70% 98.12% 2 0 1 2 5 4.88% 0.00% 2.27% 2.30% 1.88% 41 94 44 87 266 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 2007 7112005261 98.12%51.88%8 94100%8597.7% 4397.73%3995.12% 0212 28
11 2007 9 (%) 59 22.18 207 77.82 266 100.00 2007 29
10 12 13 15 19 59 29.27% 13.83% 34.09% 21.84% 22.18% 29 81 29 68 207 70.73% 86.17% 65.91% 78.16% 77.82% 41 94 44 87 266 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 2007 910122005 5922.18%20777.82% 1921.84%1534.09% 1313.83%1229.27% 68298129 30
12 2007 11 2,200 18.60% 6,062 51.26% 1,609 13.60% 1,956 16.54% 11,827 100.00% 2007 1113200511,827 6,06251.26%2,200 18.60%1,95616.54%1,609 13.6% 31
12 931 173 956 412 2,472 37.66% 7.00% 38.67% 16.67% 100.00% 1,161 5,597 479 1,403 8,640 13.44% 64.78% 5.54% 16.24% 100.00% 507,726 59,253 267,381 283,659 1,118,019 45.41% 5.30% 23.92% 25.37% 100.00% 1,056,761 678,342 334,615 554,624 2,624,342 40.27% 25.85% 12.75% 21.13% 100.00% 94 19 43 61 217 43.32% 8.76% 19.82% 28.11% 100.00% 14 273 131 80 498 2.81% 54.82% 26.31% 16.06% 100.00% 55,266 14,700 94,333 19,610 183,909 30.05% 7.99% 51.29% 10.66% 100.00% 31,950 86,050 142,072 61,380 321,452 9.94% 26.77% 44.20% 19.09% 100.00% 2007 32
13 2007 14122005 1,118,019507,72645.41% 283,65925.37%267,38123.92% 59,2535.3% 33
14 2007 15122005 2,624,3421,056,76140.27% 678,342554,62421.13% 334,61512.75% 34
20051,782,847,266 2,116,772,806333,925,540 152005 2007 35
132005 () (%) 328,502,374 18.43% 457,529,941 25.66% 191,634,433 10.75% 121,213,340 6.80% 56,579,970 3.17% 146,331,860 8.21% 134,867,586 7.56% 346,187,762 19.42% 1,782,847,266 100.00% 2007 1316 20051,782,847,266 457,529,94125.66%328,502,374 18.43%191,634,43310.75% 146,331,8608.21% 134,867,5867.56%121,213,3406.8% 56,579,9703.17%6 346,187,76219.42% 36
14 203,445,759 12,294,854 12,294,854 56,673,644 56,673,644 53,386,567 56,088,117 328,502,374 42.08% 4.50% 4.34% 18.93% 18.83% 15.53% 7.85% 18.43% 123,735,608 181,104,488 191,778,014 68,378,732 68,378,732 72,121,587 73,637,587 457,529,941 25.59% 66.36% 67.62% 22.84% 22.72% 20.98% 10.30% 25.66% 42,660,000 36,520,953 36,520,953 55,145,469 55,145,469 39,938,301 57,308,011 191,634,433 8.82% 13.38% 12.88% 18.42% 18.32% 11.62% 8.02% 10.75% 23,954,970 25,402,000 25,402,000 20,473,682 20,473,682 50,174,350 49,412,688 119,243,340 4.95% 9.31% 8.96% 6.84% 6.80% 14.60% 6.91% 6.69% 16,583,970 3,912,000 3,912,000 20,436,000 20,436,000 15,648,000 15,648,000 56,579,970 3.43% 1.43% 1.38% 6.83% 6.79% 4.55% 2.19% 3.17% 23,810,904 7,948,668 7,948,668 54,048,138 54,048,138 57,755,852 60,524,150 146,331,860 4.92% 2.91% 2.80% 18.05% 17.96% 16.80% 8.47% 8.21% 49,309,265 5,747,180 5,747,180 24,202,628 24,202,628 54,743,265 55,608,513 134,867,586 10.20% 2.11% 2.03% 8.08% 8.04% 15.92% 7.78% 7.56% 0 0 0 0 1,600,000 0 346,557,762 348,157,762 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.53% 0.00% 48.48% 19.53% 483,500,476 272,930,143 283,603,669 299,358,293 300,958,293 343,767,922 714,784,828 1,782,847,266 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 2007 142005483,500,476 203,445,75942.08% 123,735,60825.59%49,309,265 10.2%42,660,0008.82% 23,954,9704.95%23,810,904 4.92%16,583,9703.43% 2005272,930,143 181,104,48866.36% 36,520,95313.38%25,402,000 37
9.31%12,294,8544.5% 7,948,6682.91%5,747,180 2.11%3,912,0001.43% 2005299,358,293 68,3789,73222.84% 56,673,64418.93%55,145,46918.42% 54,048,13818.05% 24,202,6288.08%20,473,682 6.84%20,436,0006.84% 2005343,767,922 72,121,58720.98% 57,755,85216.8%54,743,265 15.92%53,386,56715.53% 50,174,35014.6%39,938,30111.62% 15,648,0004.55% 38
162005 2007 152005 507,562,560 23.98% 348,155,441 16.45% 362,888,322 17.14% 898,166,483 42.43% 2,116,772,806 100.00% 2007 39
1720052,116,772,806 898,166,48342.43% 507,562,56023.98%362,888,32217.14% 348,155,44116.45% 20051,782,847,266 2,116,772,806 333,925,540 42.08% 25.59% 10.2%77.87% 66.36% 13.38% 9.31%89.5% 22.84% 18.93%18.42% 18.05% 78.24% 40
20.98% 16.8% 15.92%15.53% 69.23% 3,25752.74%28.43%1,765 57%88% 18.83% 18.83% 18.83% 200511,827 559,253 5.3% 1,118,0192,624,342 41
2 78572005 98.12% 22.18% 34.09% 42
19971999 CORPScoreCORPS 18 Participants Service Clients Operations Resources 17CORPS 1999 CClients OOperations RResources P Participants SServiceCORPS PR OSC 12 CORPS 310 43
CS P RPR CPR CORPS CR CPR CPR P 2007CORPS C O 44
R P S 23 2006CORPS C O R P S CORPS CO PRS 45
2007 (Vision)(Mission)(Position) (Objectives) 2007 46
47 18 2007 19
48
16 2000 2004 2005 2006 2007 49
2001 2001 2001 50
158 2006 53 51
39 20078594 52
2007 53
2009 105 54
81 8186 818821283884 2885298636 87 87898750 888966 90 71 3 () 6 55
1 91 69 11~13 9269 2008 460 9373 () 56
() () () 9470 794 22 98 57
4 90 93 94 98 98 4 13 58
90 9092 93 93 31 94 94 59
933 631 94 31 9394 179394 93 94 % % % ( ), ( ) 60
93 94 DM 93 9392 % ( ) 94 9393 93 ( ) DM 1794 61
94 93 () DM8 9493 5 959697 18 62
189497 94 97 % % ( ) DM 94 9393 93 97 9797 96 63
94 97 ( ) DM 9794 9 DM DM 93 94 64
97 31 9722 9CORPS 19 65
19CORPS CORPS Clients Operations Resources Participants Services 66
9397 97 97 20 67
2097 ( ) DM 68
973122 69
DM 5 5 9397 1052525 2530 5 98 4000()A500()B A4000 4000500500 70
9397 1. 2193977795 659797 131517 9520199322 219397 93 94 95 96 97 17 17 18 16 13 17 17 18 17 15 17 18 20 19 17 22 21 21 19 20 73 73 77 71 65 71
2. 2293130,650,000 97100,000,00027,900,00 40,500,000179,500,000160,750,000 139,750,000139,650,000 971,192,063,324 93956,627,786 345,009,119435,181,4339497 183,939,973237,054,01893 182,090,960 951,268,521,30293 986,275,503442,457,515348,210,567 9395185,394,097227,046,327 9697237,624,738236,581,412 951,216,763,05297 1,005,104,686 461,721,019~352,878,52493~95 176,020,82~217,046,2739697215,627,607 221,335,833 951,268,521,30293986,275,503 467,858,366~364,129,862 93~95185,394,097~227,046,32796 97237,624,738236,581,412 94 96~97 72
229397 93~97 17 $30,150,000 $183,939,973 $208,531,026 $226,494,183 $203,025,028 17 $40,500,000 $245,587,734 $267,674,314 $278,702,400 $249,645,811 93 17 $25,000,000 $182,090,960 $176,020,822 $180,527,604 $185,394,097 22 $35,000,000 $345,009,119 $352,878,524 $364,129,862 $348,210,567 73 $130,650,000 $956,627,786 $1,005,104,686 $1,049,854,049 $986,275,503 17 $27,800,000 $212,627,766 $269,067,725 $262,046,159 $227,436,472 17 $37,900,000 $248,934,062 $263,191,107 $278,903,008 $261,743,244 94 18 $30,000,000 $193,424,187 $192,658,878 $191,705,156 $197,650,453 21 $34,300,000 $376,996,154 $369,743,677 $378,402,118 $387,646,176 73 $130,000,000 $1,031,982,169 $1,094,661,387 $1,111,056,441 $1,074,476,345 18 $29,400,000 $237,054,018 $294,608,525 $297,521,432 $305,075,896 18 $36,600,000 $293,567,287 $332,628,357 $354,647,615 $330,872,959 95 20 $30,700,000 $219,538,869 $217,046,273 $222,733,505 $227,046,327 21 $33,300,000 $404,085,814 $372,479,897 $387,184,883 $405,526,120 77 $130,000,000 $1,154,245,988 $1,216,763,052 $1,262,087,435 $1,268,521,302 16 $29,400,000 $225,403,584 $215,627,607 $216,928,363 $237,624,738 17 $36,600,000 $257,522,924 $273,153,248 $305,563,886 $271,447,488 96 19 $30,300,000 $244,814,460 $223,410,619 $215,200,235 $249,371,578 19 $32,700,000 $385,996,000 $402,092,050 $404,283,952 $387,911,415 71 $129,000,000 $1,113,736,968 $1,114,283,524 $1,141,976,436 $1,146,355,219 97 13 $23,000,000 $220,146,304 $221,335,833 $225,962,468 $236,581,412 15 $27,900,000 $272,667,020 $269,181,959 $287,986,327 $285,670,196 17(16) $23,650,000 $264,068,567 $249,111,185 $242,147,310 $267,412,296 20 $25,450,000 $435,181,433 $461,721,019 $467,858,366 $442,457,515 73
93~97 65(64) 6 $100,000,000 $1,192,063,324 $1,201,349,996 $1,223,954,471 $1,232,121,419 3. 23973,00896 2,447939697 938~1,2069495967880 361~503 239397 546 361 93 749 961 2,617 575 468 94 967 927 2,937 477 503 95 880 840 2,700 446 370 96 693 938 2,447 6 97 74
97 596 379 827 1,206 3,008 75
1. 24934 97101040,000,000 4519 40 5,000,00040,000,0005,000,000 249397 93 94 95 96 97 4 7 8 8 10 45 45 49 46 40 24 21 20 17 14 73 73 77 71 64 7 2. 25 9382,250,0009753,850,0009497 9462,162,5849748,399,076 9322,800,000 9395492,907,249577,291,329 9697540,137,076702,539,108 7 97 76
48,399,076~83,325,191 93~95508,029,597~602,167,757 9697544,777,004 708,349,01251,902,492~86,801,359 9395529,370,183~ 603,482,568 9697525,116,238 671,203,05158,661,586~ 92,585,322 9395601,376,447 615,436,120949697516,817,706 549,883,336688,121,256 64,894,586 104,296,891 77
259397 93~97 4 $22,800,000 $329,741,028 $320,829,489 $344,180,711 $338,188,102 93 45 $82,250,000 $543,561,567 $591,689,875 $601,376,447 $561,286,042 24 $25,600,000 $83,325,191 $92,585,322 $104,296,891 $86,801,359 73 $130,650,000 $956,627,786 $1,005,104,686 $1,049,854,049 $986,275,503 7 $36,900,000 $476,912,336 $493,295,116 $516,871,706 $498,578,930 94 45 $74,400,000 $492,907,249 $529,370,183 $516,398,718 $508,029,597 20 $18,700,000 $62,162,584 $71,996,088 $77,786,017 $67,867,818 72 $130,000,000 $1,031,982,169 $1,094,661,387 $1,111,056,441 $1,074,476,345 8 $34,400,000 $517,280,370 $539,752,394 $568,953,117 $600,235,568 95 49 $78,600,000 $577,291,329 $603,482,568 $615,436,120 $602,167,757 20 $17,000,000 $59,674,289 $73,528,090 $77,698,198 $66,117,977 77 $130,000,000 $1,154,245,988 $1,216,763,052 $1,262,087,435 $1,268,521,302 8 $37,200,000 $540,137,076 $525,116,238 $549,883,336 $544,777,004 96 46 $72,700,000 $515,266,861 $507,139,484 $509,812,079 $540,540,096 17 $19,100,000 $58,333,031 $82,027,802 $82,281,021 $61,038,119 71 $129,000,000 $1,113,736,968 $1,114,283,524 $1,141,976,436 $1,146,355,219 10 $32,800,000 $702,539,108 $671,203,051 $688,121,256 $708,349,012 97 40 $53,850,000 $441,125,140 $464,235,359 $470,938,629 $471,869,915 14 $12,650,000 $48,399,076 $58,661,586 $64,894,586 $51,902,492 64 8 $993,000,000 $1,192,063,324 $1,194,099,996 $1,223,954,471 $1,232,121,419 3. 2693 1,781961,45594~97 946199627293 297 8 97 78
26 297 93 1,781 539 2,617 623 94 1,695 619 2,937 563 95 1,653 484 2,700 720 96 1,455 272 2,447 1,028 97 1,605 363 2,996 79
229397 () 1. 9 199397 2093971,744,072 1,649,5301,206,907 9 80
1,178,227952,086,982 96977,569 1,448,589 81
() 1. 209397. 21 26.32% 20.59%20.34%16.46% 20.69% 9629.83%97 22.68% 82
() 1. () 219397() 83
229397() 222397 3847 453324 9540976020 9636945317 9745952718 6 5974 416 84
2. 10 239397 10 85
249397 2425 2.344.522.08 1.571.43 965.06 933 7224 949680 86
3. 259397 26 95 171.57% 238.96%161.74% 153.95%146.93% 94352.3% 97303.35%95164.74%187.56% 87
4. 269397 88
279397 2728 15.47 21.519.0210.18 9.86 9428.2296 13.2615 89
() 1. 11 289397 29 10.7911.67 11.6111.088.61 946.82 9311.825 11 90
2. 093 299497 30 69.7%76.75% 72.03%66.61%62.13% 94 72.29%9784.88%12.59% 94969766.61% 97 91
3. 0 309397 92
319397 3132 10,791 16,7219,4268,293 7,237 9627,650 939,18018,4709714,997 943,33596 9,228979,227 967,518 9312,416 93
() 1. 329397 33 109.65% 116.01%114.49%105.75% 101.04% 100%93 119.81%97112.3% 97 127.52%9599.34%28.18% 94
2. 339397 34 9496 112.03% 115.20%115.05%115.02% 101.95% 94168.56% 56.53%9591.71%96 90.01%78.55% 95
3. 349397 35 9495 97.24%101.28%99.89% 94.73%92.24% 9784.35% 949790% 10% 96
4. 359397 36 39.12%53.24% 38.26%37.2%30.22% 9337.78%9447.04%10% 97
939655% 9744.35% 96433.98%9731.02% 98
5. () 12 369397 37 13.28% 21.18%13.08% 12.12%6.18% 9420.73% 12 99
969.95%9718.18% 8.23% 9516.24%96 8.25% 100
6. 379397 38 16.35% 28.26%17.34%9.43% 9.07% 9521.06%9733.36% 12.3% 95 20.78% 101
7. 0 389397 39 16.63% 31.26%17.04%8.9% 6.69% 9324.08%96 39.93%15.85% 3.66% 102
8. 399397 40 8.47%17.04% 9.21%4.71%4.38% 9314.57%95 20.5%5.93% 94 103
11.28%6.79%957.38% 4.18%9595 104
9. 13 409397 41 1,541.751,891.041,734.9 1,558.75963.15 971,031.48 952,203.91,172.4295 13 105
9594 689.43971,285.49 94 2,199.66971,648.07551.59 106
() 1. 419397 42 39.24%49.36%40.9% 36.46%29.64% 9456.15% 107
9746.34%9.81% 9337.93% 9621.45%9440.89% 9730.14% 108
2. 429397 109
439397 4344 4.585.01 4.844.623.98 94 3.18395 5.565.78 942.67 975.35 931.88 946.114.2395 4.99697 110
3. 95 939596 97 14 3 15 3 16 449397 14 95() 15 9593~95 16 (3)3 111
45 37.42%53.57% 38.9%36.5%25.2% 9654.99% 9751.36% 9528.9% 9721.93% 112
4. 95 939596 97 17 3 18 3 19 459397 17 95() 18 9593~95 19 (3)3 113
46 8.66%18.52%9.64% 5.02%3.24% 958.83% 968.57%978.57%9697 9518.36% 9618.44%9718.76% 952.32%962.64% 974.77%96972.13% 959510.7%97 8.99%1.71%954.88% 965.47%974.72% 114
98 40,000,0005,000,00040,000,000 5,000,0009397 22 () 1. 20 469397 20 115
47 1,448,5892,333,3851,533,395 1,077,765 97 951,840,499 972,752,425 931,392,010 951,675,743 961,492,628971,533,385 93748,695 95982,73296 925,319971,077,765 116
() 1. 479397 48 20.69%32.19%18.14% 6.5% 93~959433.45%9531.57% 9634.63%9728.08% 6.55% 117
9319.85%9716.46% 948%974.6% 118
() 1. 489397 119
499397 4950 38.49746.81 9634.4685.29 36.5523.61 9570.38 979029 9740.13 9632.63 96169429.48 13.48 972,996 21 96 2,447646.2971,028 93297731 21 97 120
1,637.8931,781 961,455326 455.694619 96272347 121
2. 509397 122
519397 5152 97 2.342.76 2.342.16 932.25 943.71951.8896 3.88972.12 972.8 93~961.97~2.47 971.64 93~962.08~2.48 167.4 123
9418993147 10520.4 124
3. 529397 53 171.92% 191.13%143.79%122.33% 100% 100% 94176.68%96120.42% 125
100%97 240.13%93165.53% 96139.18% 9388.17% 100% 126
4. 539397() 127
549397() 5455 15.5142.6814.2 8.14 9346 9447.299532.5596 50.559737.118 93~95 15.4~15.93969.98597 14.1 938.5894 12.81595~967.945 977.438.81 1,110.4 941,29396931 128
639161 129
() 1. 22 559397 56 10.7837.79 8.845.22 9344.755 9437.439540.7596 22 130
9734.6331.45 13.35 9311.8947.8995~978.31~8.09 936.339546.05~4.43 2.33 131
2. 093 569497 57 70.03%80.22% 71.78%60.55% 9482.5%9576.14% 59679.15%9783.07% 56.93% 132
9569.68%5 9775.56%5 5.88% 9450.84%5 9774.56%23.72% 133
3. 0 579397() 134
589397() 5859 10,824.6350,835.77 7,471.582,372.3 93~95 49,876.5~45,8069666,037.635 9743,548.4522,489.23 93~95 7,228.1~7998.02969,187.445 975,641.953,545.54 933,226.74941,317.05 5953,319.615 962,090.4971,907.71 2,002.56 135
722,04996954,717 93573,122 364,640.2313,997.643,411.2 136
() 1. 599397 60 109.65% 128.07%104.24%97.94% 100% 9590.13%94101.3% 939697 98.26~100.98%11.27% 137
93109.28% 9699%949597102.79~106.91% 10.28% 93124.57% 94117.66%595122.23% 96137.68%97138.2%5 20.54 138
2. 609397 61 111.98% 115.14%113.58%95.59% 93~95 98.99~94.80%9682.84%5 97102.56%519.72% 93115.92% 94145.09%595104.03% 139
9699.3%597103.56% 45.79% 9394 115.21%115.52%95120.53%96101.62% 597122.81%5 21.19% 140
3. 619397 62 97.76% 99.63%99.28%97.09% 93 97.41%94102.31%9599.95%96 107.06%59791.42%5 141
15.64% 93 97.65%9495.74%95100.6%5 9697.22%9794.23%5 6.37% 93 108.52%594~96100%86.89% 597103.89%21.63% 142
4. 629397 63 39.21% 56.51%45%13.7% 143
9360.08% 9460.82%59554.99% 9654.6%9752.08%5 8.74% 9339.07% 9439.71%59535.4% 9632.88%9732.85%5 6.86% 9312.61% 9416.42%59515.41% 9611.57%59712.48% 4.85% 144
5. () 23 639397 64 94 13.28% 13.79%12.72%11.87% 23 145
936.94% 59411.81%9512.17% 9617.11%593~9697 11.87%10.17% 93 15.12%59413.09%95 14.17%9611.55%59715.01% 3.57% 939.48% 59413.09%9513.85%96 11.73%9715.47%5 5.99% 146
6. 649397 65 16.35% 24%18.18%9.20% 9323.12% 59424.58%9523.21%96 23.86%9725.24%5 2.13% 147
9320.1% 9413.69%59515.25% 9619.05%9722.82%594 979.13% 935.79% 5946.99%9510.78%96 14.89%593~9697 7.57%7.32% 148
7. 659397 66 16.63% 32.15%16.74%10.11% 9330.28% 9434.65%9526.96%596 32.71%9736.17%595~97 9.21% 149
9314.27%94 16.65%9516.48%9622.06% 59714.24%5 9396 7.28% 9310.16%94 7.77%5959.95%96 8.16%9714.5%56.73% 150
8. 669397 67 8.47% 9.01%7.56%7.54% 935.93% 59410.15%9510.28%5 968.7%979.96% 4.35% 151
939.09% 5947.56%956.26%5 967.43%977.44% 938.98% 945.41%59510.33%5 965.99%976.98%4.92% 152
9. 679397 68 1,541.75 1,654.321,327.76 1,209.793 93 93 153
1,356.385941,771.6395 1,791.86961,843.2597 1,508.53486.82 93 1,954.755941,073.6795 1,313.396928.25597 1,368.86585.89 93980 5941,000.4951,582.64 593~9596 1,416.33971,068.9895~97 602.47 154
() 1. 689397 69 39.29%47.02% 39.74%35.1%95 155
9356.57%5 9450.6%9540.52%93~95 9649.4%9737.99%5 18.58% 9343.1%94 40.97%9544.52%596 35.99%9734.13%595~97 10.39% 9342.31%5 9441.28%9535.71%9627.63% 593~969728.91% 14.68% 156
2. 699397() 157
709397() 7071 4.610.88 4.233.19 93 9312.75948.14 5959.389613.25 594~969710.9 5.51 933.64943.18 5954.76964.3797 5.252.02 931.085 943.38953.593~95 962.06975.934.85 158
326.497400 93241 189.857 159
3. 95 9395 9697 24 3 25 3 26 719397 24 95() 25 9593~95 26 SUM(3)3 160
72 37.42%55.45%38.35% 15.63% 95 16.67%9616.47%9713.75%3 2.92% 95 40.94%9638.23%9735.88%5 5.06% 95 65.68%9651.71%9748.96%5 16.72% 161
4. 95 9395 9697 27 3 28 3 29 729397 27 95() 28 9593~95 29 SUM(3)3 162
73 8.66% 9.85%6.27%5.71% 95 10.11%969.73%979.72%3 0.39% 95 5.45%966.48%976.89%5 1.44% 95 5.49%5965.96%975.69% 0.47% 163
9397 () 9397(93 95)9497 9697 (7122) () 9397( 10745)95() (72238123) () 9395 (7122)94939597 (7223) () 9397 (7122)9396 97(94957223) 164
() 93974 10(7324)934 9697810 949697 97 (75 257626) () 9397 9397 9395 9395 9395 (752576 26) () 9397 9497 9397 (75257626) 165
(7887) () 9397 () 939796 () 9397 () 9397 (88104) () 9397 64.47%~68.68% 9312,415 166
() 9397 9396 () 9397 9396 () 9397 167
(105112) () 9397 () 9397 () 9397 () 9397 168
(113127) () 9397 () 939797 () 9397 (128152) () 9397 9697 9396 9395 169
9397 9495 () 939793 949597 939596 97 9396 9593 () 9397 9495 93969396 97 170
(153161) () 9397 939395 9793 969496 9597 9795 () 9397 9597 () 9397 939396 969393 95 959797 171
172
18CORPS Operation ParticipantsResource ClientsServices 97CORPS 19ParticipantsOperations ServiceService ( ) 173
() 19 97 = 174
73 175
9397 176
9397 (1,242,018.5235.85) () 7493 7527 23.53%41.18% 27.27% 18.18% 177
2793 93 X= Y= 11.76% 11.76% 58.82% 17.65% 5.88% 5.88% 52.94% 35.29% 23.53% 11.76% 41.18% 23.53% 27.27% 27.27% 27.27% 18.18% 178
(1,409,782.3340.23) () 7594 762848.06% 29.41%52.94% 29.41%44.44%38.89% 28.57%38.1% 179
2894 94 X= Y= 5.88% 17.65% 29.41% 47.06% 11.76% 5.88% 52.94% 29.41% 44.44% 0.00% 38.89% 16.67% 14.29% 28.57% 38.10% 19.05% 180
(1,512,852.7335.06) () 7695 772933.33% 50%55.56%27.78% 35%45% 28.57% 33.33% 181
2995 95 X= Y= 5.56% 11.11% 33.33% 50.00% 5.56% 11.11% 55.56% 27.78% 35.00% 10.00% 45.00% 10.00% 28.57% 33.33% 28.57% 28.57% 182
(1,454,095.2834.46) () 7796 783025% 31.25%37.5% 95 42.11%31.58% (52.63%)31.58% 183
3096 96 X= Y= 6.25% 25.00% 31.25% 37.50% 0.00% 5.88% 82.35% 11.76% 21.05% 5.26% 42.11% 31.58% 5.26% 52.63% 31.58% 10.53% 184
(1,624,199.4846.28) () 7897 7931 30.77%80%93 41.18% 29.41%23.53%40% 25%20% 15%9596 185
3197 97 X= Y= 7.69% 30.77% 30.77% 30.77% 0.00% 6.67% 80.00% 13.33% 29.41% 5.88% 23.53% 41.18% 25.00% 15.00% 40.00% 20.00% 186
329397 9397 93 94 95 96 97 11.76% 17.65% 11.11% 25.00% 30.77% 19.26% 11.76% 5.88% 5.56% 6.25% 7.69% 7.43% 58.82% 29.41% 33.33% 31.25% 30.77% 36.72% 17.65% 47.06% 50.00% 37.50% 30.77% 36.60% 5.88% 5.88% 11.11% 5.88% 6.67% 7.08% 5.88% 11.76% 5.56% 0.00% 0.00% 4.64% 52.94% 52.94% 55.56% 82.35% 80.00% 64.76% 35.29% 29.41% 27.78% 11.76% 13.33% 23.51% 11.76% 0.00% 10.00% 5.26% 5.88% 6.58% 23.53% 44.44% 35.00% 21.05% 29.41% 30.69% 41.18% 38.89% 45.00% 42.11% 23.53% 38.14% 23.53% 16.67% 10.00% 31.58% 41.18% 24.59% 27.27% 28.57% 33.33% 52.63% 15.00% 31.36% 27.27% 19.05% 9.52% 10.53% 25.00% 18.27% 27.27% 38.10% 28.57% 31.58% 40.00% 33.10% 18.18% 14.29% 28.57% 5.26% 20.00% 17.26% 799397 8032 95 187
(80) 809397 813296 188
819397 8232 829397 8332 189
190
9397 9397 (1,242,018.5235.85) () 8393 843375% 31.11%28.89% 22.22%17.78% 75%12.5% 191
3393 93 X= Y= 0.00% 75.00% 0.00% 25.00% 31.11% 17.78% 22.22% 28.89% 12.50% 0.00% 75.00% 12.50% 192
(1,409,782.3340.23) () 8494 83471.43% 14.29% 40%28.89%20% 11.11%76.19% 19.05% 193
3494 94 X= Y= 14.29% 71.43% 0.00% 14.29% 20.00% 11.11% 28.89% 40.00% 19.05% 0.00% 76.19% 4.76% 194
(1,5122,852.7335.06) () 8595 863575% 32.65%20.41%14.29% 70% 20%10% 195
3595 95 X= Y= 12.50% 75.00% 12.50% 0.00% 20.41% 14.29% 32.65% 32.65% 20.00% 0.00% 70.00% 10.00% 196
(1,454,095.2834.46) () 8696 8736 39.13%30.43% 17.39%13.04% (88.24%) 197
3696 96 X= Y= 0.00% 100.00% 0.00% 0.00% 13.04% 17.39% 39.13% 30.43% 0.00% 0.00% 88.24% 11.76% 198
(1,448,589.6738.38) () 8797 883760% 20% 42.5%30% 20%7.5%78.57% 7.14%14.29% 199
3797 97 X= Y= 20.00% 60.00% 0.00% 20.00% 20.00% 7.50% 42.50% 30.00% 7.14% 0.00% 78.57% 14.29% 200
389397 9397 93 94 95 96 97 75.00% 71.43% 75.00% 100.00% 60.00% 76.29% 0.00% 14.29% 12.50% 0.00% 20.00% 9.36% 0.00% 0.00% 12.50% 0.00% 0.00% 2.50% 25.00% 14.29% 0.00% 0.00% 20.00% 11.86% 17.78% 11.11% 14.29% 17.39% 7.50% 13.61% 31.11% 20.00% 20.41% 13.04% 20.00% 20.91% 22.22% 28.89% 32.65% 39.13% 42.50% 33.08% 28.89% 40.00% 32.65% 30.43% 30.00% 32.39% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 12.50% 19.05% 20.00% 0.00% 7.14% 11.74% 75.00% 76.19% 70.00% 88.24% 78.57% 77.60% 12.50% 4.76% 10.00% 11.76% 14.29% 10.66% 889397 89389397 76.29% 97 60%96(100%) 201
899397 903866.47% 94 909397 202
9138(77.6%) 203
9397 399397 9397 93 11.76% 11.76% 58.82% 17.65% 94 17.65% 5.88% 29.41% 47.06% 95 11.11% 5.56% 33.33% 50.00% 96 25.00% 6.25% 31.25% 37.50% 97 30.77% 7.69% 30.77% 30.77% 93 5.88% 5.88% 52.94% 35.29% 94 5.88% 11.76% 52.94% 29.41% 95 11.11% 5.56% 55.56% 27.78% 96 5.88% 0.00% 82.35% 11.76% 97 6.67% 0.00% 80.00% 13.33% 93 11.76% 23.53% 41.18% 23.53% 94 0.00% 44.44% 38.89% 16.67% 95 10.00% 35.00% 45.00% 10.00% 96 5.26% 21.05% 42.11% 31.58% 97 5.88% 29.41% 23.53% 41.18% 93 27.27% 27.27% 27.27% 18.18% 94 28.57% 19.05% 38.10% 14.29% 95 33.33% 9.52% 28.57% 28.57% 96 52.63% 10.53% 31.58% 5.26% 97 15.00% 25.00% 40.00% 20.00% 9697 80%(9682.35%9780%) 9341.18%94 204
44.44%9741.18% 9652.63%97 15% 919397 205
409397 9397 93 94 95 96 97 75.00% 71.43% 75.00% 100.00% 60.00% 0.00% 14.29% 12.50% 0.00% 20.00% 0.00% 0.00% 12.50% 0.00% 0.00% 25.00% 14.29% 0.00% 0.00% 20.00% 17.78% 11.11% 14.29% 17.39% 7.50% 31.11% 20.00% 20.41% 13.04% 20.00% 22.22% 28.89% 32.65% 39.13% 42.50% 28.89% 40.00% 32.65% 30.43% 30.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 12.50% 19.05% 20.00% 0.00% 7.14% 75.00% 76.19% 70.00% 88.24% 78.57% 12.50% 4.76% 10.00% 11.76% 14.29% 9396 (100%) 206
929397 20%(97 30%) 50% 207
3 208
209
98 424 41 98 2 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 2 7 1 0 0 12 0 2 1 0 0 0 3 98 0 0 0 0 2 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 5 5 4 4 8 1 2 5 24 41 2 7 221 212985 42 98 3 0 1 0 0 1 5 0 2 3 1 0 1 7 0 1 2 0 0 1 4 1 1 2 0 2 2 8 4 4 8 1 2 5 24 42 311 210
3 211 1212 9821 43 98 1 3 0 0 1 5 0 3 3 0 1 7 0 3 0 0 1 4 1 3 0 2 2 8 2 12 3 2 5 24 43 12239825 () 211
() 1. 2. () 1. 2. () () 264 212
44 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 98 98 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 98 98 6 213
2007 () (C3I) () (B2II) 2 (C4II) 214
(D3I) () (B3II)... (C4I) ()(C2III) (B3II) ()(A1I) (B3II) 215
(A1I) (C2I) (C1I) 5 Support (C1I) () (C3I) () (C3I) 216
23 (B2I) 4 517 (C4II) (B4II) (B4I) 217
Target (C4I) (B3II)...... (B4I) (B4I) (A4I) 218
(B3II) CASE(C2II) () (C1I) (C2II) 2006 (C2I) ()... (B4I) 219
(D4I) () (C2II) 1010 Review105 (B2I) 1. (C2II) 2. 220
Handle (C4II) 2 2 (C4I) 3. (C3I) Confuse(C1I) 4. 221
(B4I) 5. (C4I) 6. (D2I) 7.... ()(C2II) (B2III) 222
(C1I) 1. workshop (B4I) workshop(b2ii) 2. Q&A 3. (B2I) 4. 5. 223
224
225
226
workshop Q&A 227
228
() 229
230
231
232
233
234
235
XY 236
( ) () () 237
238
1. 1999 2. 20078594 3. 2001 9309325 4. 1996 5. 2005 6. 2009 7. 2005 8. 2007 9. 2007 5372 10. 2007 11. 2006 12. 2007 13. 2000 (Stewart, D. W., & Kamins, M. A., 1999) 239
14. 2007 15. 2005 16. 2006CORPS 17. 2004 88104 18. 2008 19. 1997 253741 20. 2007 21. 2001 22. 1999 240
241
Arts Village SOHO 2005 93 2005 1999 242
2004 45 243
2004 2004 20072005 2007 200920072008 244
2007 46 245
246
workshop Workshop 247
248
715 1330~1530 (106136202) ( ) 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 249