The Reluctant Supplier: U.S. Decisionmaking for Arms Sales (Cambridge, Mass.: Oelgeschlager, Gumm & Hain, 1983) Dscisionnaking for Arms Transfers.. 84
U.S.Taiwan Arms Talks F-16 85
F-16 26 OH-58D 42 AH-1W AIM-9S 900 3 Knox 38 RGM-84 150 F-16 AIM-7M OH-58D AH-1W AIM-9S F-16 AIM-7M AH-1W,F-16 RGM-84 Knox Register of the transfers and licensed production of major conventional weapons to Taiwan, 1993-2002.http://projects.sipri.se/armstrade/ atchi_taidata.htmlshirley A. Kan, Taiwan: Major U.S. Arms Sales Since 1990 (Updated January 27, 2003) Report for Congress, Congressional Research Service, The Library of Congress. 4-2 OH-58D 26 1992 Knox 3 AH-1W 42 RGM-84 AIM-9S F-16 150 AIM-7M 4-1 86
C-130 4 4 E-2C T M-60A3 C-130 28 M-109A5 300 M-60A3 4-3 C-130H E-2C T-38 M-60A3 PAC-2 Aggressive Class Knox Mk-15 Newport C-130H M-109A5 M-60A3 87
C-130H 8 E-2C 4 T-38 4-4 1993~1996 M-60A3 460 3 200 Knox 3 4 2 M-109A5 Mk-15 4-1 C-130H E-2T 4 T-38 AH-1W 4 S-70 11 Knox 2 E-2T 13 OH-58D 9 CH-47D AGM-114K 1 3 F-16 AIM-120C 4-5 AH-1W 13 OH-58D 9 CH-47D 1299 2000 11 S-70 2 Knox 1 3 110 282 4 S-70 2 E-2T 200 AIM-120C 88
AH-1W S-70A/UH-60L S-70B/SH-60B BGM-71 TOW FLM-92A RGM-84 FLM-92A Knox OH-58D CH-47D E-2T AGM-114K RGM-84 Anchorage Diver Class AIM-120C 4-6 F-16 MIM-72F 1997~2000 AH-1W 21 OH-58D 13 CH-47D 9 FLM-92A 2027 BGM-71 TOW 1786 AGM-114K S-70B/SH-60B 11 Knox 2 RGM-84 110 Anchorage 1 Diver Class 3 RGM-84 110 MIM-72F S-70A/UH-60L 4 E-2T 2 AIM-120C 4-1 89
P-3C 40 AGM-65G 77 RGM-84 146 M-109A5 4 Kidd 30 AH-64D 290 BGM-71 TOW AGM-65G RGM-84 M-109A5 AH-64D BGM-71 TOW Kidd Kidd 30 AH-64D 290 BGM-71 TOW 140 M-109A5 4 Kidd 77 RGM-84 40 AGM-65G 4-8 4-8 AH-64D 30 Kidd 4 BGM-71 TOW 290 RGM-8 M-109A5 AGM-65G 4-1 90
F-16 Block-20 Block-10/15/25/30/32/40/42/50/52 Paul Jackson, Jane s All the World s Aircraft 2002-2003 (Surrey, England: Jane s Information Group Limited, 2003), p. 688. 91
OH-58D AH-1W AH-1,,,,1995 AH-1Z, 2003 AH-1W AH-1Z F-16 F-16A/BC/D, F-16 A/B Block-20, F-16A/B,,, AIM-7M 69%, AIM-7P/R, AIM-9S AIM-9M, AH-1W, RGM-84,, Knox,, Jane s All the World s Aircraft 2002-2003, Jane s Fighting Ships 2001-2002, Jane s Air-Launched Weapons 2003 C-130H T-38 PAC-2 Knox Mk-15 Newport M-109A5 E-2T M-60A3 92
C-130H C-130A/B/E/H, E-2T T-38 E-2B, E-2B (E-2C ),, M-60A3,, M-1 1981, PAC-2, PAC-3, 1999, (1995), 60%, Aggressive Class 1950,, Knox Mk-15 ( ), Newport,,, C-130H M-109A5 M-109A6,,, A1.A2.A6 ; A2,A5 28 M-60A3 M-60A3 M-109A5 Knox 93
Anchorage Diver Class MIM-72F 4-11 AH-1W S-70A/UH-60L S-70C-6 (S-70C-1 ), S-70B/SH-60B SH-60F,SH-60B BGM-71 TOW A, A FIM-92A, RGM-84 FLM-92A Knox OH-58D CH-47D/SD,CH-47D E-2T AGM-114K AH-1W OH-58D, AGM-114L/M RGM-84 Anchorage 1960,, Diver Class 1946,, AIM-120C,,, F-16 MIM-72F AIM-9,, AIM-7M 94
Kidd AGM-65G IIR, RGM-84 M-109A5 AH-64D AH-64A/D, BGM-71 TOW Kidd,,, 95
AH-1W 42 OH-58D 26 AIM-9S 900 Knox 3 RGM-84 38 F-16 150 AIM-7M 600 96
M-109A5 28 M-60A3 160 3 200 Knox 3 383 4 T-38 40 E-2T 4 C-130H 4 M-60A3 300 M-109A5 28 Mk-15 6 Newport 2 C-130H 4 AIM-120 F-16 97
AH-1W 21 BGM-71 TOW 1786 FLM-92A 1299 FLM-92A 728 RGM-84 52 S-70B/SH-60B 11 Knox 2 S-70A/UH-60L 4 CH-47D 9 OH-58D 13 AGM-114K 240 RGM-84 58 MIM-72F 282 Anchorage 1 Diver Class 3 E-2T 2 AIM-120C 200 98
AH-64D 30 M-109A5 146 BGM-71 TOW 290 Kidd 4 RGM-84 77 AGM-65G 40 Knox 99
Bates Gill James R. Lilley 100
AH-1W Z-8 OH-58D Knox Knox C-130H 10 E-2T A-50E M-60A3 T-59 101
RGM-84 HY-2 Knox Newport F-16 SU-27 F-16 AIM-7M SU-27 R-27R-27 AIM-7M 4 C-130 M-109A5 T-70,85,89,83 M-60A3 T-59I/II RGM-84 HY-2 OH-58D Knox RGM-84 C101 RGM-84 AH-1W Z-8 S-70 Z-9C Anchorage 102
AIM-120 AA-12 E-2T A-50 OH-58D 26 AH-1W 42 /, /,,,,,2.5 352km/h,,,,, 3.2h, Z-8 ( ) 315km/h,,, Knox 3 7963km, 27.5kt,127 (1) (4), (1),(2),, 27 4000km, 26kt,5 (4),HY-2 (2), 100mm (2) C-130H 4 556km/h, 3602km( ), 64~92 22597kg 10 4930km, 124~178 21400kg E-2T 4 2~4,2,3~4,2~4,4~8 A-50E4 M-60A3 160 12~20,2~4,10,8~14, 12~20 48km/h, 496km, -10+20, 60, 105mm60 T-59 6000 ( ) 50km/h, 440km, -5+18, 30, 100mm34 103
RGM-84 38 224kg, 0.9, 130km,, HY-2 Knox 3 513kg,, 306m/sec, 105km,,,6 29, 2 200 3, 15000,, 100,8, 5, 40~70%( ) 75, 12~32, 24.5,1~3 Newport 2 22kt, 471,20~40, (1), 40mm (1) 35 Yuliang30,Yuling1,Hudao4, F-16 150 100, 3 2.05, 925km,G 1.1:1,AIM-7M SU-27 37 1.1, 1500km, G 8.17:1,R-27 +9, +9, (F-16 AIM-7M 600 ( ), 100km, 45km, 39kg R-27 (AA-10) C-130H 4, 72~172km, 39kg, 8G 10 28 M-109A5 122mmT-70,85,89 152mmT-83 30000m, 155mm50, 56km/h, 4, T-70 : 15300m, 122mm40, 45km/h, 6~8, T-83 : 17230m, 152mm30, 55km/h, M-60A3 300 T-59I/II6000 RGM-84 52,90 104
HY-2 OH-58D 13 Knox 2,8 31, 2 RGM-84 58,148 C101 1850kg, 2,,, AH-1W 21 Z-8( ) S-70 11 4.5, AQS-18V3, Z-9C ( ) 20, (2) 4.5,,H-12, (2) TV (2) Anchorage 1 3~18,50 LVT, 338 8 3 AIM-120 200 ( ) AA-12,,, (2), (4) E-2T 2 A-50E 200, 10, 150, 16 335, 50KM, 4 +,, 175kg, 50KM, 3,G 12 G, The Military Balance 1992~2002; Jane s All the World s Aircraft 2002-2003 ; Jane s Fighting Ships 2001-2002, Y2K, 89 7 2001 1 2002 2 Y-2K 105
Stockholm International Peace Research Institute, SIPRI F-5E/F F-16 SU-27 http://projects.sipri.se/armstrade/atchi_taidata.html 106
SU-27 F-104F-5 F-104 E-2T C-130H SU-27 SU-27 R K 18 30 FL-II AH-1W 26 OH-58D 160 M-60A3 The International Institute of Strategic Studies, The Military Balance1996~1997, (London: Oxford University Press, October 1996), p. 181. The International Institute of Strategic Studies, The Military Balance1996~1997, op. cit., p197. The International Institute of Strategic Studies, The Military Balance1996~1997, op. cit., p180. 107
F-16 3000 SU-27 50 J-8 250 J-8II AA-12 AIM-120 MICA G 12G AIM-120 RGM-84 K SS-N-22 OH-58D 300 M-60A3 28 M-109A5 The International Institute of Strategic Studies, The Military Balance1999~2000 (London: Oxford University Press, October 1999), p. 188. The International Institute of Strategic Studies, The Military Balance1999~2000, op. cit., p. 205. The International Institute of Strategic Studies, The Military Balance1999~2000, op. cit., p. 187. 108
SU-27 The International Institute of Strategic Studies, The Military Balance2002~2003 (London: Oxford University Press, October 2002), p. 165. 109
M-9 M-11 40-41 110
The International Institute of Strategic Studies, The Military Balance2002~2003, p. 163-165. 111
The Military Balance 2002~2003 F-16C/D 18 F-16A/B 8 F-18 12 SU-27 SH-2F2 UH-60L 18 F-16A 42 F-16 4 4 KC-135 8 CH-47 18 M IG-29 6 CN-235 10 Mi-17 2 Lekiu 10 Mig-29 16 HAWK-209 3 CN-235 2 MI-17 The International Institute of Strategic Studies, The Military Balance 2001~2002 (London: Oxford University Press, October 2001), pp181~185. 112
113
containment congagement 114
F-16 IDF M-2000 F-16F 115
http://homelf.kimo.com.tw/kajin1967/military/japan/ (Michael J. Green)(Patrick M. Cronin).. (The U.S.-Japan Alliance: Past, Present, and Future) 116
http://home.kimo.com.tw/kajin1967/military/s_korea/usfk.htm http://home.kimo.com.tw/kajin1967/military/s_korea/usfk.htm 117
F-15 F/A-18 F-16 F-16 49 4-20 F-15 F-16 F/A-18 M-2000 IDF SU-27 1 4 1.1 1270km 1 2 2.05 1600km 4 1 2.8 1750km 2 2 2.2 1445km 1 4 1.7 600km 2 2 2 1.1 1500km Jane s All the World s Aircraft 2002-2003 Y2K (Michael J. Green)(Patrick M. Cronin).. http://home.kimo.com.tw/kajin1967/military/s_korea/usfk.htm 118
1200 F-16M-2000 F-16 SU-27 F-16 F/A-18 F-16 F-16 119
SU-30 KH-35 120
http://www.sef.org.tw/www/html/discuss2.htm David M.Lampton, "Enhancing Global, and Taiwan Secutity for the Twenty-First Century ", Testimony before the United States Senate Committee on Foreign Relations. Hearings on " S.693, The Taiwan Security Enhancement Act ", August 4, 1999. 121
F-16 Kidd P-3C Kidd 30 140 400 Kidd 122
Richard A. Bitzinger 123
124
F-16 125