096THU DOC

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "096THU DOC"

陨樗闵
7 years ago
Views:

2 Analysis of the Medical Lawsuit Based on Events of the Supreme Court By Fu-Yao Wang Advisor: Prof. Chung-Yu Pan A Thesis Submitted to Tunghai University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Business Administration July 2008 Taichung, Taiwan

3 I

4 Analysis of the Medical LawsuitBased on Events of the Supreme Court Student: Fu-Yao Wang Advisor: Prof. Chung-Yu Pan Department of Industrial Engineering and Enterprise Information Tunghai University ABSTRACT The entanglements of medical lawsuits came always from various medical malpractices. If the two sides could not reach an agreement, except irrational combat, medical lawsuits would be deemed the only path to solve this controversy, which costs a lot of social resources. It`s frequent that they both disputed solely standing on each place until the court declared a final sentence. However, in this view, we could just obtain the reference books which focused on medical laws and never mentioned the defense skills of lawsuits. Meanwhile, any article about this issue could not be reviewed among the academic journals. Therefore, in this research we had taken the civil court verdicts of Supreme Judicial Court as the database. It s highly expected that the results of this study could be recommended as an essential reference before legal actions from the rivaling identities such as hospital managers, physicians and patients, in order to cut the meaningless filing of lawsuits, to promote the medical quality and then to improve patient safety. Keyword: Medical malpractice,medical negligence,damage compensation II

5 III 2008

6 IV

7 V

8 VI

9 VII

10 1 1.1 informational asymmetry

12 Medical Dispute Medical Malpractice Claim (1998) 2002

13 (1998)

15 Doctor Company

16 , ~

19 %

20 %

21 15 54% % % % % % %

23 % 4 27% 2 13% 2 13% 1 7% 67%

24 19 68% 9 32% 16 84% % % 11 58%

26 cc 600cc ()

27 18 ()

28 ,978, ,804 2,530 2,530 2,372, ,978 11,256,569 5,628,285 5,442,613 2,721,307 3,108,764 1,036,255 2,972, ,972 10,345,046 3,448,349 4,207,890 2,103,945 26,949,998 2,073,077 4,921, ,179,926 4,440,122 3,367,564 26,949,99 11,256,569 5,628,285 3,448,

30 1,978,825 2,530 2,372,847 11,256,569 5,442,613 3,108,764 2,972,917 10,345,046 4,207, ,684 2,372,847 5,442, , ,000 8,538, ,349, $1,219,827 $2,192,857 $3,412,684 $1,219,827 $451,471 $1,671, ,150 2,150, ,810,595 21

31 2,612, ,306,445 ( 259) 462, ,684 2,372,847 5,442, , ,000 15,349,

32 ,587,141 2,530 11,256,569 3,007,316 2,742,917 10,345,046 4,207,890 33,149, ,600, $4,735,630 $1,933,333 $6,668,963 $4,735,630 $1,657,143 $6,387, ,127,749 1,720, ,691,887 4,300, ,564,138 ( 109) 2,580,

33 4.3 1,587,141 2,530 11,256,569 3,007,316 2,742,917 10,345,046 4,207,890 11,600,

34 ,, ,, ,,1731 ( ) 4 89,, ,, ,, ,,709 ( ) 8 91,,222 25

35 9 91,,1941 ( ) 10 92,, ,, ,, ,,852 ( ) 14 94,, ,,1859 ( ) 16 94,, ,, ,, ,,1226 ( ) ,, ,,2950 ( ) ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,2476 ( ) 27 96,, ,,

36 ,921,880 6,179,926 4,440,122 3,367,564 $1,671,298 $6,387,373 $3,412,684 $6,668,963 67%

38 (3): (5):

44 35

49 cc 600cc

53 44 () ( )( )

54 45

55 ,,

56 47

57 48

58 ,,

59 50

60 ? 51

61 ,, ?

62 ? ? 53

63 ,, ()

64 55

65 ,, ()

66 57 Cimedin Decadron Dermovate Decadron Dermovate Cream Oint

67 58

68 ,, () Ketoprofenid Aspirin Buscopan

69 60 Ketoprofenid? Aspirin Buscopan

70 61 Aspirin Ketoprofenid

71 62

72 63 Aspirin

73 64

74 ,, Mc-Robert Mc-Robert

75 66 Johnson Spellacy Mc-Robert

76 67 Mc-Robert? Johnson Spellacy

77 -- 91,,222 68

78 ?

79 70

80 71

81 ,,

82 73 ()

83 () 74

84 ,, () () ()

85 76 ()

87 78

88 ()

89 80 () ()

90 81

91 ,, ()

93 84

94 -- 93,, () () 85

95 86 propofol () () ()

96 87 () () () ()

97 88

98 89

99 ,, <span style="color:#e8e8e8">.</span>

100 91 () ()

101 () () () () 92

102 ,,

103 94 106/64mmHg () Q ST T GOT 22 GOT capoten

104 95

105 ,,

106 97

107 98

108 ,,

109 100

110 101

111 102 () () ()

112 103 () 3,215,2392,130,7583,944,500893,676599,2324,000,000 14,783,405 () ()

113 104

114 ,, ( ) ()

115

116 107

117 ,,

118 109 () ()

119 110 () ()

120 111

121 ,, ()

122 113

123 114

124 ,,

125 116 williams 1~0 PRO

126 Cx.O s APGAR E4V2M3 E V M Problem OrientedSheet PROM and large hematoma on head R/O vaccumcaputcephalohematoma Problem Oriented Sheet R/O Subgaleal hemorrhage Special conditions of Baby HGB APTT APTT>100 APTT69 HGB /61 117

127 118 hypovolemicshock 29% Ahuja Christmas IX APTT K VIIIXX prothrombin 221 WC:Subgalealhematoma.JAMA244:1597-8,

128 119

129 ,, () () () ()

130 121 Sabiston's Chest of Surgery ray

131 122 Chest PA Chestpa in

132 123 () () ()

133 cc 600cc () () () 400cc 600cc () ()

134 125

135 ,,

136 127

137 128 () () () ()

138 () () 129

139 ,,

140 131

141 132 ROV size normal

142 Myoma=1.62x1.49cm atfundus 133

143 ,, () () () ()

144 135

145 136 GCSVital signpupil sign GCS M GCS EMV 12MN-8AM ICU 0

146 137 ICU

147 138

148 ,,

149 140

150 141 OPDF/U pt pt

151 142 AJCC B2 AJCC

152 143

153 ,, () () () () () () ()

154 145 NaKClCaGlu CC

155 146 () ( )( )

156 147 ()

157 148

158 ,,

159 150

160 151

161 152

162 ,,

163 154

164 155

165 156

166 157

167 158

Public Projects A Thesis Submitted to Department of Construction Engineering National Kaohsiung First University of Science and Technology In Partial

Public Projects A Thesis Submitted to Department of Construction Engineering National Kaohsiung First University of Science and Technology In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of Master