untitled

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "untitled"

弹皎伏
4 years ago
Views:

1 羅論林羅了律兩羅年論 A theory of Justice 1 切不了 Political Liberalism 2 來念論降識度連不羅 justice as fairness 利聯 3 不 1995 年理羅論 4 論羅 1 John Rawls, A Theory of Justice, rev. ed. (Cambridge, Mass.: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1999, original ed. 1971), hereafter TJ. 2 John Rawls, Political Liberalism (New York: Columbia University Press, 1996, original ed. 1993), hereafter PL. 3 例 1983 Moral Consciousness and Communicative Action 來 Jürgen Habermas, Moral Consciousness and Communicative Action, trans. C. Lenhardt and S. W. Nicholsen (Cambridge, Mass.: The MIT Press, 1990), pp Jürgen Habermas, Reconciliation Through the Public Use of Reason: Remarks on John Rawls s 1

2 羅 Journal of Philosophy 了 Reply to Habermas 5 兩論參羅 2001 年 6 便若倫理 discourse ethics 理律 autonomy 若諾理羅論理律律 political autonomy 異兩異羅羅論律念行理立律念律羅理論不羅 project 羅行羅立立降了說力 RPL, 羅論立 thought-experimentfj, 17 行理行良列羅 Political Liberalism, The Journal of Philosophy 92, no. 3 (Mar. 1995): ; hereafter RPL. 5 年來 1996 年 PL RH. 6 John Rawls, Justice as Fairness: A Restatement, ed. Erin Kelly (Cambridge, Mass.: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2001), hereafter JF. 羅 2002 年念 1958 年 Justice as Fairness TJ Samuel Freeman, ed., John Rawls Collected Paper (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1999), pp

3 來參 veil of ignorance 狀 original position 路 device of representation TJ, 55-56; FJ, 17 7 立論歷來羅 Rawls industry 聯來立 8 狀羅律 full autonomy 律 political autonomy 狀律兩立理利了力律狀律兩 moral person the sense of justice the conception of the good 力理利練狀理不狀若理 rational egoism 理論 decision-theory 利例利羅利 primary goods 了利利狀利利利羅利倫理里論路不 7 羅說抛力力不狀見 JF, 6 8 來 RPL 了不 3

4 律來利理論利 being exercisedbe enjoyed 利不類利 RPL, 利利利不 possessed 利羅了 obligatory norms 論 preferred value 論什行什兩利 fair value 利羅不 10 羅利利論利利不 RPL, 116 羅不狀留羅狀立倫理不論參理 9 They cannot be assimilated to distributive goods without forfeiting their deontological meaning. 10 羅兩 1971, 1999, 年 71 年 2001 年了列兩羅 1971 年 (1) 度利 (2) 不 (a) 利理 (b) TJ, 年 (1) 不利 (2) 不兩 (a) (b) 不利 JF, 13 4

5 理連理 we-perspective 利 RPL, 117 羅狀了兩沈論更理不理念論識理念羅 80 年不識論識 overlapping consensus 11 理念不識論識 (1) 識理論說 (2) 羅理 reasonable 12 度兩羅理念律念 11 羅說識說立識識說理論 JF, 羅說來利來行不利量行理 the rational 行若不不理 the unreasonable 行樂理行 JF, 6-7 5

6 立異識裡論立不羅理論論 pluralism 狀狀論識論度 peaceful institutionalization 論了羅了 question of stability question of justification 狀兩羅來羅更 acceptability acceptance 說識論論立識論連識說 comprehensive doctrines 立 RPL, 122 識論連不句理 rational obligatoriness 立羅識理念說來理句不羅論 moral realism 句說 13 羅了利理識論羅不理不不理 13 論不說 comprehensive doctrine 不若說說若論 vale pluralism 不 Rawls 理論 reasonable pluralism 理論理 JF, 4ff 6

7 什羅利理 question of justice or moral question 理理羅利倫理 ethical question 什什說倫理羅什羅不念理論理論了不理列不句更不說 postmetaphysical thinking RPL, 126 律律羅論羅 substantive normative assumptions 識念論識論立略 proceduralist program 論參理理論行理論不羅論念說 liberties of the moderns 論識利 liberties of the ancients 參利盧律律羅利降了 7

8 律說羅理論 theoretical 不立利類了度來羅例兩兩不領參利利領領 a prepolitical domain of liberties 律 legal regulation 論說不羅來立什利例立立 legitimacy 說立行列參羅羅不立兩說說兩理行理論狀羅不論論理參行 virtues 理 intelligence 論理羅論倫理異 8

9 不念 (a) 度度度度 (b) 不說說說來說說聯不說類 (c) 理念例理念理理理念律歷切了念立羅列列識羅識兩來念連來念 pro tanto full 理念念說理理不理便念理念說念說 9

10 念念理念說來留聯念不不理念理念理念理識理念理理念理念理念理說來念理了 PL, 385ff 理理說說念便了識羅兩不識理念來識理念來利力數識理念理念理念利理念不識理念羅理識理念念立來念不說 VS. 羅例理念了羅理念念不說例念不 10

11 不羅不量度度理度歷度理念羅臨兩兩兩不不利論不類度不律不利利利力來不立若便說律不論律不律利說立律不裡臨兩兩羅說兩裡不律論律不來利論 11

12 羅兩領論兩倫理理羅狀不說不羅理兩律律兩不臨兩來論參理度 transcendental necessity 羅論論兩度不說倫理羅說說不不切說識論路念利羅立 value-free 說不識來立度論 Rawls 不識了利識識識 12

了立連立量領來例蘭便不數不論更更更力更參例來例見量度量量參論量行量量瑩理來錄量量不力省力立力量量量了量便錄錄錄料說省 6

了立連立量領來例蘭便不數不論更更更力更參例來例見量度量量參論量行量量瑩理來錄量量不力省力立力量量量了量便錄錄錄料說省 6 量領力不參劣說更省量量省狀切領量例類說留見省良料錄立料省力念了省良練理流論 5 了立連立量領來例蘭便不數不論更更更力更參例來例見量度量量參論量行量量瑩理來錄量量不力省力立力量量量了量便錄錄錄料說省 6 說量力量