男女共同参画推進に関する意識調査 報告書 平成 19 年 3 月 秋田大学男女共同参画推進専門委員会
p 17 2 s³ w s³w s å 2 18 4 p ¼s³ l p s³ 17 12 ¼ î oå 16 11 p s{ 17 10 p p { s 18 2 p Â{ { p o ñ p så ³ ¼ Ì š ÿ ¼ 1,375 s m Ø ó ó ½ 810 58.9 o s³ û mø» ½ s ³ s ³ p mø p ¼¼å l ¼å p s³w w { - 1-
å 11 6 sò j 12 6 ûp ûp s ³ l ² ûp å s 17 2 p s³ w w 12 ¼ î s³ o sò ³v p s ³ ¼s Ì ÿ 1 ¼ p ¼s³ ¼s m Ø» åjð å 17 4 ¼ 1,375 š sm Ì Ø ó 18 4 10 4 24 ó 810 58.9% š ñ 810 š Â š Ê š Fisher Cuzick 5% š ½ š sš - 2-
¼ Ý l Ò ¼ â ¼± ¼± ¼ ¼ â â s s ³¼ s ü s Ì» sš¼ s s³ p! s - 3-
810 92%s s ì 1 s ss s š š sš! p s¼ î { ì 38s 4 ù 2 ñ ì 62â 21% ¼â ì o ì s ( ) ì m ì { - 4-
ì ì ì ì ì (%) (%) ¼ ¼ â â 18 29 18 29 4/ 23 4/ 15 1/ 6 13/142 22/186 (17.4) (26.7) (16.7) ( 9.2) (11.8) 30 39 30 39 9/ 17 2/ 7 36/ 97 12/ 71 59/192 (52.9) (28.6) (37.1) (16.9) (30.7) 40 49 40 49 18/ 28 9/ 15 38/ 92 16/46 81/181 (64.3) (60.0) (41.3) (34.8) (44.8) 50 65 50 65 48/ 59 15/ 36 60/102 23/ 48 146/245 (81.4) (41.7) (58.8) (47.9) (59.6) 79/127 30/ 73 135/297 64/307 308/804 (62.2) (41.1) (45.5) (20.9) (38.3)! p s ì 45 17 3 Ê 17 ¼ ìñ - 5-
ì! s å s š (66%) (66%) Ý (24%) (20%)s š o ¼â o sš 18 7 ¼ ¼ 14.8 ¼ 25.7 ¼ 3.8 ¼ 42.6(¼ )25.1â 89.1s å Ì s ¾ š sš ¼ Ý l Ò! s å» - 6-
»» 810 % 32% 40» 44 5» 55¼ 47 Ý 44 28 29» Ý sšš o s Q2-5»Q2-4 21% 53% P < 0.001Ì s» Q2-4 Q2-5 ñ s»»»»»» š sš ¼ Ý l Ò! ûp ûp s ³ l ² ûp sš¼ ¼ ± ¼± ñ{ - 7-
ì 810 73 ì 26%å (6) ìsì 50 65 š 47 50 65 sš 25%šo ¼¼± â ì ì ì ûp sš¼ ì ì ì! sš¼ š 810 34ou 25~ 23 7 u s ¼ 32 ¼¼± 4u ~ s Ê 30 39 40 49 š ì~ o Q2-9 ½~sš¼ ²» sš¼ š u ~ - 8-
! sšp sø 776 o 59 sš 36 p 26 sò å p 24 p sø sšm sš o p oš o ~ ss(8) ss Ø sš p š sš! p sš¼ sš¼ ² j š ¼ ¼ 299 å² å²sš ² 40 o m s šå ² 32½ ~ ~ sš¼ ² 14 2 s s Êsš ² š o ~sš¼ ² sš osšs š¼ ² å» ³ ú9 ¼ s š ²o m sšå ² ûm¼ š - 9-
p sš¼ sš¼ ² j s å ~ å m å m sš š sš! sš Ò å 749 42 Ò å 10 19 820 29 1330 39 1140 49 12 ½ s10 10 19š o ûp ñ 20 20 29šo 30 s sš o 65 ½ 38 m å ¼ m Ò sšî sš¼ p âo šsšì s~¼ - 10-
sš¼ò å s š sš! sp š 740 Ž 29 À24 24sš170 23² 157 21s n 5 À² sš o sš p 11 30 39 40 49 50 59 ² ¾ o½ sÿ Ø ½ÿ ² å» ³ ú - 11-
図 2-11 大学として取り組むべきこと (Q2-11 男女別選択順に 8 位まで )! s ûm š ½ 753 î î Ø mø sš 61 šm40sš ² å ³»32 s 1 îø ½š š åî mo sš sš ²³o12 o ¼sš š î mø ½s mø å ms ü - 12-
図 2-12 男女共同参画のために実行したいこと (Q2-12) m Ì Ø ümø p å s ³ s Ø ½ p m p! m s ms p - 13-
Ê p 782 28 s s ¼ š sš o s s š sš ¼ â å s å s š s op = 0.001) s mø s mø! s såì š sš - 14-
¼î s 206 o½ ~ so šp å Ì mø± Ä sš ú ¼ â ¼ ¼ â p š sš pš sš 18 29 sš 16 š! mç 759 45 ) m š sš! ½ sš š sš Ç š Ç - 15-
± osš Ç î ¼ o sš¼ š¼mš Ç sš Ç Ý ½ s š»! {m š sš p»ò s š {gì o sš ò Â sš òm s ª m»s Øs mì š sš À 565 62% À 72% 1 sš o š osš š ñ ½ Ê o Ý o - 16-
ÝÊ o» ³ { ~ p m À ü Q3-5 ² Q4 ½Ò ì ìì š sš ì 524(64.7) 226(58.2) 298(75.6) ì 233(28.8) 141(36.3) 92(23.4) ì 25( 3.1) 21( 5.4) 4( 1.0) 28( 3.5) 810 388 394 ì 810 65% 524 ì 29% 233 ì 3 25 sš m ì 58 226 ì 35% 141 ì 5% 21 sš m ì 76 298 ì 23% 92 ì 1% 4 sšìsš ì ì ì s š sš 18 29 98/181(54.1) 6/29(20.7) 92/152(60.5) 30 39 124/187(66.3) 42/83(50.1) 82/104(78.9) 40 49 126/180(70.0) 62/110(56.4) 64/70(91.4) 50 65 176/231(76.2) 116/163(71.1) 60/68(88.2) s18 29 ì o šsš m 30 40 ì 8 š 5 s50-17-
šì š ì Ò ì š š 810 ( š 406 sš 404 ) 35% 281 ) 53% 430 12% 99 sš mš 23% 79 77% 263 sš mš 55% 202 45% 165 sš m½ š š» š» p ñ š 29 40% 68 30 47% 82 40 43% 72 30 â š 53% 163 ¼ 23% 29 18% 13 25% 75 ½ p s s ¾ u Q4-2 281 Q4-3 204 26% 74 í 8 22 11% 31 å 27% 77 š í Ê Ã š sì š sš 74(26.3) 4 5 70 35 í 22( 7.3) 1 1 21 10 31(11.0) 18 23 13 6 å 77(27.4) 34 43 43 21 4- š 204 57 147 í ~ - 18-
í mq4-2 š 40% m 23% å 46% š Ì ¼ â 74(26.3) 3 4 11 56 22( 7.8) 1 0 6 15 í 31(11.0) 8 3 15 5 å 77(27.4) 10 5 25 37 4-3 204 22 12 57 113 ½ â â o Q4-2 s ¾ j d d d ¼ ~o d d o m ½{ â oš í Ò vv v šå sš ª š í Ç sšã } ûm»sš m š {ó mó m ì Ò² - 19-
Ò ó å ª Ì ñ oí { ¼ ñ š m Øš 810 23% 189 40% 320 31% 250 4 Ì» 29 21% 37 46% 82 Ê o s mø š sš 189(23.4) 47(12.7) 142(36.6) 320(39.5) 180(48.5) 140(36.1) 250(30.9) 144(38.8) 106(27.3) ½ 759 371 388 å osš š 4 å ~å Q2-4 å 266 37% 98 321 47% 152 o { m 810 34% 271 í 12% 93 11% 88 13% 102 18% 147 s { m š sš 1 271(33.5) 59 17.0 212 60.1-20-
2 í 93(11.5) 21 6.0 72 20.4 3 88(10.9) 82 23.6 6 1.7 4 102(12.6) 80 23.0 22 6.2 5 147(18.2) 106 30.5 41 11.6 sší š í 2 š 3 sšš í s» mø ½ í Ò½ Ò Q4-5 { m 2 í 283 ½ o 5 š sš m 138(50.0) 99(55.3) 39(40.2) m 109(39.5) 44(24.6) 65(67.0) } 99(35.9) 40(22.4) 59(60.8) 56(20.3) 54(30.2) 2( 2.1) î 50(18.1) 41(22.9) 9( 9.3) m } Ò p sš m Ê osšm } o o sš â ù å Ì m} 3 ~ m {o p» ûš ½» 810 o o» š sš À í 413(56.7) 167(45.6) 246(67.8) - 21-
382(52.4) 164(44.8) 218(60.1) 291(39.9) 156(42.6) 135(37.2) š sš sš m À í 4 š 3 4 d s ú ñ o âù ½Â ì ûÿo oå j å { m o { { pn ªv o m p { Ã{Ã Ê { ÜÀÀÝ Ã Q5-1 ì ì 390 (48.2%) ì 88 10.9% ì ìš o ìsš oì 65% 524 ì p ¼ 810 ½ ìì š sš ì 310 38.3 132(33.2) 178(45.6) ì 390 48.2 197(49.5) 193(49.5) ì 88 10.9 69(17.3) 19( 4.9) 22( 2.7) - 22-
ì s š sš 18 29 55/179(30.7) 4/29(13.8) 51/150(34.0) 30 39 51/188(27.1) 13/84(15.5) 38/104(36.5) 40 49 82/180(45.6) 38/111(34.2) 44/69(63.8) 50 65 122/238(51.3) 77/171(45.0) 45/67(67.2) ìs À ìs 20 š sò ª sšš ~ š š 18% (145 ) š 70% (565 ) 12% (100 ) 7 š š š s š sš 18 29 26/168(15.5) 1/25(4.0) 25/143(17.5) 30 39 23/160(14.4) 5/64(7.8) 18/96(18.8) 40 49 45/161(28.0) 21/92(22.8) 24/69(34.8) 50 65 51/219(23.3) 30/154(19.5) 21/65(32.3) Ì o ì š( ì ) ìñ š 145 í 3% 4 141 å 65% (68 ) p Ò å 31% (33 )Ò - 23-
Ò m 19 m } 8 4 î 3 3 1 1 îå m» Ò m Øš mò m š møš 58% (446 ) 6% (47 ) p mø š sš 47( 6.1) 27( 7.0) 20( 5.3) 446(58.2) 189(49.1) 257(67.5) 273(35.6) 169(43.9) 104(27.3) ½ 766 385 381 Øš sš š o Øs š sš 56/123(45.5) 44/94(46.8) 12/29(41.4) 37/69(53.6) 22/50(44.0) 15/19(79.0) ¼ 143/289(49.5) 112/225(49.8) 31/64(48.4) â 210/285(73.7) 11/16(68.8) 199/269(74.0) sâo Ê š - 24-
p s Q2-4 m s o mš 44% 353 í 11% 92 š ½ å š sš 353(43.6) 154 (39.3) 199(51.8) í 92(11.4) 49(12.5) 43(11.2) 34( 4.2) 26 ( 6.6) 8( 2.8) 154(19.0) 88(22.5) 66(17.2) 143(17.7) 75(19.1) 68(17.7) sšs šsš o ò sšš šsš š 18% s íò í Ò Ò ÿ 1 m73% o m } 34%30% sš ½ ñ å» Ò š sš m 199(72.9) 110(69.2) 89(78.1) m } 93(34.1) 47(29.6) 46(40.4) 83(30.4) 42(26.4) 41(36.0) î 40(14.7) 36(22.6) 4( 3.5) 17( 6.2) 10( 6.3) 7( 6.1) 18( 6.6) 17(10.7) 1(0.9) - 25-
12( 4.4) 9( 5.7) 3( 2.6) 7( 2.6) 4( 2.5) 3( 2.6) ÿ 4 î ssšo š ¼ (î )o ~ m» ûšo À í Ò ª o» š sš À í 499(61.6) 213(56.7) 286(75.9) 397(49.0) 205(54.5) 192(50.9) Òª 244(30.1) 122(32.5) 122(32.4) ª½ 94(11.6) 74(19.7) 20( 5.3) sšà í sš p š psš À í ñòª ª½ ŽÀ í ª Ò å³ ¼ å» o ò p»½ š - 26-
l 18 4 p ¼ p ¼s ³ 810 ¼s m Ì Ø s³s m Ì Ø p s³ m s sš~ ~å ~å½ s møs ñsp ² ÌÌ ¼ sš¼ å wsš¼ ½ ~³ û» Ž p ÿ ¼ ú ì sš» šø ½p šm} À í»½ ò p p» ½ ¼} mø ½ Ç Ýå 7 { ½ sž ì p s ì ¼ ìì s Ììs å î¼ å - 27-
¼m Ì Ø š»² p s ³ - 28-
p s³ s o I. š Q1-1 Q1-2 ¼ Ý ½ îò Ð lò i î ¼ ³ š (%) sš (%) s (%) ¼ 51 ( 12.6) 11 ( 2.7) 62 ( 7.7) 20 ( 4.9) 22 ( 5.5) 42 ( 5.2) 107 ( 26.4) 10 ( 2.5) 117 ( 14.4) 117 ( 28.8) 61 ( 15.1) 178 ( 22.0) Ý 43 ( 10.6) 276 ( 68.3) 319 ( 39.4) 52 ( 12.8) 17 ( 4.2) 69 ( 8.5) 4 ( 1.0) 3 ( 0.7) 7 ( 0.9) l Ò 12 ( 3.0) 3 ( 0.7) 15 ( 1.9) 0 ( 0.0) 1 ( 0.3) 1 ( 0.1) 406 (100) 404 (100) 810 (100) Q1-3 â ¼¼ îâ ââ
š (%) sš (%) s (%) 97 ( 23.9) 30 ( 7.4) 127 ( 15.7) 55 ( 13.6) 19 ( 4.7) 74 ( 9.1) ¼ 236 ( 58.1) 64 ( 15.8) 300 ( 37.0) â 18 ( 4.4) 291 ( 72.0) 309 ( 38.1) 406 (100) 404 (100) 810 (100) Q1-4 š š sš Q1-5 10 29 30 39 40 49 50 59 60 š (%) sš (%) s (%) 18 29 30 ( 7.4) 156 ( 38.6) 186 ( 23.1) 30 39 85 ( 21.0) 107 ( 26.5) 192 ( 23.8) 40 49 112 ( 27.8) 70 ( 17.3) 182 ( 22.6) 50 59 145 ( 43.7) 70 ( 17.6) 215 ( 30.6) 60 * 31 ( 7.7) 1 ( 0.2) 32 ( 4.0) 403 (100) 404 (100) 807 ( 99.6) * 60 50 59 Q1-6 ¼± ¼± ¼ » Ž»Ò â â % s% 810 % ¼± 78 (91.8) 7 ( 8.2) 85 (10.5) ¼± 59 (89.8) 9 (13.2) 68 ( 8.4) 26 (83.9) 5 (16.1) 31 ( 3.8) 54 (70.1) 23 (29.9) 77 ( 9.5) ¼ 20 (48.8) 21 (51.2) 41 ( 5.1) 37 (97.4) 1 (2.6) 38 ( 4.7) 48 (80.0) 12 (20.0) 60 ( 7.4)
22 (55.0) 45 (45.0) 40 ( 4.9) «21 (80.8) 5 (19.2) 26 ( 3.2) 11 (78.6) 3 (21.4) 14 ( 1.7) 9 (81.8) 2 (18.2) 11 ( 1.4) 0 ( 0) 26 (100) 26 ( 3.2) 6 ( 2.3) 255 (97.7) 261 (32.2)»» 2 (100) 0 ( 0) 2 (0.3) Ž»Ò â 5 (62.5) 3 (37.5) 8 ( 1.0) â 6 (31.6) 13 (68.4) 19( 2.4) 2 (66.7) 1 (33.3) 3 ( 0.4) II. s Q2-1 s (%) 748 ( 92.4) 60 ( 7.4) 2 ( 0.2) 810 (100) s s š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 18 29 27 / 30 ( 90.0) 127 / 156 ( 81.4) 154 / 186 ( 82.8) 0.304 30 39 77 / 85 ( 90.6) 100 / 107 ( 93.5) 177 / 192 ( 92.2) 0.590 40 49 104 / 111 ( 93.7) 68 / 70 ( 97.1) 172 / 181 ( 95.0) 0.486 50 65 171 / 175 ( 97.7) 71 / 71 ( 100.0) 242 / 246 ( 98.4) 0.327 379 / 401 (94.5) 366 / 404 ( 90.6) 745 / 805 ( 92.6) 0.043 P 0.009 < 0.001 < 0.001 Q2-2 2005 12 14 p s¼ î { ì ìq2-4
(%) ì 310 ( 38.3) ì 497 ( 61.4) 3 ( 0.4) 810 (100) ì (%) ¼ â P 18 29 4/ 23 4/ 15 1/ 6 13/142 22/186 (17.4) (26.7) (16.7) ( 9.2) (11.8) 0.104 30 39 9/ 17 2/ 7 36/ 97 12/ 71 59/192 (52.9) (28.6) (37.1) (16.9) (30.7) 0.004 40 49 18/ 28 9/ 15 38/ 92 16/46 81/181 (64.3) (60.0) (41.3) (34.8) (44.8) 0.046 50 65 48/ 59 15/ 36 60/102 23/ 48 146/245 (81.4) (41.7) (58.8) (47.9) (59.6) < 0.001 79/127 30/ 73 135/297 64/307 308/804 (62.2) (41.1) (45.5) (20.9) (38.3) < 0.001 P < 0.001 0.282 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 Q2-3 p s (%) 140 ( 17.3) 258 ( 31.9) 412 (50.9) 810 (100) Q2-4 s å s š å (%) 60 ( 7.4) 206 ( 25.4)
190 ( 23.5) 131 ( 16.2) 180 ( 22.2) 25 ( 3.1) 18 ( 2.2) 810 (100) Q2-5 å»»»»»ò å (%) 65 ( 8.0) 257 ( 31.7) 354 ( 43.7) 89 ( 11.0) 45 ( 5.6) 810 (100) Q2-6 ûp 2000 ûp s ³ l ² 2010 ûp sš¼ ¼± ¼± 20% ñ{ ì ì (%) ì 211 ( 26.1) ì 594 ( 73.3) 5 ( 0.6) 810 (100) ì s š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 18 29 4 / 30 ( 21.0) 15 / 155 ( 9.7) 19 / 185 ( 10.3) 0.518 30 39 24 / 85 ( 28.2) 12 / 107 ( 11.2) 36 / 192 ( 18.8) 0.005 40 49 39 / 112 ( 34.8) 18 / 68 ( 26.5) 57 / 180 ( 31.7) 0.253 50 65 81 / 174 ( 46.6) 18 / 71 ( 25.4) 99 / 245 ( 40.4) 0.002 148 / 401 ( 36.9) 63 / 401 ( 15.7) 211 / 802 ( 26.3) < 0.001 P < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001
Q2-7 2010 sš¼ 20% š u ½ ½ ½ ~ å (%) u 199 ( 24.6) 53 ( 6.5) 57 ( 7.0) ~ 183 ( 22.5) 275 ( 34.0) 34 ( 4.2) 10 ( 1.2) 810 (100) Q2-8 sš p søø î Ø ¼ Ø sò å p sš p î ¼ Ê å š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 1 197 ( 50.1) 260 ( 67.9) 457 ( 58.9) < 0.001 2 117 ( 29.8) 71 ( 18.5) 188 ( 24.2) < 0.001 3 116 ( 29.5) 166 ( 43.3) 282 ( 36.3) < 0.001 4 101 ( 25.7) 103 ( 26.9) 204 ( 26.3) 0.744 5 21 ( 5.3) 28 ( 7.3) 49 ( 6.3) 0.302 6 63 ( 16.0) 17 ( 4.4) 80 ( 10.3) < 0.001 7 18 ( 4.6) 6 ( 1.6) 24 ( 3.1) 0.021 393 (100) 383 (100) 776 (100) Q2-9 p sš¼1998 2.3%ûp 99 90 sš¼ ² j š ¼
½~ ~sš¼ ² m sš² m sšå ² ² å²sš ² å š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 1 31 ( 10.4) 41 ( 18.8) 72 ( 13.9) 0.007 2 91 ( 30.4) 72 ( 33.0) 163 ( 31.5) 0.566 3 8 ( 2.7) 9 ( 4.1) 17 ( 3.3) 0.455 4 139 ( 46.5) 67 ( 30.7) 206 ( 39.9) < 0.001 5 30 ( 10.0) 29 ( 13.3) 59 ( 11.4) 0.265 299 (100) 218 (100) 517 (100) Q2-10 sš¼ sš Ò å ¼ sš¼ Ò å¼ o sšò å 10% 10 19% 20 29% 30 39% 40 49% 50 59% 60% å š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P < 10 % 8 ( 2.0) 1 ( 0.3) 9 ( 1.2) 0.040 10 19 % 44 ( 11.2) 19 ( 5.3) 63 ( 8.4) 0.040 20 29 % 66 ( 16.8) 33 ( 9.2) 99 ( 13.2) 0.002 30 39 % 42 ( 10.7) 42 ( 11.8) 84 ( 11.2) 0.728 40 49 % 41 ( 10.5) 46 ( 12.9) 87 ( 11.6) 0.307 50 59 % 12 ( 3.1) 14 ( 3.9) 26 ( 3.5) 0.554 > 60 % 1 ( 0.3) 0 ( 0) 1 ( 0.1) 1.000 132 ( 33.7) 182 ( 51.0) 314 ( 41.9) < 0.001 46 ( 11.7) 20 ( 5.6) 66 ( 8.8) 0.004 392 (100) 357 (100) 749 (100) Q2-11 sp š ² sš w«p Ž Ž À Ž
¼ sš Ç p Ê å š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 1 65 ( 17.3) 92 ( 25.2) 157 ( 21.2) 0.009 2 80 ( 21.3) 99 ( 27.1) 179 ( 24.2) 0.072 3 91 ( 24.3) 79 ( 21.6) 170 ( 23.0) 0.432 4 17 ( 4.5) 5 ( 1.4) 22 ( 3.0) 0.016 5 103 ( 27.5) 114 ( 31.2) 217 ( 29.3) 0.294 6 23 ( 6.1) 34 ( 9.3) 57 ( 7.7) 0.129 7 62 ( 16.5) 44 ( 12.1) 106 ( 14.3) 0.093 8 69 ( 18.4) 111 ( 30.4) 180 ( 24.3) < 0.001 9 18 ( 4.8) 13 ( 3.6) 31 ( 4.2) 0.465 10 8 ( 2.1) 8 ( 2.2) 16 ( 2.2) < 0.001 11 8 ( 2.1) 7 ( 1.9) 15 ( 2.0) 1.000 12 6 ( 1.6) 4 ( 1.1) 10 ( 1.4) 0.752 13 12 ( 3.2) 10 ( 2.7) 22 ( 3.0) 0.83 14 61 ( 16.3) 51 ( 14.0) 112 ( 15.1) 0.413 15 29 ( 7.7) 7 ( 1.9) 36 ( 4.9) < 0.001 16 13 ( 3.5) 6 ( 1.6) 19 ( 2.6) 0.162 375 (100) 365 (100) 740 (100) Q2-12 sûm š ½ ùsšå ² ³ sš ² å ³» šm m î s å î m î î Ø mø sš å
š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 1 77 ( 20.5) 51 ( 13.5) 128 ( 17.0) 0.012 2 87 ( 23.2) 156 ( 41.3) 243 ( 32.3) < 0.001 3 141 ( 37.6) 161 ( 42.6) 302 ( 40.1) 0.181 4 19 ( 5.1) 16 ( 4.2) 35 ( 4.7) 0.608 5 29 ( 7.7) 42 ( 11.1) 71 ( 9.4) 0.134 6 112 ( 29.9) 50 ( 13.2) 162 ( 21.5) < 0.001 7 105 ( 28.0) 64 ( 16.9) 169 ( 22.4) < 0.001 8 229 ( 61.1) 233 ( 61.6) 462 ( 61.4) 0.881 9 16 ( 4.3) 10 ( 2.7) 26 ( 3.5) 0.238 375 (100) 378 (100) 753 (100) 57 810 III. m Ì Ø Q3-1 m s p Ê Q3-3 (%) p 32 ( 4.0) 186 ( 23.0) Ê 564 ( 69.6) 28 ( 3.5) 810 (100) s s (Q1-3) š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P ¼ â P Q3-2 s
¼î å (%) s (%) s (%) s P ¼î Q3-3 mç Q3-5 š (%) sš (%) s (%) Q3-4 ½ sš š sš Ç š Ç ± å (%) (%) (%) (%) P sš š sš Ç š Ç ±
Q3-5 {m š À š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 68 ( 24.8) 118 ( 40.6) 186 ( 32.9) < 0.001 77 ( 28.1) 89 ( 30.6) 166 ( 29.4) 0.579 À 28 ( 10.2) 28 ( 9.6) 56 ( 9.9) 0.888 73 ( 26.6) 43 ( 14.8) 116 ( 20.5) 0.001 28 ( 10.2) 13 ( 4.5) 41 ( 7.3) 0.009 274 (100) 291 (100) 565 (100) IV. Q4-1 ì ì ì ì Q4-4 (%) ì 524 ( 64.7) ì 233 ( 28.8) ì 25 ( 3.1) 28 ( 3.5) 810 (100) ì s š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 18 29 6 / 29 (20.7) 92 / 152 (60.5) 98 / 181 (54.1) < 0.001 30 39 42 / 83 (50.1) 82 / 104 (78.9) 124 / 187 (66.3) < 0.001 40 49 62 / 110 (56.4) 64 / 70 (91.4) 126 / 180 (70.0) < 0.001 50 65 116 / 163 (71.1) 60 / 68 (88.2) 176 / 231 (76.2) 0.004 226 / 385 (58.7) 298 / 394 (75.6) 524 / 779 (67.3) < 0.001 P < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 Q4-2 š Q4-3 Q4-4
(%) 281 ( 34.7) 430 ( 53.1) 99 ( 12.2) 810 (100) šs š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 18 29 5 / 27 (18.5) 63 / 143 (44.1) 68 / 170 (40.0) 0.017 30 39 27 / 74 (36.5) 55 / 102 (53.9) 82 / 176 (46.6) 0.032 40 49 25 / 104 (24.0) 47 / 62 (75.8) 72 / 166 (43.4) < 0.001 50 65 22 / 137 (16.1) 37 / 60 (61.7) 59 / 197 (30.0) < 0.001 79 / 342 (23.1) 202 / 367 (55.0) 281 / 709 (39.6) < 0.001 P 0.023 < 0.001 0.027 Q4-3 í å Ò¼ Ò (%) ¼ â 74 ( 26.3) 3 4 11 56 í 22 ( 7.8) 1 0 6 15 31 ( 11.0) 8 3 15 5 å 77 ( 27.4) 10 5 25 37 Q4-3 ½ 204 22 12 57 113 77 ( 27.4) 7 1 19 50 š 281 (100) 29 13 76 163 Q4-4 m Øš
š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 47 ( 12.7) 142 ( 36.6) 189 ( 23.4) < 0.001 180 ( 48.5) 140 ( 36.1) 320 ( 39.5) 0.001 144 ( 38.8) 106 ( 27.3) 250 ( 30.9) 0.001 371 (100) 388 (100) 759 ( 93.7) 51 ( 6.3) 810 (100) s š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 18 29 5 / 28 (17.9) 32 / 150 (21.3) 37 / 178 (20.8) 0.803 30 39 5 / 80 ( 6.3) 38 / 104 (36.5) 43 / 184 (23.4) < 0.001 40 49 11 / 108 (10.2) 29 / 66 (43.9) 40 / 174 (23.0) < 0.001 50 65 26 / 152 (17.1) 43 / 68 (63.2) 69 / 220 (31.4) < 0.001 47 / 371 (12.7) 142 / 388 (36.6) 189 / 759 (24.9) < 0.001 P 0.148 < 0.001 0.018 s š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 18 29 9 / 28 (32.1) 73 / 150 (48.7) 82 / 178 (46.1) 0.148 30 39 44 / 80 (55.0) 37 / 104 (35.6) 81 / 184 (44.0) 0.011 40 49 63 / 108 (58.3) 16 / 66 (24.2) 79 / 174 (45.4) < 0.001 50 65 61 / 152 (40.1) 14 / 68 (20.6) 75 / 220 (34.1) 0.005 180 / 371 (48.5) 140 / 388 (36.1) 320 / 759 (42.2) 0.001 P 0.348 < 0.001 0.021 Q4-5 { m Q4-7 í Q4-7 š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 59 ( 17.0) 212 ( 60.1) 271 ( 33.5) < 0.001 í 21 ( 6.0) 72 ( 20.4) 93 ( 11.5) < 0.001 82 ( 23.6) 6 ( 1.7) 88 ( 10.9) < 0.001 80 ( 23.0) 22 ( 6.2) 102 ( 12.6) < 0.001
106 ( 30.5) 41 (11.6) 147 ( 18.2) < 0.001 348 (100) 353 (100) 701 ( 86.5) 109 ( 13.5) 810 (100) Q4-6 íò½ m} î m å š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 1 54 ( 30.2) 2 ( 2.1) 56 ( 20.3) < 0.001 2 11 ( 6.2) 7 ( 7.2) 18 ( 6.5) 0.800 3 7 ( 3.9) 6 ( 6.2) 13 ( 4.7) 0.390 4 40 ( 22.4) 59 ( 60.8) 99 ( 35.9) < 0.001 5 5 ( 2.7) 7 ( 7.2) 12 ( 4.4) 0.120 6 44 ( 24.6) 65 ( 67.0) 109 ( 39.5) < 0.001 7 41 ( 22.9) 9 ( 9.3) 50 ( 18.1) 0.005 8 99 ( 55.3) 39 ( 40.2) 138 ( 50.0) 0.023 9 4 ( 2.2) 5 ( 5.2) 9 ( 3.3) 0.286 179 (100) 97 (100) 276 (100) Q4-7 ~ m { Ào p» ûš ½ m~ À í ª½ Òª å š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 1 167 ( 45.6) 246 ( 67.8) 413 ( 56.7) < 0.000 2 156 ( 42.6) 135 ( 37.2) 291 ( 39.9) 0.151 3 53 ( 14.5) 14 ( 3.9) 67 ( 9.2) < 0.000 4 91 ( 24.9) 96 ( 26.5) 187 ( 25.7) 0.672 5 164 ( 44.8) 218 ( 60.1) 382 ( 52.4) < 0.000 6 16 ( 4.4) 33 ( 9.1) 49 ( 6.7) 0.012 366 (100) 363 (100) 729 (100)
V. Q5-1 ì ì ì ì Q5-4 (%) ì 310 ( 38.3) ì 390 ( 48.2) ì 88 (10.9) 22 ( 2.7) 810 (100) ì s š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 18 29 4 / 29 (13.8) 51 / 150 (34.0) 55 / 179 (30.7) 0.046 30 39 13 / 84 (15.5) 38 / 104 (36.5) 51 / 188 (27.1) 0.002 40 49 38 / 111 (34.2) 44 / 69 (63.8) 82 / 180 (45.6) < 0.001 50 65 77 / 171 (45.0) 45 / 67 (67.2) 122 / 238 (51.3) 0.002 132 / 395 (33.4) 178 / 390 (45.6) 310 / 785 (39.5) 0.001 P < 0.001 < 0.001 < 0.001 Q5-2 š Q5-3 Q5-4 (%) 145 ( 17.9) 565 ( 69.8) 100 ( 12.4) 810 (100) šs š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 18 29 1 / 25 ( 4.0) 25 / 143 (17.5) 26 / 168 (15.5) 0.131 30 39 5 / 64 ( 7.8) 18 / 96 (18.8) 23 / 160 (14.4) 0.066 40 49 21 / 92 (22.8) 24 / 69 (34.8) 45 / 161 (28.0) 0.111 50 65 30 / 154 (19.5) 21 / 65 (32.3) 51 / 219 (23.3) 0.054
57 / 335 (17.0) 88 / 373 (23.6) 145 / 708 (20.5) 0.032 P 0.015 0.002 0.008 Q5-3 í å Ò¼ Ò (%) 3 ( 2.9) í 1 ( 1.0) 33 (31.4) å 68 (64.8) 105 (100) Q5-4 m Øš š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 27 ( 7.0) 20 ( 5.3) 47 ( 5.8) 0.367 189 ( 49.1) 257 ( 67.5) 446 ( 55.1) < 0.001 169 ( 43.9) 104 ( 27.3) 273 ( 33.7) < 0.001 385 (100) 381 (100) 766 ( 94.6) s š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 44/94 ( 46.8) 12/29 ( 41.4) 56/123 ( 45.5) 0.673 22/50 ( 44.0) 15/19 ( 79.0) 37/69 ( 53.6) 0.014 ¼ 112/225 ( 49.8) 31/64 ( 48.4) 143/289 ( 49.5) 0.888 â 11/16 ( 68.8) 199/269 ( 74.0) 210/285 ( 73.7) 0.770 189/385 ( 49.1) 257/381 ( 67.5) 446/766 ( 58.2) < 0.001 P 0.365 < 0.001 < 0.001 Q5-5 mš Q5-7 í Q5-7
š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 154 ( 39.3) 199 ( 51.8) 353 ( 43.6) 0.001 í 49 ( 12.5) 43 ( 11.2) 92 ( 11.4) 0.581 26 ( 6.6) 8 ( 2.8) 34 ( 4.2) 0.002 88 ( 22.5) 66 ( 17.2) 154 ( 19.0) 0.072 75 ( 19.1) 68 ( 17.7) 143 ( 17.7) 0.664 392 (100) 384 (100) 776 ( 95.8) 34 ( 4.2) 810 (100) Q5-6 íò½ m} î m å š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 1 17 ( 10.7) 1 ( 0.9) 18 ( 6.6) 0.001 2 9 ( 5.7) 3 ( 2.6) 12 ( 4.4) 0.370 3 10 ( 6.3) 7 ( 6.1) 17 ( 6.2) 1.000 4 42 ( 26.4) 41 ( 36.0) 83 ( 30.4) 0.109 5 4 ( 2.5) 3 ( 2.6) 7 ( 2.6) 1.000 6 47 ( 29.6) 46 ( 40.4) 93 ( 34.1) 0.071 7 36 ( 22.6) 4 ( 3.5) 40 ( 14.7) < 0.001 8 110 ( 69.2) 89 ( 78.1) 199 ( 72.9) 0.129 9 3 ( 1.9) 3 ( 2.6) 6 ( 2.2) 0.696 158 (100) 114 (100) 274 (100) Q5-7 ~ m À o p» ûš ½ m~ À í ª½ Òª å š (%) sš (%) s (%) s P 1 213 ( 56.7) 286 ( 75.9) 499 ( 61.6) < 0.000
2 205 ( 54.5) 192 ( 50.9) 397 ( 49.0) 0.343 3 74 ( 19.7 ) 20 ( 5.3) 94 ( 11.6) < 0.000 4 122 ( 32.5) 122 ( 32.4) 244 ( 30.1) 1.000 5 38 ( 10.1) 38 ( 10.1) 76 ( 9.4) 1.000 6 16 ( 4.3) 21 ( 5.6) 37 ( 4.6) 0.501 376 (100) 377 (100) 753 (100)
s Ì ¼¼Ì š s š 17 ¼± ¼± ¼¼ Ì š s š 17 ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼¼ Ì š s š 17 ¼ ¼ ¼ ¼ - 47-
¼¼ sš ¼ ± ¼± sš sš Ò i î l Ò ¼ î ¼ ³ ¼ Ý sš ½ ½ - 48-
Ì š s š 17 š s š 17 š s š 17 7 1-49-
¼ š s š 17 «â Ì o â š s š â Ì š s š - 50-
s ååo»žs³ 11 s³³ j 12 sj~ 18 sj ÿ~ 12 p 2010 ûp s š¼ 20%» å ò 16 s³ w ³w p å å å ¼ 1,375 ¼ ¼å 800 ww å l w ww åpn ñ ls å À p í